Poll of the Day > Sony's new GAY Film is an OSCAR Contender that has a SEX Scene with a PEACH!!!

Topic List
Page List: 1, 2
mrduckbear
09/08/17 7:50:17 PM
#1:


Would you watch this movie?


Sony's upcoming film "Call Me By Your Name" starring 31 y/o Armie Hammer and 21 y/o newcomver Timothee Chamelet is getting major buzz after it screen to critics which has an astonishing 98% metacritic rating which could be Sony's first Oscar winning film!!

But there is also a controversial scene that has raised some eyebrows but hasn't lowered the quality of the film.

It's set in 1983 about 2 gay men in Italy on a 24 y/o man named Oliver and italian teen named Elio who is 17 and is based off of a novel..

But there is one scene in particular where one of them is having SEX with a PEACH..and the other eats the peach!!..this scene was in the novel as well

The Hollywood Reporter said "The handful of sex scenes are tastefully shot but short and not particularly explicit, though Aciman's famous peach scene is featured here in modest but ambiguous fashion"

Sony Pictures Classics will release the film on November 24th, just in time for Oscars voting..

It has a 98% tomatometer rating with 98% metacritic rating..

Would you watch this movie?

Call Me By Your Name -

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2017/09/08/16/440AFFC900000578-4865802-image-a-3_1504883737050.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2017/09/08/18/440B001100000578-4865802-Chamelet_and_Hammer_are_pictured_together_at_a_recent_screening_-m-4_1504891647455.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2017/09/08/18/440AFFB300000578-4865802-The_film_has_received_critical_acclaim_and_is_expecrted_to_be_a_-a-5_1504891655718.jpg

Peach -

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2017/09/08/16/440B470100000578-4865802-image-m-21_1504885828319.jpg
---
Every time a Gamefaqs User PROVES they Stepped on a Bug, i will STOP Posting for 24 Hours...Beware, this is NOT a good thing to do!!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Lokarin
09/08/17 7:51:04 PM
#2:


Well, it's harder than a pie...
---
"Salt cures Everything!"
My YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/Nirakolov/videos
... Copied to Clipboard!
Nade Duck
09/08/17 7:57:01 PM
#3:


i thought the mango was considered the gayest fruit.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
ClarkDuke
09/08/17 7:58:51 PM
#4:


... Copied to Clipboard!
magemaximus
09/08/17 8:00:53 PM
#5:


damn why did you put a nasty pic of a peach
---
You can't persuade fanboys. You'd be better off trying to convince a wall. ~CodeNamePlasmaSnake~
... Copied to Clipboard!
wwinterj25
09/08/17 8:04:46 PM
#6:


mrduckbear posted...
this scene was in the novel as well


I don't see the problem in that case.

mrduckbear posted...
Would you watch this movie?


Probably not. Gay love stories are not for me.
---
One who knows nothing can understand nothing.
http://psnprofiles.com/wwinterj - http://i.imgur.com/kDysIcd.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
madadude
09/08/17 8:04:56 PM
#7:


I already have seen it and it is an incredible movie, can't wait to see it again.

Timothee Chamelet deserves to win best actor for sure and Michael Stuhlbarg who plays his father deserves supporting actor. Armie Hammer is good too but not as good as Stuhlbarg.

Here is the trailer, which is a pretty good trailer for it I think:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z9AYPxH5NTM


It is a very beautiful and honest movie. Much better than Moonlight if we are comparing high profile LGBT films of the past few years (though Moonlight isn't bad don't get me wrong)
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
LaggnFragnLarry
09/08/17 8:06:13 PM
#8:


i will wait for the eventual all female reboot
... Copied to Clipboard!
FellWolf
09/08/17 8:27:54 PM
#9:


LaggnFragnLarry posted...
i will wait for the eventual all female reboot


She hS sex wita BAANAN
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
dedbus
09/08/17 8:46:06 PM
#10:


They need to lay off the American pie sequels.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Lokarin
09/08/17 8:55:27 PM
#11:


