LogFAQs > #901999348

That's just dumb. I've looked at his stats before and I can't really contextualize them too well but I remember comparing him year to year to like Sidney Crosby or whoever I knew to be good at the time and thinking like oh he had 8x as many goals as Crosby does when he was his age.

In baseball it's all completely disputed all the time. There are too many factors that get people riled up (PEDs primarily but Ruth didn't play against non whites for example) but the one thing I can think of is that Pedro Martinez at his peak was the best pitcher who ever lived. You'll get some love for peak Sandy Koufax and Kershaw had momentum for a minute there but really Pedro is the only reasonable stance to take for GOAT peak