LogFAQs > #973206112

Scholar of the First Sin does make some parts of the game more linear, particularly access to the DLC. That's probably my biggest gripe with Scholar in particular. Vanilla DS2 gives you the keys to open the DLC doors in your starting inventory, but in Scholar they moved the keys to different locations, requiring you to go pick them up after clearing specific sections of the game -- instead of only needing to go to the DLC door of your choice.

I'd still recommend Scholar overall. Better framerate, and it adds content that makes the story feel more complete. Plus, the remixed enemy placements are controversial with some people, but I personally think they are better. It forces you to be cautious and play well - something that is more true to the spirit of DeS and Dark Souls. Vanilla DS2 you could be reckless or make mistakes and still be fine most of the time.