Y'know.... I can eat a peach for hours
---
"Salt cures Everything!"
My YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/Nirakolov/videos
... Copied to Clipboard!
helIy
09/08/17 9:41:03 PM
#12:


so?

american pie had a sex scene with a pie
---
depressed again
morning comes too fast and i'm tired of the routine
... Copied to Clipboard!
TheCyborgNinja
09/08/17 9:44:35 PM
#13:


I don't care if people are gay, doing gay stuff, but it grosses me out on top of already being largely unrelateable. Pass.
---
"message parlor" ? do you mean the post office ? - SlayerX888
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyuubi4269
09/08/17 9:49:49 PM
#14:


mrduckbear posted...
Armie Hammer

pornname/10
---
RIP_Supa posted...
I've seen some stuff
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zeus
09/08/17 9:54:02 PM
#15:


mrduckbear posted...
which has an astonishing 98% metacritic rating which could be Sony's first Oscar winning film!!


I don't assign much value to metacritic ratings and, generally speaking, neither does the Academy. There's an almost zero chance of it getting an Oscar not because of its quality, but because it's premiering too soon in the year.
---
(\/)(\/)|-|
In Zeus We Trust: All Others Pay Cash
... Copied to Clipboard!
wwinterj25
09/08/17 10:15:55 PM
#16:


helIy posted...
so?

american pie had a sex scene with a pie

I can't say I know what is better though.
---
One who knows nothing can understand nothing.
http://psnprofiles.com/wwinterj - http://i.imgur.com/kDysIcd.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
Metal_Mario99
09/09/17 2:20:57 AM
#17:


Sounds terrible in every way.
---
The GameFAQs mods are terrible at their job.
... Copied to Clipboard!
CountessRolab
09/09/17 2:39:38 AM
#18:


I think it actually looks really good. To discount a romance movie simply because it is gay is silly. Brokeback Mountain and Blue is the Warmest Color were both excellent.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
wwinterj25
09/09/17 3:44:19 AM
#19:


CountessRolab posted...
To discount a romance movie simply because it is gay is silly.


Not as silly as watching films I've no interest in just because. For the record I generally don't like love story films and 'chick flicks' so avoid them.
---
One who knows nothing can understand nothing.
http://psnprofiles.com/wwinterj - http://i.imgur.com/kDysIcd.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
CountessRolab
09/09/17 3:47:31 AM
#20:


TheCyborgNinja posted...
I don't care if people are gay, doing gay stuff, but it grosses me out on top of already being largely unrelateable. Pass.

I think you are overacting. I find heterosexual sex repulsive, but i have no problem watching straight movies. I can appreciate a good romance story.


wwinterj25 posted...
CountessRolab posted...
To discount a romance movie simply because it is gay is silly.


Not as silly as watching films I've no interest in just because. For the record I generally don't like love story films and 'chick flicks' so avoid them.

That is fine. I am more referring to the attitude shown in the above post.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
wwinterj25
09/09/17 3:51:27 AM
#21:


CountessRolab posted...
That is fine. I am more referring to the attitude shown in the above post.


I see. Yeah I don't see how they would gross someone out. I mean I watch soaps so having gay storylines is common in those and love storylines in general so it's not like I shy away from them everytime I see them as it's a fact of life. Plus these things have shown up in some porn I watch so....
---
One who knows nothing can understand nothing.
http://psnprofiles.com/wwinterj - http://i.imgur.com/kDysIcd.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
CountessRolab
09/09/17 3:55:02 AM
#22:


wwinterj25 posted...
CountessRolab posted...
That is fine. I am more referring to the attitude shown in the above post.


I see. Yeah I don't see how they would gross someone out. I mean I watch soaps so having gay storylines is common in those and love storylines in general so it's not like I shy away from them everytime I see them as it's a fact of life. Plus these things have shown up in some porn I watch so....


