Board 8 > Monster Mafia: The Rebootening Topic 6 - Postgame Discussion

(+) Yeah! (+)

continue here

Result: MZero lynched, mafia wins

Scumboard: http://draculascastle.freeforums.net/board/1/general-discussion

I am so happy ben didnt lynch me whoo
---

I'm so sad ):
---

Shoutout to Scare though. Probably the only one in the game who ever would have went ahead with me posing as Masons
---

You should totally be allowed to edit posts made in topics that got 500'd as long as they're still < 1 hour old.

Also, I groaned pretty hard when I saw my team was Chris red and pirate cause it felt so intentional and not random at all.

Not that I'm accusing our host of that.
---

Ben you just couldn't get the job done. My will power too strong.
---

I'm getting a host itch. Chris am I allowed to host again? You put me on probation after Broadway Mafia cause I accidentally mislead Spiral in his night action results.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Shoutout to Scare though. Probably the only one in the game who ever would have went ahead with me posing as Masons

I would of played with you! Honest

Obellisk posted...

Also, I groaned pretty hard when I saw my team was Chris red and pirate cause it felt so intentional and not random at all.

Not that I'm accusing our host of that.

Karma bit back quick for your hazing

For the record I PMed IGCD and said if town needed a replace I wanted it so I could try to get red and chris lynched.

Late D1 they voted Pirate back to back and it screamed bussing to save Chris and I didn't trust either of them after that.

Sbell had me fully fooled though, good job.
---

TotallyNotMI posted...

For the record I PMed IGCD and said if town needed a replace I wanted it so I could try to get red and chris lynched.

Late D1 they voted Pirate back to back and it screamed bussing to save Chris and I didn't trust either of them after that.

Sbell had me fully fooled though, good job.

I vote him as either alignment there.
---

TotallyNotMI posted...

Late D1 they voted Pirate back to back and it screamed bussing to save Chris and I didn't trust either of them after that.

Sbell has me fully fooled though, good job.

Yeah that confused even me. I didn't think it looked good at all.

And thanks! I really did play poorly day 1 but I felt I channeled my inner townsbell after that.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

TotallyNotMI posted...

For the record I PMed IGCD and said if town needed a replace I wanted it so I could try to get red and chris lynched.

Late D1 they voted Pirate back to back and it screamed bussing to save Chris and I didn't trust either of them after that.

Sbell had me fully fooled though, good job.

I vote him as either alignment there.

It wasn't just your vote though. It was you and red voting together seconds apart that made you looked linked together. It looked planned
---

If you hadnt claimed mason I dont save you and I dont think there is a cult and I probably dont die

I dont necessarily think that claim worked
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Ben you just couldn't get the job done. My will power too strong.

It's strong. There were certain defenses you used that I couldn't fight back against. I've never been known for being able to push a lynch though.
---

Neablis posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Shoutout to Scare though. Probably the only one in the game who ever would have went ahead with me posing as Masons

I would of played with you! Honest

next time ;D
---

Also no mason claim would have made chris and red not being killed much more suspicious.

You could justify killing confirmed town over them.

The mason claim was fun but screwed town hard.
---

Sorry for the hiccups that came along in the game, but despite them I feel this was my most successful hosting. I didn't put alignments in the flips because I wanted people to read the flavour. I thought I did a good job of indicating who was what in the flavour. I did mean to post the plum flavour the previous night but I got it typed up and the kids distracted me. It was kind of a type it up and forget to hit post kind of a thing.

I welcome any and all comments, complaints and critiques to help me be a better host.
---

Also plum to be fair you fucked that claim so much i probably would have voted you too. The slow burn of info just makes you look like you are stalling
---

masterplum posted...

If you hadnt claimed mason I dont save you and I dont think there is a cult and I probably dont die

I dont necessarily think that claim worked

):

Maybe. Chris did prostitute you though, so he would have known something and probably forced you to claim anyway
---

masterplum posted...

I was the Han of this game. Just freaking trust good players. Dammit

No, you weren't.
---

TotallyNotMI posted...

Also no mason claim would have made chris and red not being killed much more suspicious.

You could justify killing confirmed town over them.

The mason claim was fun but screwed town hard.

