LogFAQs > #943699415

1. HB Adrian Peterson No But really it's a "yes" from me
Spite vote for being such a thorn in my side for so long!

2. HB Cornell Brockington - No
KCF said he was a better version of Cedric Benson. Anyone getting compared to Cedric Benson is gonna be an automatic no from me!

3. HB Courtney Lewis Yes
Ive wavered on this a couple times now. While the numbers arent there I dont think well see another running back as efficient as Lewis which to me adds to his case for hall eligibility. While he doesnt have the counting stats, he does have a Pro Bowl to his name and like KCF listed, was nominated for several key awards. And I think he definitely helped elevate Minnesota in the time that he was there finally get to and win the big game.

4. WR Mark Clayton Yes
WR winning an MVP, nothing more needs to be said really.

5. WR Roddy White Yes
As KCF and Shattered said, this is probably borderline but I think once we see all these elite WRs retire, were going to have a sharp drop off in WR production. Weve seen it every couple of years actually, where only a couple receivers manage to break 1000 yards. So Im going to hedge my bets here and say that White is going to be better than some of the younger WRs coming up with a few exceptions.

6. TE Dominique Byrd No
Its going to be really hard for a TE to get into the league cause they really arent a big part of the offense in this particular game. Off the top of my head there is only one TE that has stood out to me as being Hall worthy and Byrd is not the one Im thinking of.

7. RT George Foster - Yes
Allowing six or fewer sacks a season for 13 seasons is absurd.

8. RG Brandon Moore No
KCF and Shattered laid it out pretty well here.

9. LE Abdul Hodge No
REVENGE IS SWEET! Maybe if he had opted to take the money and a starter roll playing for the Titans instead of signing as a backup with the Washington Football Team, he would have had better counting stats! Of course, maybe Hodge knew something we all didnt and that I am cursed to forever be a miserable GM. Its still a no from me though.

10. DT LeKevin Smith

11. MLB Lofa Tatupu Yes
Other than being not a great sack producer, I dunno what more you could ask from him. Easy yes.

12. MLB Gerris Wilkinson No
Hall of Fame name but not a Hall of Fame player.

13. CB Adam Jones - Yes
While those INT numbers are indeed great, those tackle numbers are pretty great as well for a CB. Nearly 19 a season? Seems great to me! And managing to stay above an 80 OVR for nonpowerhouse teams like the Chiefs and Panthers is pretty great too.

14. SS Thomas Davis No
Honestly was going to vote yes for his cumulative totals but his averages were yeah just average. No real dips and having one big high I guess does not do it for me though.

15. SS Michael Huff No
Same situation as Davis.