LogFAQs > #923674251

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Question for the crowd: How likely is it that Luis in topic two tells scum buddy red "darn, Red stole my thunder on Pez."

How many of Pez and Red are MORE likely to be scum based off this interaction? #136 Luis post there for the record.

Below is the quote you're talking about

You think that's a Mafia/Mafia interaction?

I mean, you know my thoughts on Red so probably

Should note that about half of the players never talk about or interacted with Luis, and Luis didn't interact with them

But Red is probably one of those players that you can't just ignore, even if it's your teammate

I'll look for any further Red interactions

Luis_Sera Posted...
You have no idea how disappointed I am to read through all those overnight posts only to have red steal my thunder right at the end. At least partly.

To elaborate, I don't think pez "SK hunting" is sufficient on it's own for me to think he's scum. People can have skewed perspectives. What irked me was his justification for thinking so. red just highlighted it but I think his reasoning is backwards. In a 17 player game I assume 5 scum unless given reason to believe otherwise. A SK doesn't (or shouldn't) fit in 17 because 5+1 SK means town has under two thirds numbers, and 4+1 means the mafia is under 25%. Assuming then, 5 scum, when increasing that to 21 players, without throwing off the balance, the natural course of action would be adding 3 town and 1 scum. I just don't see how you look at that, biased perspective or not, and immediately suspect the addition of an SK unless you know more than you're letting on. No-one is that one-track.