LogFAQs > #980266115

Honestly, I'm at a bit of a loss. Everyone I had scum suspicions of ended up looking better on reread. Death was one of them, where I saw his first couple of posts from Day 1 and was like, "Either scum Death has learned to become hella less passive or this is town Death."

Ctes was one person I initially had suspicion on upon reread. There was a point where he brought up the idea that, if Taco was scum, then somebody who played in Baseball Musical Mafia was also likely to be scum. Way later into the day, I brought up that same point, and then Ctes went back on his original statement by saying (effectively) "it means nothing since it includes almost the entire game". So I thought that was odd.

But then he was the first person to point out the flaw in Knightz' claim that there was nothing in his PM about why Luis Guzman is Vanilla... and then Knightz later provided justification for why Luis is Vanilla. And I think that was a pretty early post before Knightz started gaining some serious traction.

MI is one player I couldn't get a solid grasp of even on reread. And I don't remember what conclusions I made from an SBell reread, if I made any at all.

And I also completely forgot about Ulti. It's a bit strange that everyone has just seemed to put him in town without much discussion, but, well, I'm coming to the same conclusions of Death and Ctes being town, so I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt here and assume he's legit.

Blade... I think my opinion of him will be heavily affected by Corrik. Otherwise, I have no grasp on him, though I never did a reread either.

And of course, Ben is either an Oscar award winning scum... or he's town. I don't need a reread to remember all of the incredible towny posts he's made.

So TL;DR: my PoE is narrowed down to Corrik, Red, Peaf, SBell, and MI. Tentatively Blade depending on how Corrik flips. Death, Ctes, and Ben are out of my PoE, and Ulti could potentially go back in, but he's firmly out for until I have reason to believe otherwise.