LogFAQs > #980385086

So I just realized something.

If Death flips town, that means IGCD was protected last night, yeah? Because my jail didn't stop the nightkill.

That would mean Ben and Ctes are highly unlikely to have exactly one scum between them. Think about it. Ben and Ctes both agreed that IGCD would likely draw protection last night, and that's information they shared with us, right?

Let's assume one of them is town and would have no reason to lie about that discussion. If the other was scum, they could have very easily directed the kill to someone else besides IGCD, knowing that he was very likely to be doc protected. However, if Death is town, we know IGCD was shot, which means scum Ben or scum Ctes didn't direct the shot somewhere else despite acknowledging that IGCD was the obvious doc target.

This means one of two things: either Ben and Ctes are both scum pulling theater (unlikely) or they're both town, contingent on Death flips town. If exactly one of them were scum, they wouldn't have shot at IGCD. Of course, if Death flips scum, none of that holds true, but who cares? We'd have dead scum.

I really think killing Death really is the optimal play here. We could potentially get three town clears off of his flip.