Board 8 > Chrono Trigger Mafia Topic 9: All life begins with Nu and ends with Nu...

(+) Yeah! (+)

This is the truth!
This is my belief!
...At least for now

You all saw nothing.
---

[1] Corrik - red
[1] dowolf - JC
[1] JC - Corrik
[0] prof - (Corrik)
[0] eaed - (prof)

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Day ends on Tuesday, March 28 2017, at 11 PM EDT, or when a majority is reached.

a half an hour left
---

f***.

Also VI you still have a 1 in my vote rather than the 0 you should
---

dat 1 second ninja

bng_mmmk posted...

red13n posted...

f*** it since the cats out of the bag. I am Robo Town BP.

But if JC made the gambit of claiming a doc save good for him. Especially with my going after the guy that scum would know was SK when I went after him. But it would be ballsy as s*** to make that gambit and then risk running into a claim of me being BP. So I'm not buying that right now. If he did it, good for him.

!!!!

OK so really though? Like I was driving to work this morning thinking about how your play was so town but your actions made no sense and then it clicked and I was OH f***.

What makes you say "my going after the guy that scum would know as SK"?

---

Chaeix posted...

A) dowolf hasn't even claimed yet man

nuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu i haven't claimed yet nuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

>_>

(it's funny because I was literally refusing to claim because I didn't want scum to catch onto red being bp, since red being BP was literally the only way Red's actions make a lick of sense.)

but now he's claimed. In the final half-hour of the day. Flipping everything on its head. Okay.

We now have zero reason to throw JC in the 100% town pile. How does this change things.
---

Dowolf claim or I am voting you.
---

How fast did Jc respond he saved red. Or did oddity basically give him that claim.because he assumed jc did it.
---

Actually.

##vote: Dowolf
##unvote:

To make my distate for you not claiming clear.
---

*distaste
---

JC was part of the Ulti vote pile

JC was part of the Seven vote pile.

JC was the opposite lynch to Seven.

This entire game makes perfect f***ing sense with JC scum. Everything fits together.

Every.

f***ing.

Thing.
---

profDEADPOOL posted...

Dowolf claim or I am voting you.

nuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
---

[1] Corrik - red
[1] dowolf - JC, (prof)
[1] JC - Corrik
[0] prof - (Corrik)
[0] eaed - (prof)

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Day ends on Tuesday, March 28 2017, at 11 PM EDT, or when a majority is reached.
---

dowolf posted...

JC was part of the Ulti vote pile

JC was part of the Seven vote pile.

JC was the opposite lynch to Seven.

This entire game makes perfect f***ing sense with JC scum. Everything fits together.

Every.

f***ing.

Thing.

i wish i was better at mafia so my ineptitude didn't end up getting used for accusations of me being scum
---

Corrik posted...

How fast did Jc respond he saved red. Or did oddity basically give him that claim.because he assumed jc did it.

JC said he trusts Red, Oddity says he gave JC a doc save, JC says he saved Red 2 minutes later.
---

Time to nut up or shut up.

##Vote: JC

Confident there will be no scum hammer here. Every. single. sign. points to JC being scum. Corrik is likely his teammate who tried to go for the win, saw it wouldn't happen, and caved before the eventual BP claim came out.

Holy s*** I'm pumped right now.
---

dowolf posted...

JC was part of the Ulti vote pile

JC was part of the Seven vote pile.

JC was the opposite lynch to Seven.

This entire game makes perfect f***ing sense with JC scum. Everything fits together.

Every.

f***ing.

Thing.

So vote with me. Cuz where do u think my vote is.
---

hey i know this is a wifom question but like

if i were scum why would i claim i used my doc save on bp

i could have literally claimed i used it on anyone and the scenario requires me to know red is bp from shooting him

why the f*** would i do that as scum?
---

[2] JC - Corrik, puns
[1] Corrik - red
[1] dowolf - JC, (prof)
[0] prof - (Corrik)
[0] eaed - (prof)

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Day ends on Tuesday, March 28 2017, at 11 PM EDT, or when a majority is reached.
---

Corrik posted...

So vote with me. Cuz where do u think my vote is.

I am being cautious.

But don't you worry.

We got this.
---

Chaeix posted...

if i were scum why would i claim i used my doc save on bp

You didn't, obviously. Tracker had died; you had no need to fear being called out on it.
---

Get the votes on Corrik please.
---

Oh it was one minute after JC said he trusts Red that Oddity said that.

And that trusting Red was JC's first post in the game.
---

JC being scum would make me look scummy unfortunately. However, batting 1000 on day 1. Woohoo
---

##vote: Corrik
---

dowolf posted...

Chaeix posted...

if i were scum why would i claim i used my doc save on bp

You didn't, obviously. Tracker had died; you had no need to fear being called out on it.

but if i was scum, i wouldn't use the doc save on the person i shot. i would just say i saved someone else and missed. i would still have the doc save and would know red was the bp. why would i claim i shot red?
---

bng_mmmk posted...

Confident there will be no scum hammer here.

I mean Corrik is scum so yeah there won't be regardless of JC's alignment.
---

[2] JC - Corrik, puns
[2] Corrik - red, prof
[1] dowolf - JC, (prof)
[0] prof - (Corrik)
[0] eaed - (prof)

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Day ends on Tuesday, March 28 2017, at 11 PM EDT, or when a majority is reached.
---

##Vote: Corrik

This sudden JC accusation stuff is really sudden, feels desperate
---

Chaeix posted...

but if i was scum, i wouldn't use the doc save on the person i shot. i would just say i saved someone else and missed. i would still have the doc save and would know red was the bp. why would i claim i shot red?

Yes. You did save someone else. Some scumbuddy. Presumably not God.