I always roll my eyes when people act all "gay is icky!!"
I have fucking lived my entire life in an ocean of media focused on sex that I find repulsive (it is in virtually every movie/song to some degree), but I can move beyond that. People need to realize that sex isnt that big of a deal, and media isnt automatically bad just because you arent sexually attracted to it.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
madadude
09/09/17 9:18:58 AM
#23:


Zeus posted...
but because it's premiering too soon in the year.

@Zeus

What? It's coming out November 24th?

How is that too soon, if anything it is too late. Most of the last few oscar winners came out in October.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
_AdjI_
09/09/17 10:31:36 AM
#24:


I'm just baffled by how boning a peach would even work. Like, did he cut a hole through it?
... Copied to Clipboard!
Troll_Police_
09/09/17 10:44:54 AM
#25:


im just gonna re purpose a quote about brokeback mountain


"Call me by your name" will win the oscar, and 2 people will go to see it.
---
Is this going to be one of those times when you pretend not to have a plan until the last moment? And then turn out to really not have one?
... Copied to Clipboard!
Troll_Police_
09/09/17 10:46:04 AM
#26:


CountessRolab posted...
Brokeback Mountain and Blue is the Warmest Color were both excellent.


haaaaaahahahahahaha

no they fucking werent and you know it
---
Is this going to be one of those times when you pretend not to have a plan until the last moment? And then turn out to really not have one?
... Copied to Clipboard!
CountessRolab
09/09/17 3:22:17 PM
#27:


Troll_Police_ posted...
CountessRolab posted...
Brokeback Mountain and Blue is the Warmest Color were both excellent.


haaaaaahahahahahaha

no they fucking werent and you know it


Blue is the Warmest Color literally won the grad prize at the Cannes Film Festival (one of the most prestigious awards in film). You clearly have unrefined taste in movies. Go watch a low-budget comedy--it will appeal to your short attention span.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Tails 64
09/09/17 3:55:51 PM
#28:


Am I the only person who came to this topic thinking something like, "Well, I bet Mario will be jealous..."?
---
http://TinyURL.com/Learn2Learn101 - My advice for surviving college and writing academically
http://TinyURL.com/SirNintendolot - My YouTube channel
... Copied to Clipboard!
Revelation34
09/09/17 4:14:42 PM
#29:


CountessRolab posted...
wwinterj25 posted...
CountessRolab posted...
That is fine. I am more referring to the attitude shown in the above post.


I see. Yeah I don't see how they would gross someone out. I mean I watch soaps so having gay storylines is common in those and love storylines in general so it's not like I shy away from them everytime I see them as it's a fact of life. Plus these things have shown up in some porn I watch so....


I always roll my eyes when people act all "gay is icky!!"
I have fucking lived my entire life in an ocean of media focused on sex that I find repulsive (it is in virtually every movie/song to some degree), but I can move beyond that. People need to realize that sex isnt that big of a deal, and media isnt automatically bad just because you arent sexually attracted to it.


You should be finding all sex repulsive then by that logic.
---
Gamertag: Kegfarms, BF code: 2033480226, Treasure Cruise code 318,374,355
... Copied to Clipboard!
madadude
09/09/17 11:55:16 PM
#30:


Troll_Police_ posted...
im just gonna re purpose a quote about brokeback mountain


"Call me by your name" will win the oscar, and 2 people will go to see it.


Brokeback Mountain made a ton at the box office though
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
VeeVees
09/09/17 11:56:12 PM
#31:


I see "oscar contender" and I lose all interest
---
Rudy sucks
... Copied to Clipboard!
helIy
09/10/17 12:01:58 AM
#32:


CountessRolab posted...
Troll_Police_ posted...
CountessRolab posted...
Brokeback Mountain and Blue is the Warmest Color were both excellent.


haaaaaahahahahahaha

no they fucking werent and you know it


Blue is the Warmest Color literally won the grad prize at the Cannes Film Festival (one of the most prestigious awards in film). You clearly have unrefined taste in movies. Go watch a low-budget comedy--it will appeal to your short attention span.

yeah schmen

you're not refined enough to call a shitty movie a shitty movie
---
depressed again
morning comes too fast and i'm tired of the routine
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zareth
09/10/17 12:27:51 AM
#33:


Yeah, Sony's gonna release an Oscar contender. That's a good one.
---
It's okay, I have no idea who I am either.
http://i.imgur.com/WOo6wcq.png
... Copied to Clipboard!
wwinterj25
09/10/17 12:51:03 AM
#34:


CountessRolab posted...
People need to realize that sex isnt that big of a deal, and media isnt automatically bad just because you arent sexually attracted to it.


