LogFAQs > #943682188

LE Abdul Hodge - No

No. He just doesn't have the counting stats for it. It's going to be a similar case to Lewis where being very good at the back end of your career just doesn't make up for not playing for a ton of years at the start. I suspect run blockers are always going to struggle to get in even if they play their entire career, nevermind half of it. They are basically going to need a ton of pro bowls to their name.

DT LeKevin Smith - Yes

He seems to be a fringe candidate in a position that will become hard to evalute. Those sack number averages across an entire career are impressive enough for me to say yes though

MLB Lofa Tatupu - Yes

At first glance I was going to say his sack numbers look low (which they do) but his INT / FF / FR numbers make up for it. He seems to be a high end disruptor. I do think a few years down the line, we will see quite a few people surpass his numbers providing they stay healthy but as of right now you can't really argue with where he is against the league and his post season accolades

12. MLB Gerris Wilkinson - No

He just doesn't quite have the numbers for me especially when compared to Lofa Tatupu. I think he's a good MLB but not HoF worthy

CB Adam Jones - Yes

I have no idea how to gauge CBs but comparing against my own ragtag bunch of misfits (who aren't very good), 31 INTs for a career seems really high.

SS Thomas Davis - No

SS'es tend to be stat stuffers and I just don't think he quite has the numbers beyond tackles. Compared to both the SSes I've utilized during my time in the league his Tackles are about the same and his Sacks, FF, FR, INTs are all below what they both on a season average basis. Now granted it's slightly unfair because these guys were starting so they don't have injuries or playing backup to drag those numbers down since they are both over 4 season sample sizes each. However, neither of them are winning awards and I don't think they made the candidates list. So there has to be a lot of better SS'es out there.

SS Michael Huff - No

Similar to the above. I just don't think he has the counting stats in a position that generally puts up impressive numbers.