2-4 is great. JFA is mostly bad. JFA is better than AJ. GSC wasn't bad throughout; what the hell?
The point of picking Not Guilty for the second option is pure schadenfreude. You're not picking Not Guilty because you actually care about getting the Not Guilty verdict (if you are, then yeah, you're doing it wrong); you're picking Not Guilty to really rub Engarde's nose in it. To go "You want that Not Guilty verdict so bad that you're willing to do all that and hurt so many people? Then fine; take it, and reap what you sew." It's like the difference between saying "YOU LOSE" and forcing the loser to admit they lost.
--
Ace Detective in Sir Chris' Police
http://i1189.photobucket.com/albums/z430/RadLink5/valdez.gif