LogFAQs > #936634708

I like Undertale a lot, but it is absolutely not in the conversation for "Greatest of All Time", and all the voters who at the time said "nono, we're voting for it because we honestly feel it's the best thing ever" have been exposed now it seems. I think I said this when it lost the GotY poll so badly but people responded by saying "it doesn't matter, it's just a stupid GotY poll". But this was a contest just like the one it won and it lost in R1 to "Octopath Traveller". I mean, yikes, is it anybody's number 1 game of all time now?

Bandwagons are fine - god knows the vast majority of us liked L-Block - but I was told by its fans that Undertale's rally was more than that, legitimate and heartfelt, born of a genuine passion for the game to be "rightly" deemed the "Best Game Ever". But where is that passion now? Is it possible that Undertale is just exactly what it seemed - a right-place, right-time cult hit that doesn't actually, long-term, belong in that upper echelon of games?

---

Not to be confused with XIII_Stones.