Board 8 > Chrono Trigger Mafia Topic 2: My Dear Old Wife Made That Lunch For Me.

(+) Yeah! (+)

<cite>VeryInsane posted [p:875138953] in Chrono Tri... [t:75114324]...</cite> <quote> </quote>

In answer to My Immortal regarding my suspicion of edwards.

eaedwards6400 posted...

Oddity posted...

I'm willing to believe the miller claim for now, then.

eadwards, you around? What do you think of the miller claim? Of me?

I hate Miller claims. It makes me feel like scum gets the ability to be focused on by role players.

As for you, I have had enough time to read everything yet so I do not have an opinion of you yet.

Didn't particularly like this answer he gave me. Wasn't willing to give an opinion on me even though there was little to read at that time. After that I haven't seen anything that stands out to me as town.
---

[2] JC - dowolf, Corrik
[1] dowolf - plum
[1] eaed - Han
[1] Han - (Ulti), eaed
[1] Oddity - (Tony), prof
[1] pj - (IGCD), Shad
[1] prof - Ulti
[1] red - Puns
[1] Ulti - (Kanz), IGCD
[0] MI - (Puns)
[0] Se7en - (prof)

With 19 alive, it takes 10 to lynch. Day Ends on Thursday, March 16 2017 at 10 PM EDT

Should be correct but lol phone votals
---

current score of 5 VS3
well if its 5 scummembers then we have the scumteam already

My Immortal posted...

htaeD posted...

good enough that I cant even remember if he was scum recently

I actually haven't been scum in quite a while.

ah
yeah this question definitely comes up every game, I do remember that
---

htaeD posted...

current score of 5 VS3
well if its 5 scummembers then we have the scumteam already

My Immortal posted...

htaeD posted...

good enough that I cant even remember if he was scum recently

I actually haven't been scum in quite a while.

ah
yeah this question definitely comes up every game, I do remember that

What
---

its a joke about the poll
---

What kind of monster would eat the old man's lunch?
---

Oh
---

But I was hungryyyyy....
---

I genuinely don't remember the sandwich
---

I am wary of Kanz for not buddying with me.
---

Chaeix posted...

I genuinely don't remember the sandwich

It wasn't explicitly a sandwich I don't think. You can eat random food in the Millenial Fair and then when the trial starts you can get slammed for it.
---

Oddity posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Oddity posted...

I'm willing to believe the miller claim for now, then.

eadwards, you around? What do you think of the miller claim? Of me?

I hate Miller claims. It makes me feel like scum gets the ability to be focused on by role players.

As for you, I have had enough time to read everything yet so I do not have an opinion of you yet.

Didn't particularly like this answer he gave me. Wasn't willing to give an opinion on me even though there was little to read at that time. After that I haven't seen anything that stands out to me as town.

I honestly don't even really understand his reasoning because of poor grammar, what in particular don't you like about it?
---

The miller thing I'm kind of meh about. But that second part where he didn't give an opinion of me felt like a 'safe' option to me. I didn't feel like there was that much to read and I was posting a lot of questions for the beginning of it. Felt there should have been some sort of commentary or something. It's not a strong scum read by any means, he's just a suspect.
---

Btw Oddity I wasn't really upset. You asked me if I had any opinions, I said yes, then you didn't ask me what they were.

I was ready to give them :(
---

Hah, I figured you would just evade the answer, so I guess I screwed up on that one.
---

What are some opinions you have btw?
---

I can explain that thought process if you would like, JC. The large problem was I was trying to catch up on my way home from SmackDown last night.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I am wary of Kanz for not buddying with me.

I remember my mistakes from Hearthstone maf Han

Not paying close attention to you and valuing your reasoning appropriately was one of them

That doesn't mean I'm just gonna follow blindly tho!
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Btw Oddity I wasn't really upset. You asked me if I had any opinions, I said yes, then you didn't ask me what they were.

I was ready to give them :(

...
erh

doesnt this go without saying?
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

I can explain that thought process if you would like, JC. The large problem was I was trying to catch up on my way home from SmackDown last night.

Yeah sure, I don't think it's super relevant any more and probably not big in the grand scheme of things but never hurts.
---

Nah, he's right. I took it serious even though I should have known better.
---

I can give better answers in 2 hours. Teaching now.

