LogFAQs > #943681750

HB Adrian Peterson - Yes

Is this one even debatable?

HB Cornell Brockington - No

We seem to see a lot of HB's at the mid-high 4.0 YPC for their career so to be sub 4 is always going to be a negative when it comes to HoF. Yes, he is an extremely high end pass catching (maybe the best?) but so is Courtney Lewis and his YPC is considerably better. Maybe I've been blessed by having a HB who doesn't fumble often but his fumble figures look high too. It also doesn't look great that he has no post season awards to his name.

HB Courtney Lewis - No

I honestly want to say yes but he just doesn't have enough counting stats due to lack of playing time. I don't think you can be a HoF based on 3 elite seasons and 2 very good seasons shortened seasons. He probably needed another 2 seasons as a starter under his belt to get the yes from me.

WR Mark Clayton - Yes

Like Peterson I don't think this is even debatable.

WR Roddy White - Yes

Like KCF I'm on the fence. I think he's borderline and it really depends on what WR numbers start looking at over the next few seasons worth of retirements. I think in general WR quality has declined since earlier seasons. Maybe now that the higher end WRs are starting to age out of the league that will change but I think White's numbers will hold up for a while because it will take us some time to develop WRs back up again. If he got another shot at this at a later date my vote would be no but since he only gets one shot I'm erring on the side of caution and voting yes.

TE Dominique Byrd - No

I think he's a borderline case similar to White. However unlike White whose numbers will hold up, I think we will get quite a few of the current crop of TEs to surpass his numbers. I feel like if he had a few more TDs to his name I'd be saying yes. It seems the good TEs typically get 4-5+ TDs a season and he's on the low end. I think he's like 50 yards a season and 0.7 ish TDs a season shy of being HoF worthy.

RT George Foster - Yes

His block/sack ratio is really good and so is his career block average. The fact that he also has multiple post season awards to his name just strengthens his case.

RG Brandon Moore - No

I don't think his numbers are going to hold up. His block/sack ratio is certainly above average but we have seen some interior O-linemen put up faur gaudier ratios. Even his block numbers aren't that great. ~40 a season is probably about average. I think it's going to be tough for interior O-linemen to get in because there's going to be people that put up 50-60+ blocks a season, there's going to be people who have like 7-8+ ratios and there's going to be people who play 16-17 seasons so have high career numbers. Moore doesn't tick a single one of those boxes.