Board 8 > Pokemon: Best in Line Day 20 - Charmander - Charmeleon - Charizard

(+) Yeah! (+)

- Taking noms
- This will stop when I feel like it

Day 1: Haunter - 35 (50.72%); Gengar - 30; Gastly - 4
Day 2: Jolteon - 24 (26.97%); Umbreon - 16; Espeon - 12; Glaceon - 11; Vaporeon - 9; Leafeon - 5; Eevee, Flareon, Sylveon - 4
Day 3: Raichu - 28 (38.89%); Pikachu - 27; Alolan Raichu - 13; Pichu - 4
Day 4: Dewott - 28 (50%); Oshawott - 14; Samurott - 14
Day 5: Dragonair - 33 (50%); Dragonite - 27, Dratini - 6
Day 6: Feraligatr - 34 (50%); Totodile - 32; Croconaw - 2
Day 7: Rockruff - 15 (34.88%); Lycanroc Midnight - 12; Midday, Dusk - 8
Day 8: Scyther - 41 (63.08%); Scizor - 22; Mega Scizor - 2
Day 9: Bellossom - 26 (48.15%); Vileplume - 14, Oddish - 10, Gloom - 4
Day 10: Garchomp - 32 (58.18%); Gabite - 12, Gible - 9, Mega Garchomp - 2
Day 11: Slowking - 20 (33.9%); Slowbro - 17; Slowpoke - 13; Mega Slowbro - 9
Day 12: Ampharos - 28 (54.9%); Mega Ampharos - 12, Mareep - 7; Flaaffy - 4
Day 13: Gyarados - 28 (62.22%); Magikarp - 15, Mega Gyarados - 2
Day 14: Froslass - 27 (56.25%); Glalie - 11; Snorunt - 6; Mega Glalie - 4
Day 15: Squirtle - 34 (51.52%); Blastoise - 21, Wartortle - 6, Mega Blastoise - 5
Day 16: Lickitung - 52 (86.67%); Lickilicky - 7
Day 17: Decidueye - 28 (58.33%); Rowlet - 16; Dartrix - 4
Day 18: Venomoth - 34 (70.83%); Venonat - 14
Day 19: Aggron - 16 (51.61%); Mega Aggron, Aron - 6; Lairon - 3

Charmeleon > Charmander > Charizard > Mega Y > Mega X
---

Surprisingly difficult. The original 3 are vastly superior to either Mega for me, but I don't have a strong preference aside from that.
---

Not a fan of the megas or Charmeleon.

Charizard > Charmander > whatever
---

Mega Charizard X > Charizard > Charmander > Charmeleon > Mega Charizard Y
---

Let's not confuse or overcomplicate things here
---

Charizard.

I bet he and Blastoise have an Insurance scam going, he torches it Blasty douses it lol.
---

Nom: Goomy line
---

great line, they're all about the same for me though... picked Y since I figured the megas wouldn't get many votes
---

i voted for Charmander

and realized i would vote for the first forms of all starter lines except Water ones minus Piplup

@kateee

I would like to suggest that you don't close these topics whenever you put up a new topic, so people can still continue the discussion even after a newer topic has been put up.
---

you can just continue any discussion in the current topic no? you're free to comment on previous lines/any pokemon.

i don't want the board to be spammed by these.

i do keep the polls open despite the topics being closed so if you "missed" the day but still want to vote you can. i do check and update past results accordingly if the topics are still around. it's kind of "too much" work to keep them longer and check beyond the purge rate for such a casual topic series because someone commented with a simple x > y and bumped it two days later.

if people have serious objections though they can say so and i'll consider it.

X is so good, but yes not surprising the board prefers the Gen 1 offerings. They are all quite good.
---

X is amazing, yeah, but like

Charizard, man
---

X is what finally makes Charizard interesting.
---

Tokoyami posted...

X is so good, but yes not surprising the board prefers the Gen 1 offerings. They are all quite good.

None of the megas have won any of these polls. I think they're just at an inherent disadvantage since fewer people have played Gen 6/7 than the earlier generations.
---

Mega Ampharos should have won

i can't think of another Mega that is just so clearly superior to its regular form.

Maybe absol
---

Charizard > Charmander > Mega X > Mega Y > Charmeleon

I love the first three a LOT though.

nominate Mudkip
---

kateee posted...

Mega Ampharos should have won

i can't think of another Mega that is just so clearly superior to its regular form.

All Mega Pokemon are doing here is siphoning votes from the normal fully evolved forms

How many of the 8 Megazard votes today go to vanilla Zard if they weren't in?
---

X > Y > Zard > Meleon > Mander

that's expected but Megas aren't going away