Board 8 > Blade Mafia 5 Topic 4: The host has actually mood a topic! MOO YEAH!

(+) Yeah! (+)

Corrik posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Corrik posted...

Mzero
IGCD
And either Shad/Eaed.

A jinjo has to be scum. No way all are town and one indy to hunt them all. Imbalanced.

I'm not a jinjo

It's like you and Mzero can't read.

Well you didn't make it very clear tbh
---

Who's town and who's scum Mzero?
---

Han Posted...

I don't want to vote Scare.

Unvote: dowolf
Vote: Panthera

I don't like the confidence Panthera has had so far this game. Feels like bravado, which comes across as cheap and forced. Reeks of Scum.

FD would be a good lynch also~

BTW, votals at the top of this topic have IGCD on multiple people

Doesn't want to lynch Scare (Indie), does want to lynch Panthera (???) and FD (town). This is odd to me because as I mentioned before, I think Han ends the day on donker even with a B8 special on panthera almost happening (CITATION NEEDED)
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

RogueNoble posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Corrik is probably Town because he's flailing about and being annoying as usual

What is scum Corrik like in your mind?

Probably more pro-Town, tbh

Likes Corrik as town for being annoying.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Pretty strong. I know the guy well-enough that I'm pretty positive he's being genuine and it feels like people are taking advantage of his noobness to push him around. That IS minus points for Corrik, but I feel Town Corrik would bully a new player around anyway.

Likes BCT for being "genuine" and bullied
---

htaeD posted...

I feel, the fact that we're thinking about it more than Han himself, speaks miles about him anyway.

I'm not awake from 3-6 am in the morning.

Corrik posted...

You have to do way too many jumps and hurdles to try to maybe find him town.

Corrik is definitely Scum. The framing of this statement makes no sense.

The simplest explanation for all this is that FD didn't die from hiding behind me.

He is a Super Hider. For him to break the mold of a regular Hider, that hints at two main possibilities:

1. He doesn't die from hiding behind Scum.
2. He doesn't die when the person he dies behind gets killed.

Number 2 is definitely broken, so number 1 is the likely correct answer. If ColZach is telling the truth and we have a confirmed third party who is doing killing, with 3 deaths night 1, I would just about guarantee that he doesn't die from hiding behind Scum.

There are numerous possibilities for how he could have died otherwise and I don't want to waste my time naming infinite things that imagination can come up with.

Upon rereading day 1, dowolf pings gut the most. He had numerous occasions of stating things like facts that were not facts at all. He was a defender in the probability discussion - probably didn't like that someone got close to the truth.

##Vote: dowolf

Also, he broke rule 1.
---

RogueNoble posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

One Piece is just an amazing series. Sorry.

Does anything match Impel Down's greatness again?

Still don't like Panthera, or FD. Would be ok with a dowolf or IGCD lynch as well.

Unvote:
Vote: Donker

Donker's vote was very bad though.

ColZach didn't look great either but the way he picked up so much steam off of the Corrik train blew red flags. I do not like how many people just went "oh ColZach is Town" either. You leave power alone, but that doesn't guarantee that they are Town, the way so many people are claiming.

Still doesn't like FD (town), Panthera (???), now also dislikes Dowolf, (???), IGCD (???)

---

RogueNoble posted...

Han Posted...

I don't want to vote Scare.

Unvote: dowolf
Vote: Panthera

I don't like the confidence Panthera has had so far this game. Feels like bravado, which comes across as cheap and forced. Reeks of Scum.

FD would be a good lynch also~

BTW, votals at the top of this topic have IGCD on multiple people

Doesn't want to lynch Scare (Indie), does want to lynch Panthera (???) and FD (town). This is odd to me because as I mentioned before, I think Han ends the day on donker even with a B8 special on panthera almost happening (CITATION NEEDED)

Yeah, I'm not sure why FD would be so sure I'm Town when he was one of my top choices.

I was ok with either a Panthera or Donker lynch yesterday. Panthera pinged my gut early on but Donker's vote on Corrik was abysmal.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

I want Donker to claim too but I've wanted Panth all day.

We can b8special both and then end up on some nobody like Starscream.

A slim point for Lurky McNoPosts here for being Han's "just sayin'" B8 special idea thrown out. Could be he hoped someone else would pick it up and run with it so his hands would be clean on a mislynch.
---

I might have missed a few posts, but for the most part we now have a pretty reasonable sandbox of Han posts to play in now.

Question is, is Scum Han more of a busser, or more of a protector? Anyone know scum Han well? I know he was just scum last game but he didn't leave much of an impression on me. Not to go all rule of 3, but he almost certainly mentioned teammates in some capacity D1.
---

The Starscream thing was obviously a joke.

I will defend to death anyone who is unable to defend themselves. The guy was absent. I would've fought against him.

Anyway, Leo, you're wasting time. I'm not Scum. Look for Scum, stop wasting time.
---

Remind me who the scum is, Han? I appear to have forgotten
---

You were doing so well reading my posts, I don't know why you'd stop there.
---

You're doing a fantastic job of proving to me this is all a horrible misunderstand, Han. I can see the shiny town sparkles flowing off you know. Not only are you claiming to put all your cards on the table, but you're being helpful and cooperative to assist town in finding the real culprit. Boy, it's a hell of a good thing you're doing all that instead of pouting and making snide comments until your inevitable lynch. That might make people feel more secure that they're lynching scum!

Here, since you're acting in such a productive pro-town manner let me help you out with some devil advocating! The claimed cop wasn't roleblocked or killed, which is unusual. FD's hint was blatant enough for scum to figure out his role, so they roleblocked and killed him to frame you. What a shocking twist!