Agreed man. Unfortunately the world is still full of people who are closed minded and think everyone should live their lives how they choose to lie their own. It's sad really.
---
One who knows nothing can understand nothing.
http://psnprofiles.com/wwinterj - http://i.imgur.com/kDysIcd.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zeus
09/10/17 1:08:44 AM
#35:


CountessRolab posted...
That is fine. I am more referring to the attitude shown in the above post.


Metal Mario's comment about it being terrible in every way does not in any way specifically state gay. Also go back to CE.

madadude posted...
Zeus posted...
but because it's premiering too soon in the year.

@ Zeus

What? It's coming out November 24th?

How is that too soon, if anything it is too late. Most of the last few oscar winners came out in October.


Oh, misread it then. November is generally a strong month, though, even if the most nominations come from films premiering in December or even later (because critics see them at film festivals prior to the actual release)

Granted, I'm still sure that this over-hyped Sony film won't amount to much because, well, Sony.
---
(\/)(\/)|-|
In Zeus We Trust: All Others Pay Cash
... Copied to Clipboard!
madadude
09/10/17 3:15:18 AM
#36:


Zeus posted...
even if the most nominations come from films premiering in December or even later (because critics see them at film festivals prior to the actual release)


that's not true though

Last year of the 9 best picture nominees, 1 came out in August, 1 in October, 4 in November and 3 in December

the year before: 1 May, 3 October, 2 November, 2 December

75% of them come out in the last 3 months of the year sure, but less than 30% come out in December or have a limited release in December and wide in January. Most are October or November
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
madadude
09/10/17 3:20:44 AM
#37:


Zeus posted...
Granted, I'm still sure that this over-hyped Sony film won't amount to much because, well, Sony.


Zareth posted...
Yeah, Sony's gonna release an Oscar contender. That's a good one.



and what? in the past 10 years Sony as had 9 Best Picture nominees (4 under Sony Pictures Classics which CMBYN is and 5 under Sony/Columbia)

Last year Sony got a total of 6 oscar nominations, 2014 they only got 2, but in 2013 they had 21 nominations and in 2012 they had 19 nominations.

Literally Zeus why do you say this stuff like its fact when you don't know what you are talking about lol

@Zeus
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
madadude
09/10/17 3:37:55 AM
#38:


As far as I see it. Call Me By Your Name is almost a guaranteed win for adapted screenplay this year, but it is an incredibly weak category this year with very few films able to qualify as an adapted screenplay that would get in (there is Last Flag Flying, Mudbound, Wonderstruck, Death of Stalin, Darkest Hour, The Disaster Artist, Hostiles and Molly's Game as its competitors... really weak slate compared to how packed original screenplay is)

It's also very sure to get nominations for picture, supporting actor (Stuhlberg), and director, and probably getting nominations for actor (Chalamet) and song for one or two of the Sufjan Stevens original songs. That's all I see it getting nominated for, editing, cinematography, and another supporting actor for Hammer is possible but I doubt it.

It's definitely SPC's main horse this year. Other things they have are Novitiate (which they will only push Melissa Leo for supporting actress) Film Stars Don't Die in Liverpool (which they will only push Annette Bening for actress and Jamie Bell for supporting actor) and A Fantastic Woman (which they will push for foreign and actress). Though really of all of those the only other one that will probably happen is Leo.

Sony/Columbia/Tristar has Roman J. Israel, Esq which will probably get Denzel Washington an actor nomination and maybe a few other, though still unsure as it hasn't premiered yet, and Baby Driver which could get sound editing and sound mixing.

