LogFAQs > #905779171

So. I've been thinking.

I was trying to operate under the assumption that one of Nana/Scare and Ashe is scum, since it's a decently likely chance that at least one of the top targets of the past few days is scum, and...

So let's look at the world of what happens when Ashe is town. The three people who voted him day 1, Tony, Sultan, and Red, never voted either of Nana and Star. Tony is additionally listed as casting no votes yesterday, while Sultan's in the interesting spot of voting for Nana/Scare yesterday. If one of the two is scum, that speaks well for Sultan. Red, on the other hand, voted only for the top two lynches of the day yesterday, though one of the major voters for him becomes Scare. That would be odd, all things considered. But we don't have to assume that, not necessarily...

More interestingly, though, if Ashe is town, then we had a town/town lynch yesterday in which five players did not vote: ColZach, who we know is town, plus Tony, PJ, Fake, and Ashe himself. We've assumed that Ashe is town, which suggests that the remaining three demand to be looked into.

Tony both voted for and was voted by one of my predecessors, while his only other vote was on Ashe. Yet he did not see need to vote for Ashe d2. Tony, mind explaining this?

PJ voted a lot d1, including ultimately being the deciding vote for Star. Yet d2, besides a rescinded vote for Chris, there's no activity on the log. PJ, mind explaining this?

Fake voted for Nana/Scare d1 (who also voted for them), which (if I'm right here) is more evidence that they're actually town if Ashe is town, but then never cast a vote yesterday, not even for Nana. Same question to you then, Fake: Explain please.

(tl;dr: ashe town seems to imply the worlds with Scare as town are more likely, with the actions of three non-voters d2 standing out, especially Tony's)
---

Nonsense. "Testing" is for when you're still guessing--and now, I have no need to guess. -- Agatha, Girl Genius