LogFAQs > #980221288

I don't think I've ever played the notorious jank from the Atari era, so I'll pick Superman 64 as a safe answer. I had no idea it was trash when I rented it, and boy oh boy, imagine going from Ocarina of Time to that. Decades later, however, I'm glad I experienced such a "landmark" game before it became so well known.

My personal most disappointing and offensive game, though, is probably Silent Hill Homecoming.