In terms of winning best picture, it's possible but I doubt it, though I'm not really sure what else could at this point. If the Spielberg picture (The Post) gets really great reviews I could see it winning (and even if it only gets average reviews I bet it will get nominated). Dunkirk... could I suppose... but it would have to win without a screenplay nomination which it isn't going to get, and that hasn't happened since Titanic. The Shape of Water is getting incredible reviews out of Venice and Telluride, so Guillermo Del Toro's film could but it would be a very odd pick for the Academy. It will get nominated I am sure but I can't see it winning. Get Out.... can't see that winning, nor can I see The Florida Project or Last Flag Flying. Darkest Hour is solid oscar bait but it's reviews aren't good enough and a true oscar bait film hasn't really won since King's Speech. So yeah I don't know what will win, but for nominations I am predicting Dunkirk, Shape of Water, Call Me By Your Name, The Post, Get Out, Last Flag Flying, Darkest Hour, and 2 or 3 of the following: The Florida Project, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri, Downsizing, Blade Runner: 2049, Roman J. Israel, Esq, Wonder Sheel, The Big Sick, Lady Bird, and The Phantom Thread.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zeus
09/10/17 1:17:43 PM
#39:


madadude posted...
Zeus posted...
even if the most nominations come from films premiering in December or even later (because critics see them at film festivals prior to the actual release)


that's not true though

Last year of the 9 best picture nominees, 1 came out in August, 1 in October, 4 in November and 3 in December

the year before: 1 May, 3 October, 2 November, 2 December

75% of them come out in the last 3 months of the year sure, but less than 30% come out in December or have a limited release in December and wide in January. Most are October or November


https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2013/01/release-dates-oscars/319514/

A map of the monthly calendar of Academy Award winners and nominees has surprising results: December is the most popular month for nominated releases, but winners tend to come from October and November.

Apparently just looking at one year for results is a fucking stupid way to judge a trend. Who knew?

madadude posted...
Zeus posted...
Granted, I'm still sure that this over-hyped Sony film won't amount to much because, well, Sony.


Zareth posted...
Yeah, Sony's gonna release an Oscar contender. That's a good one.



and what? in the past 10 years Sony as had 9 Best Picture nominees (4 under Sony Pictures Classics which CMBYN is and 5 under Sony/Columbia)

Last year Sony got a total of 6 oscar nominations, 2014 they only got 2, but in 2013 they had 21 nominations and in 2012 they had 19 nominations.

Literally Zeus why do you say this stuff like its fact when you don't know what you are talking about lol

@ Zeus


And why do you abuse the mention system? @madadude More importantly, why do you conflate "nominee" with "contender"? Are you being purposely deceptive? Or do you ignorantly believe that every nominee is an actual contender? Did you think that The Kids Are Alright had EXACTLY the same chances of winning Best Picture as the The King's Speech just because both were nominated back in 2011? If so, I've got a bridge I'd like to sell you.
---
(\/)(\/)|-|
In Zeus We Trust: All Others Pay Cash
... Copied to Clipboard!
JTekashiro
09/11/17 12:55:05 PM
#40:


How does one do that with a peach? I mean, I am no Ron Jeremy but a peach seems a little small. Do you just push the pit out in the process?
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zeus
09/11/17 10:28:10 PM
#41:


JTekashiro posted...
How does one do that with a peach? I mean, I am no Ron Jeremy but a peach seems a little small. Do you just push the pit out in the process?


Fun fact: "Pit" is just "tip" spelled backward.
---
(\/)(\/)|-|
In Zeus We Trust: All Others Pay Cash
... Copied to Clipboard!
madadude
09/12/17 12:54:36 AM
#42:


Zeus posted...

Apparently just looking at one year for results is a fucking stupid way to judge a trend. Who knew?


I checked the past 17 years but okay.