But when Red didn't die, you saw the opportunity to go for broke, and you took it.
---

I mean honestly they're both probably scum with my theory confirmed. Kinda like this situation because if I'm right it helps us draw conclusions in future days.
---

##Unvote

wait is that bad
---

dowolf posted...

Chaeix posted...

but if i was scum, i wouldn't use the doc save on the person i shot. i would just say i saved someone else and missed. i would still have the doc save and would know red was the bp. why would i claim i shot red?

Yes. You did save someone else. Some scumbuddy. Presumably not God.

But when Red didn't die, you saw the opportunity to go for broke, and you took it.

but that literally doesn't make sense

why would i claim to have saved the bp

i would be setting myself up for failure

i could have picked ANY OTHER PERSON
---

Chaeix posted...

dowolf posted...

Chaeix posted...

but if i was scum, i wouldn't use the doc save on the person i shot. i would just say i saved someone else and missed. i would still have the doc save and would know red was the bp. why would i claim i shot red?

Yes. You did save someone else. Some scumbuddy. Presumably not God.

But when Red didn't die, you saw the opportunity to go for broke, and you took it.

but that literally doesn't make sense

why would i claim to have saved the bp

i would be setting myself up for failure

i could have picked ANY OTHER PERSON

This is a dumb WIFOM thing that will never be resolved.
---

[2] Corrik - red, prof, (pj)
[2] JC - Corrik, puns
[1] dowolf - JC, (prof)
[0] prof - (Corrik)
[0] eaed - (prof)

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Day ends on Tuesday, March 28 2017 at 11 PM EDT, or when a majority is reached.
---

pjbasis posted...

##Unvote

wait is that bad

the fact corrik hasn't been scumhammered yet is pretty damning

i still want dowolf to claim before day's end though. i'll move to corrik when needed
---

Town BP is unlikely to claim it given the fact we've been in a deep f***ing hole since D2. I feel a little backward for forcing red's hand but it kinda cracks the game open so I feel vindicated.
---

Chaeix posted...

dowolf posted...

Chaeix posted...

if i were scum why would i claim i used my doc save on bp

You didn't, obviously. Tracker had died; you had no need to fear being called out on it.

but if i was scum, i wouldn't use the doc save on the person i shot. i would just say i saved someone else and missed. i would still have the doc save and would know red was the bp. why would i claim i shot red?

I actually bought this when I first read this just now. Then I realized... who else could you have claimed to save rhere rhat would have been believable
---

Corrik posted...

Chaeix posted...

dowolf posted...

Chaeix posted...

if i were scum why would i claim i used my doc save on bp

You didn't, obviously. Tracker had died; you had no need to fear being called out on it.

but if i was scum, i wouldn't use the doc save on the person i shot. i would just say i saved someone else and missed. i would still have the doc save and would know red was the bp. why would i claim i shot red?

I actually bought this when I first read this just now. Then I realized... who else could you have claimed to save rhere rhat would have been believable

everyone
---

Chaeix posted...

i could have picked ANY OTHER PERSON

because if you die and flip scum, guess where suspicion falls?

on the person you claimed to save.

on the person the scumteam knew was bulletproof.

check and mate. Now king me.
---

As I said, its a hell of a play if JC made it. But at that point, I don't expect scum to make a gambit because to them it looks like they have the game in hand. And this is why I've been saying, I'm putting a lot of faith in Oddity's read.
---

profDEADPOOL posted...

Chaeix posted...

dowolf posted...

Chaeix posted...

but if i was scum, i wouldn't use the doc save on the person i shot. i would just say i saved someone else and missed. i would still have the doc save and would know red was the bp. why would i claim i shot red?

Yes. You did save someone else. Some scumbuddy. Presumably not God.

But when Red didn't die, you saw the opportunity to go for broke, and you took it.

but that literally doesn't make sense

why would i claim to have saved the bp

i would be setting myself up for failure

i could have picked ANY OTHER PERSON

This is a dumb WIFOM thing that will never be resolved.

the problem is dowolf is using it as an argument and not a wifom discussion
---

Chaeix posted...

i still want dowolf to claim before day's end though.

...Was I not clear enough?
http://adiumxtras.com/images/pictures/chrono_trigger_nu_1_25369_7315_image_11364.png
dowolf posted...

nuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

---

... f*** you also Dowolf.

But that isn't a full claim so lets have it
---

pjbasis posted...

##Vote: Corrik

This sudden JC accusation stuff is really sudden, feels desperate

</3

Really were scum weren't you my good friend.

So my reads are totally changed now.

JC, Deadpool, Pjare scum
---

if you feel like you're being WIFOM'd, it doesn't mean the situation isn't solvable.

It means you're asking the wrong questions.

Now, I don't know what the right question for you is, because to me, this is super-simple. But we have ten minutes. Let's talk this through.
---

Oh. Nilla.

Thought that was obvious >_>
---

No one should talk to Dowolf until he full claims
---

red13n posted...

As I said, its a hell of a play if JC made it. But at that point, I don't expect scum to make a gambit because to them it looks like they have the game in hand. And this is why I've been saying, I'm putting a lot of faith in Oddity's read.

It's exactly the kind of play Ulti would make under the assumption that JC was going to die soon anyway. Buy him time and get deeper into the game revealing fewer scum.

It's not exactly a difficult maneuver considering he literally got gifted a save by an inventor.
---

... DAMMIT THAT NINJA.

In what way was it obvious.
---

Corrik posted...

pjbasis posted...

##Vote: Corrik

This sudden JC accusation stuff is really sudden, feels desperate

</3

Really were scum weren't you my good friend.

So my reads are totally changed now.

JC, Deadpool, Pjare scum

good thing all 3 of us are here, wasting our chance to scumhammer you and win the game

good game deadpool and pj we did it, now let's wait 5 more minutes before we scumhammer
---