Final Fantasy X - 9.4/10 Final Fantasy XII - 5.3/10 Suikoden III - Note to self: play this eventually. Suikoden V - 9.2/10 Persona 3 - 8.2/10 Persona 4 - 9.9/10 Shadow Hearts - ...Why did I lose my memory card. Shadow Hearts 2 - :( Disgaea - 7.5/10
Final Fantasy X - 9.5 Final Fantasy XII - 4 Suikoden III - 3 Suikoden V - 5.5 Disgaea - 7.5
You can mostly discard my Suikoden ratings though I didn't have the patience to get more than like 10 hours into either one. Might get back to em though.
-- No problem! This is a cute and pop genocide of love!
Final Fantasy X - 9 Final Fantasy XII - 7 Suikoden III - 5 Suikoden V - 6 Persona 3 - 10 Persona 4 - 7 Shadow Hearts - 10 Shadow Hearts 2 - 9 Disgaea - 7
Final Fantasy X- 9.5 Final Fantasy XII- 4, the lowest score you'll see me give a Final Fantasy game Suikoden III- Haven't played Suikoden V- Haven't played, again Persona 3- 8.5 Persona 4- Haven't played since I can't find it anywhere Shadow Hearts- 9 Shadow Hearts 2- Haven't started playing yet Disgaea- Haven't played
--
I bring order and chaos, I am life and death, creator and destroyer, just like the rest of humanity. My bunnyslug: http://img.imgcake.com/nio/catapngzu.png
Final Fantasy X - 7/10 Final Fantasy XII - 6/10 Suikoden III - 6/10 Suikoden V - 6/10 Persona 3 - n/a (only played it on the PSP, so if that counts, 9/10) Persona 4 - 10/10 Shadow Hearts - n/a Shadow Hearts 2 - n/a Disgaea - 6/10
These are easily the 3 best from your list. I recommend adding Dragon Quest 8 and Valkyrie Profile 2 to your list, since that would complete the top 5 on the PS2.
--
Tornadoman78: tornadoman and tornadogirl like to kick box each other in my tornaolayzers and she dosent even mind getting hit
Final Fantasy X - 9/10 Final Fantasy XII - 6/10 Suikoden III - 7/10 Suikoden V - 10/10 Persona 3 - 9/10 Persona 4 - 10/10 Shadow Hearts - 5/10 Shadow Hearts 2 - 6/10 Disgaea - 9/10
--
See You In Another Life, Brother. God, too busy to help the broncos on Sundays, gave them Manning
Final Fantasy X - 8 Final Fantasy XII - 4 Suikoden III - 8 Suikoden V - 9 Persona 3 - 9 Persona 4 - 10 Shadow Hearts - 7 Shadow Hearts 2 - 9 Disgaea - 7.5
Final Fantasy X - 9.5/10 Final Fantasy XII - 6/10 Suikoden III - Haven't played it Suikoden V - Haven't played it Persona 3 - 10/10 Persona 4 - 9/10 Shadow Hearts - 7.5/10 Shadow Hearts 2 - Haven't played it Disgaea - Haven't played it
--
"THIS is how you make Nintendo win another generation. Good job, Sony and Microsoft, you're idiots." - Vlado
Final Fantasy X - 9 Final Fantasy XII - 8 Suikoden III - 7 Suikoden V - 7 Persona 3 - 9 Persona 4 - 10 Shadow Hearts - 5 Shadow Hearts 2 - 9 Disgaea - 5
-- I'm no longer a Nadal supporter. Andy Murray is my new favorite player/person. -Princess Anri
Final Fantasy X - 10 Final Fantasy XII - 5 Suikoden III - 7 Suikoden V - 6 Persona 3 - 9 Persona 4 - 10 Shadow Hearts - 8 Shadow Hearts 2 - 9 Disgaea - 9
Final Fantasy X - 9.5/10 Final Fantasy XII 8.5/10 Suikoden III 4/10 Suikoden V haven't played Persona 3 9/10 Persona 4 9.5/10 Shadow Hearts never played Shadow Hearts 2 never played Disgaea 8/10
Final Fantasy X - 9.5 Final Fantasy XII - 9 Suikoden III - 8.5 Suikoden V - 9 Persona 3 - 8.5 Persona 4 - 10 Shadow Hearts - 8 Shadow Hearts 2 - 8.75 Disgaea - 9.5
-- http://www.facebook.com/zerosignal The photograph reflects, every streetlight a reminder; nightswimming deserves a quiet night
Final Fantasy X: 9.5 Final Fantasy XII: 4 Suikoden III: 9 Suikoden V: 8.5 Persona 3: 8.5 (P3P gets a 9.5) Persona 4: 9.5 Shadow Hearts: 9 Shadow Hearts 2: 9 Disgaea: 7.5
I'm normally a harsh rater, but there are too many great games here!