And you just said oscar contender, you didn't say best picture winning contender, there are plenty of oscars, not just picture, but even going off of your distinction between being a best picture nominee and contender, The Social Network was a contender to win and that was a Sony film, as was Zero Dark Thirty and American Hustle to a lesser extent. So the notion that Sony not putting out best picture winning contenders is still a laughable concept. When compared to the other major distribution companies over the past 10 years they have been far more successful than Universal at least when it comes to this.


And I just did the mention system because, at least for me personally, I would very likely miss a response to a post of mine, but I guess if you were planning to look back for a response anyway it is unnecessary.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Yellow
09/12/17 1:19:19 AM
#43:


Looks like a borefest. I like movies where people get hurt and things blow up.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zeus
09/12/17 1:43:40 AM
#44:


madadude posted...
And you just said oscar contender, you didn't say best picture winning contender,


It's understood to mean best picture.

madadude posted...
The Social Network was a contender to win and that was a Sony film, as was Zero Dark Thirty and American Hustle to a lesser extent.


American Hustle, maybe. The others... clearly not. Social Network was up against The King's Speech AND Inception, along with Black Swan and a number of others. Given the competition, I never suspected it had a chance. Zero Dark Thirty never stood a chance either. After all, it was up against Argo that year and had some stiff competition on top of that.

American Hustle came up in a year where the competition was a bit more lax. Granted, even if 12 Years a Slave wasn't on the table, it'd still likely have lost to Dallas Buyers Club. However, neither 12 Years or Dallas was anywhere near as dominant as King's Speech.

madadude posted...
And I just did the mention system because, at least for me personally, I would very likely miss a response to a post of mine, but I guess if you were planning to look back for a response anyway it is unnecessary.


I have the topic tracked. And I don't give any priority to mentions for the most part.

A mention is generally more useful if I haven't posted in a topic at all but, 9 times out of 10, most topics which I haven't posted in it's more likely a matter of me not caring.
---
(\/)(\/)|-|
In Zeus We Trust: All Others Pay Cash
... Copied to Clipboard!
wwinterj25
09/12/17 1:48:14 AM
#45:


Yellow posted...
I like movies where people get hurt and things blow up.


Sounds like you'll enjoy this film then.
---
One who knows nothing can understand nothing.
http://psnprofiles.com/wwinterj - http://i.imgur.com/kDysIcd.gif
... Copied to Clipboard!
madadude
09/12/17 1:58:38 AM
#46:


Zeus posted...

American Hustle, maybe. The others... clearly not. Social Network was up against The King's Speech AND Inception, along with Black Swan and a number of others. Given the competition, I never suspected it had a chance. Zero Dark Thirty never stood a chance either. After all, it was up against Argo that year and had some stiff competition on top of that.

American Hustle came up in a year where the competition was a bit more lax. Granted, even if 12 Years a Slave wasn't on the table, it'd still likely have lost to Dallas Buyers Club. However, neither 12 Years or Dallas was anywhere near as dominant as King's Speech.


The Social Network was still winning quite a few precursor awards prior to the oscars that are correlated to winning best picture, not as much as King's Speech which was the frontrunner but definitely more than Inception and Black Swan, which I would have to go back and look but I am pretty sure won none of the awards or had none of the general patterns that lead to a best picture win. Plenty of pundits had Social Network predicted up to Oscar night.

American Hustle definitely wouldn't have lost to Dallas Buyers Club, are you kidding? Gravity and 12 Years a Slave were definitely top two, with American Hustle third in terms of likelihood. Not close to Gravity and 12 Years of course, which come oscar night seemed like it could easily go either way, but regardless.

Zero Dark Thirty, I'll concede wasn't as strong as the other too mentioned. Argo was a pretty clear victory despite its snub in best director. Life of Pi probably ran second that year, Lincoln third and either ZDT or SLP fourth.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zeus
09/12/17 2:58:17 AM
#47:


madadude posted...
The Social Network was still winning quite a few precursor awards prior to the oscars that are correlated to winning best picture, not as much as King's Speech which was the frontrunner but definitely more than Inception and Black Swan, which I would have to go back and look but I am pretty sure won none of the awards or had none of the general patterns that lead to a best picture win. Plenty of pundits had Social Network predicted up to Oscar night.