It might even have been a believable theory if you hadn't just folded immediately!

(Ok, even I feel a little bad for being this sarcastic)
---

I am not sure a roleblock would hit a hider.
---

For some reason this Han reminds me of PW mafia han. Something about him on day 4 (his lynch day) is just drawing parallels to today.

Was it the part where a town power confirmed him scum so he rolled over and died
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

You were doing so well reading my posts, I don't know why you'd stop there.

I admit I only just now saw you posted a concise summary when I was pulling up all your old posts

But I feel like my point remains
---

I'm very wary of anyone saying I "rolled over died".

I clearly haven't done that. Acting as though my lynch is inevitable is very Scummy.
---

If this game had votals, they would disagree.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Upon rereading day 1, dowolf pings gut the most. He had numerous occasions of stating things like facts that were not facts at all. He was a defender in the probability discussion - probably didn't like that someone got close to the truth.

##Vote: dowolf

u wot m8?

also what you got against math?
---

corrik dont ask for a hammer

dont make FD sad
---

It's not math. I asked for explanations and you provided fluff. It was always fluff.
---

About as fluff as your claim. Hammer Time!
---

RogueNoble posted...

Red said "Can we confirm that we aren't all jinjos" and a lot of people confirmed anti-Jinjo. Then once the whole game had more or less chimed in, he said "oops I wasn't thinking, there might be a role that cares about jinjos, my bad"

I think only a couple people chimed in(Someone, death i think, wasnt paying attention and said so after I said not to claim jinjo status). Honestly just wasnt thinking that deep on it originally(Blade games definitely require me just shutting my brain off a little bit)..
---

in reds defense, I posted after he said that
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

It's not math. I asked for explanations and you provided fluff. It was always fluff.

you asked for why i picked a random number.

i literally explained exactly what was going through my head when i picked that number.

...Like, I'm not going to up and tell you that's not fluff, but it's the fluff you asked for.
---

....oh I am talking to red

I will just visit a corner now
---

I am caught up but dont have any input on the day.
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

I am caught up but dont have any input on the day.

Yeah, this for me too.
---

dowolf posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

It's not math. I asked for explanations and you provided fluff. It was always fluff.

you asked for why i picked a random number.

i literally explained exactly what was going through my head when i picked that number.

...Like, I'm not going to up and tell you that's not fluff, but it's the fluff you asked for.

I didn't want fluff though, at that point.

Perhaps that is the problem. I was ready to move on with the game, but you were stuck on page 1 for the whole topic?

Why did you want to lynch red, anyway?
---

Han, don't take the high ground. You're scum. Scum doesn't *get* the high ground.
---

I'm literally not Scum. And when I flip Town, I want to make sure fellow Town doesn't just forget about the people who drove in the knife.
---

Nice claim.
---

Corrik posted...

Nice claim.

I'll probably claim soon since you guys seem set on idling the day to oblivion. I was hoping I wouldn't have to claim just to get y'all to play the game.

Dowolf hopped on FD's post right away. He is most likely Scum who set this situation up.
---

That really makes perfect sense. Roleblock the expected hider, kill him, get a mislynch off of it.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

That really makes perfect sense. Roleblock the expected hider, kill him, get a mislynch off of it.

How do you roleblock and untargetable role?
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

I am caught up but dont have any input on the day.

KujikawaRising posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

I am caught up but dont have any input on the day.

Yeah, this for me too.

-10 points to Hufflepuff
---

RogueNoble posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

I am caught up but dont have any input on the day.

KujikawaRising posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

I am caught up but dont have any input on the day.

Yeah, this for me too.

-10 points to Hufflepuff

It's fine.
---

You don't get it IGCD, you might not win the house cup.

I think roleblocking trumps hiding, since you have to actually successfully perform the hiding action, but as I say it's a little late for that theory to hold much water.
---

RogueNoble posted...

You don't get it IGCD, you might not win the house cup.

I think roleblocking trumps hiding, since you have to actually successfully perform the hiding action, but as I say it's a little late for that theory to hold much water.

it should but this probably literally didnt happen.
---

RogueNoble posted...

You don't get it IGCD, you might not win the house cup.

I think roleblocking trumps hiding, since you have to actually successfully perform the hiding action, but as I say it's a little late for that theory to hold much water.

I dont need to win anything, other than this game. Even then the need is more of a desire. It seems odd to roleblock and kill FD when there are likely better choices for both on night 1.
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

That really makes perfect sense. Roleblock the expected hider, kill him, get a mislynch off of it.

How do you roleblock and untargetable role?

Hider doesn't necessarily become untargetable when they hide.

red13n posted...

RogueNoble posted...

You don't get it IGCD, you might not win the house cup.

I think roleblocking trumps hiding, since you have to actually successfully perform the hiding action, but as I say it's a little late for that theory to hold much water.

it should but this probably literally didnt happen.

I'm Town, so it either happened or there's another explanation.

Strongman that does through hiding is a possibility, though it seems weird to use that on FD night 1. I don't much get why they would put that many resources into getting me mislynched unless they thought I had established myself that well day 1.
---

humoring Han here for a second

but if scum did know FD was hider, than of course they'd be tempted to use their strongman (if they knew it could hit a hiding player) on him

allthough in that case, they could have just shot Han instead and get a double kill, if they knew that much
---

That's a good point. If Scum expected FD to hide behind me, they would just kill me.
---

Less focus on Han more on han's interactions tbh.

At work.
---

More on finding Scum would be good, tbqh.
---

Sorry Han you are super dead
---

Just so everyone knows, due to a family emergency, my mind is else where at the moment
---

It is ok you don't do a lot to begin with. Family is more important than mafia.
---