Kanz, I was town in hearthstone
---

I feel like if scum claims miller they could potentially be a target for any scanners or watchers if they are scum. They often feel like they get a free pass too. I think someone even said it in the first topic that PJ once made it to day 5 because he claimed miller as scum.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I can give better answers in 2 hours. Teaching now.

Kanz, I was town in hearthstone

...Yes? And I just said 'I was wrong not to trust Han in hearthstone once he explained his reasoning cause he was totally right about Ulti'.
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

I feel like if scum claims miller they could potentially be a target for any scanners or watchers if they are scum. They often feel like they get a free pass too. I think someone even said it in the first topic that PJ once made it to day 5 because he claimed miller as scum.

Why would a watcher watch someone they think is scum?
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

I feel like if scum claims miller they could potentially be a target for any scanners or watchers if they are scum. They often feel like they get a free pass too. I think someone even said it in the first topic that PJ once made it to day 5 because he claimed miller as scum.

why would a scanner scan a miller claim?

why would a scumteam have the guy with the believed miller claim send in the kill, risking the claim?
---

dowolf posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

I feel like if scum claims miller they could potentially be a target for any scanners or watchers if they are scum. They often feel like they get a free pass too. I think someone even said it in the first topic that PJ once made it to day 5 because he claimed miller as scum.

why would a scanner scan a miller claim?

why would a scumteam have the guy with the believed miller claim send in the kill, risking the claim?

Not sure why I focused on the watcher aspect there.
---

Shaduln posted...

dowolf posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

I feel like if scum claims miller they could potentially be a target for any scanners or watchers if they are scum. They often feel like they get a free pass too. I think someone even said it in the first topic that PJ once made it to day 5 because he claimed miller as scum.

why would a scanner scan a miller claim?

why would a scumteam have the guy with the believed miller claim send in the kill, risking the claim?

Not sure why I focused on the watcher aspect there.

It was all dumb, you just picked the part that stood out as dumbest to you
---

Mayhaps it is bigger in the grand scheme of things
---

why did eaed say anything in that post at all
---

the question is

does dumb = scum
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

I can explain that thought process if you would like, JC. The large problem was I was trying to catch up on my way home from SmackDown last night.

Let's not forget the other really bad eaed post here -- why wouldn't you just provide your thought process? Why would you say you could and not? It just seems like he's hoping that it gets forgotten and he won't have to.
---

Chaeix posted...

the question is

does dumb = scum

if only. this game would be so much easier.
---

I don't think a scanner would waste it as much as a watcher. In case the scum team was dumb enough to send the claimed miller out for the night kill.
---

Oh, you seem to be confusing watcher with tracker?
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

I don't think a scanner would waste it as much as a watcher. In case the scum team was dumb enough to send the claimed miller out for the night kill.

Odd turn of phrase. Either way, you consider it a waste?

...What is your end goal here? Are you trying to get scanners to waste uses on PJ?
---

What role is which?
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

I don't think a scanner would waste it as much as a watcher. In case the scum team was dumb enough to send the claimed miller out for the night kill.

I will be honest I would have preferred an answer of "oh I guess I didn't think that through" here because the initial thought seemed poorly thought out and a little misguided. This seems like it's trying really hard to explain it away
---

No, just saying I hate Millers.
---

What
---

Hey guys I think eaed hates millers.
---

honest question: has eaed said anything all game other than "I hate millers"?

because I am drawing a blank.
---

Noted: Ead has watcher fear.
---

This chain of posts confuses me. *Scratches head*

Why even bother with all this pointless meta? Scanning millers is dumb unless you're like, detective or whatever. Sending in kills through the miller is dumb unless town thinks he's super confirmed or you're pulling off a mindgame you feel confident about. Why so much overthinking?
---

dowolf posted...

honest question: has eaed said anything all game other than "I hate millers"?

because I am drawing a blank.

And got defense when Han called him scum.
---

That's just the way I think. I'm a programmer irl I tend to try and think of every possible scenario of how someone could break what I have programmed. It is that kind of overthinking that has caused me to make mistakes at my new job.
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

I think someone even said it in the first topic that PJ once made it to day 5 because he claimed miller as scum.

lol what game was that?

But also was it because I claimed miller that I survived that long?
---

pj, you got any suspects?
---

Pj when is the last time you didn't survive until endgame?
---