Heh. Well, I do always prioritize fun.
---

Also I forgot to change the day godfather back to just a regular godfather because originally Corrik was going to be able to use his scan during the day or at night and red was only going to scan innocent if scanned during the day.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

masterplum posted...

I was the Han of this game. Just freaking trust good players. Dammit

No, you weren't.

What part of me being completely sure chris was scum did you not understand
---

masterplum posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

masterplum posted...

I was the Han of this game. Just freaking trust good players. Dammit

No, you weren't.

What part of me being completely sure chris was scum did you not understand

The part where you played at an Alakazam level.
---

I'm not saying I played great this game, but being right about a read doesn't make you the "Han of the game". Completely bumbling the day (which to be fair, you said you probably shouldn't have signed up) is not something I do as Town.

The only time I've ever been mislynched is PoE at end of game.
---

TotallyNotMI posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

TotallyNotMI posted...

For the record I PMed IGCD and said if town needed a replace I wanted it so I could try to get red and chris lynched.

Late D1 they voted Pirate back to back and it screamed bussing to save Chris and I didn't trust either of them after that.

Sbell had me fully fooled though, good job.

I vote him as either alignment there.

It wasn't just your vote though. It was you and red voting together seconds apart that made you looked linked together. It looked planned

It was not though. We discussed the game barely.
---

To clarify, I DO think you're a good player plum, and from my memory across all of b8 mafia history, probably the most improved.

But you did not have a strong showing here.
---

That went by fast
Next?
---

Good game.

I am a little weirded out plum talked about how I made my claim so obvious and was dumb and shit. While also saying he had no idea if I was telling the truth or not.

Seemed a bit contradicting to me.
---

Plum was def. Off his game this game
---

My reads were super on point

But I tilted hard
---

When I died, Sbell was the only one I thought was likely scum of the scum team. Though I didn't really have any scum reads either.

Red was acting weird with his not parking on a splinter vote, but it wasn't too damning. Chris I felt played pretty similar to when he fake claimed miller as town. But, he did try a little harder in that game also to make up for it than he did here. He only seemed to this game once I gave him a fresh breath of life by bringing up that past game.
---

Noice... 2 wins as scum... I'm on a roll
---

Also, I claimed daycop truly because they couldn't roleblock me and I should have been the obvious night save then.

Sure they could have a strongman. But, then sure we could have a watcher.

Seemed fine enough to me to take the odds.
---

Lynching harris always. Noted
---

TotallyNotMI posted...

For the record I PMed IGCD and said if town needed a replace I wanted it so I could try to get red and chris lynched.

Late D1 they voted Pirate back to back and it screamed bussing to save Chris and I didn't trust either of them after that.

Sbell had me fully fooled though, good job.

I don't think a host should allow you to replace then. If someone replaces which isn't you then you could infer they took that replacement over you because the slot was scum.
---

Corrik posted...

Also, I claimed daycop truly because they couldn't roleblock me and I should have been the obvious night save then.

Sure they could have a strongman. But, then sure we could have a watcher.

Seemed fine enough to me to take the odds.

I think you played very well Corrik.
---

So whos next?
---

Whatever queue we had was purged. I think Sbell wants to go next. I am ready to do Danganronpa Mafia any time though
---

Newbie mafia by sheep, obviously.

Oh, you mean here? No idea.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Whatever queue we had was purged. I think Sbell wants to go next. I am ready to do Danganronpa Mafia any time though

I want to host but need to work on it.

Go ahead.
---

Can't be in next game unfortunately going on a cruise which means no internet.

I would host next but I'm doing Extra Life this year and that's coming up next weekend so I can't. I'd like to do it before the new year though
---

Arti posted...

I would host next but I'm doing Extra Life this year and that's coming up next weekend so I can't. I'd like to do it before the new year though

Wow way to rub it in, asshole.
---

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/77135194#1

Here's the signups
---

Also the lack of alignment with flips did no one any favors here.

Lets please not make a habit of that.

Also ben that was only a half lie i was basing my posts based on what igcd told us on the scumboard.

I'm thinking the game I'm gunna run will be a Broadway Mafia 2.

Redemption for the no contest that BM1 had.
---