Inception won 4 Oscars. Social Network won 3. Black Swan won 1, but it was for Best Actress which is a more significant category.

madadude posted...
American Hustle definitely wouldn't have lost to Dallas Buyers Club, are you kidding? Gravity and 12 Years a Slave were definitely top two, with American Hustle third in terms of likelihood. Not close to Gravity and 12 Years of course, which come oscar night seemed like it could easily go either way, but regardless.


Dallas Buyers Club won 3 Oscars, but those included best actor and best supporting actor which are generally more significant awards.

12 Years won 3 Oscars, best picture, best supporting actress, and best screenplay. While Gravity won 7 Oscars, the only actually significant one was Best Director. The rest were just stuff like sound and visual effects, which doesn't exactly make a film a strong contender for best picture.

As American Hustle -- your "third best" film of the year -- how many Oscars did it win? Zero. While it could have beaten Gravity for best picture, it certainly would have lost to Dallas.

madadude posted...
Zero Dark Thirty, I'll concede wasn't as strong as the other too mentioned. Argo was a pretty clear victory despite its snub in best director. Life of Pi probably ran second that year, Lincoln third and either ZDT or SLP fourth.


Lincoln wasn't really predicted for big things near as I can recall.
---
(\/)(\/)|-|
In Zeus We Trust: All Others Pay Cash
... Copied to Clipboard!
fettster777
09/12/17 9:07:44 AM
#48:


Does he ejaculate in the peach?
... Copied to Clipboard!
#49
Post #49 was unavailable or deleted.
madadude
09/14/17 2:39:54 AM
#50:


Zeus posted...
Inception won 4 Oscars. Social Network won 3. Black Swan won 1, but it was for Best Actress which is a more significant category.


So? We are talking about the race for best picture, as you clearly were making clear. Plus Social Network won editing and screenplay which are far more significant categories than actress in terms of winning best picture, and Inception won purely technical awards, and wasn't even nominated for director, so it had nothing significant going for it.

Zeus posted...
Dallas Buyers Club won 3 Oscars, but those included best actor and best supporting actor which are generally more significant awards.

12 Years won 3 Oscars, best picture, best supporting actress, and best screenplay. While Gravity won 7 Oscars, the only actually significant one was Best Director. The rest were just stuff like sound and visual effects, which doesn't exactly make a film a strong contender for best picture.

As American Hustle -- your "third best" film of the year -- how many Oscars did it win? Zero. While it could have beaten Gravity for best picture, it certainly would have lost to Dallas.


Again, so?

The number of Oscars won isn't what we are talking about here, we are talking about being a runner up for Best Picture. The precursor awards, which are the most common predictors of the Oscar race, as well as looking at what pundits were predicting at the time, clearly show American Hustle was third and had a slim chance, while Dallas Buyers Club had none. Dallas Buyers Club was the favorite to win actor, supporting actor, and makeup as those were the film's strengths. Acting awards are not a good predictor of best picture winners, plenty of acting winners haven't had their film nominated in best picture over the years. A good amount have also been the sole nominee of their film, yet won the award.

Both before the awards and after the awards, the vast consensus was that American Hustle was the second runner up, while Dallas Buyers Club wasn't on the radar to win.

American Hustle had a director nomination, which Dallas didn't have. In terms of the actual other awards predicting the Oscar winner, the best predictors are the nominees of director, screenplay and editing.

12 Years a Slave and American Hustle were the only ones to have all 3. Dallas and Captain Phillips didn't have directing nominations, Nebraska and Wolf of Wall Street didn't have editing nominations. Gravity didn't have a screenplay nomination.

AH would have certainly beat Dallas.

Zeus posted...

Lincoln wasn't really predicted for big things near as I can recall.


It was the favorite to win up until the Producer's Guild Award went to Argo.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1, 2