Board 8 > Smash Ultimate Mafia Topic 1: SUPER SMAAAASH BROOOTHERS!!

(+) Yeah! (+)

Geno's claim looks way too explanatory of the situation, Death looks way too much like he's coaching him through, and Chris's insistence on following the Towntells in spite of the circumstances of the claim looks like Scum trying to push away the bad claim with force of personality.

Geno, what is your role?
---

The claim is way too bastardized to come from newbie scum tbh. That is classic 'host totally gave him that role' and to argue otherwise is silly.
---

I'd be really shocked if geno were scum, tbh.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Geno's claim looks way too explanatory of the situation, Death looks way too much like he's coaching him through, and Chris's insistence on following the Towntells in spite of the circumstances of the claim looks like Scum trying to push away the bad claim with force of personality.

Geno, what is your role?

Claimed already.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

The claim is way too bastardized to come from newbie scum tbh. That is classic 'host totally gave him that role' and to argue otherwise is silly.

No, arguing possibilities and asking questions is playing the game.

I hate to agree with Corrik, but I think this is just a case of bad newbie misplay and Scum damage control.
---

geno4smash4 posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Geno's claim looks way too explanatory of the situation, Death looks way too much like he's coaching him through, and Chris's insistence on following the Towntells in spite of the circumstances of the claim looks like Scum trying to push away the bad claim with force of personality.

Geno, what is your role?

Claimed already.

What is your role?
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Geno's claim looks way too explanatory of the situation, Death looks way too much like he's coaching him through, and Chris's insistence on following the Towntells in spite of the circumstances of the claim looks like Scum trying to push away the bad claim with force of personality.

Geno, what is your role?

You aren't really someone to talk about weird claims, considering you claimed on your first post.

What was up with that, by the way?
---

I have a ton I need to do, but I should be free tonight so I'll be around more this evevning
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Geno's claim looks way too explanatory of the situation, Death looks way too much like he's coaching him through, and Chris's insistence on following the Towntells in spite of the circumstances of the claim looks like Scum trying to push away the bad claim with force of personality.

Geno, what is your role?

1, 2, 3.
---

ScareChan posted...

I have a ton I need to do, but I should be free tonight so I'll be around more this evevning

Good, because I may need you for backup here.
---

@eaedwards6400
We could do with a new topic so we don't dumbly fill this one up.

Also I'll have to finish my catch up replied on my breaks, but rest assured I've been working on it.
---

Han you seem way off from your recent games here.
---

I only wanted to make sure the question phrased wouldnt lead to Geno spilling absolutely everything about his role too...

and he did it anyway.

(also Chris yelling at me did make me reconsider if I was doing a clever thing)
---

red13n posted...

Han you seem way off from your recent games here.

Red is Scum #4.

FD I got your back.
---

Also come on Han
you of all people should know that I dont coach scumpartners in that way.
---

htaeD posted...

I only wanted to make sure the question phrased wouldnt lead to Geno spilling absolutely everything about his role too...

and he did it anyway.

(also Chris yelling at me did make me reconsider if I was doing a clever thing)

I thought getting it out of the way early in the day was the best thing to do, didn't want us to waste all of D1 on that.

red13n posted...

Han you seem way off from your recent games here.

No he does not. He is wrong in conclusion about me but his tone matches up.

##vote: Red

Let's murder this one first.
---

Also, any word on corrik's replacement yet?
---

geno4smash4 posted...

htaeD posted...

I only wanted to make sure the question phrased wouldnt lead to Geno spilling absolutely everything about his role too...

and he did it anyway.

(also Chris yelling at me did make me reconsider if I was doing a clever thing)

I thought getting it out of the way early in the day was the best thing to do, didn't want us to waste all of D1 on that.

It's okay, you don't know that I can 100% defend you all day every day, just try to be more active please.
---

geno4smash4 posted...

htaeD posted...

I only wanted to make sure the question phrased wouldnt lead to Geno spilling absolutely everything about his role too...

and he did it anyway.

(also Chris yelling at me did make me reconsider if I was doing a clever thing)

I thought getting it out of the way early in the day was the best thing to do, didn't want us to waste all of D1 on that.

Thats also fair. I didnt need his role or character (but admittedly, newcomer villain narrowed it down a lot already)
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

geno4smash4 posted...

htaeD posted...

I only wanted to make sure the question phrased wouldnt lead to Geno spilling absolutely everything about his role too...

and he did it anyway.

(also Chris yelling at me did make me reconsider if I was doing a clever thing)

I thought getting it out of the way early in the day was the best thing to do, didn't want us to waste all of D1 on that.

It's okay, you don't know that I can 100% defend you all day every day, just try to be more active please.

Game happened to start at the same time big leaks happened for Smash so I was watching streams lol. It's 1 am here so will go to sleep soon but tomorrow I should be more active.

*your

still having problems seeing who I am talking too I see
---

red13n posted...

Han you seem way off from your recent games here.

And like, really, I've posted 3 times. Making this conclusion makes no sense at this time.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

The claim is way too bastardized to come from newbie scum tbh. That is classic 'host totally gave him that role' and to argue otherwise is silly.

No, arguing possibilities and asking questions is playing the game.

I hate to agree with Corrik, but I think this is just a case of bad newbie misplay and Scum damage control.

Yes but asking questions of a newbie player and not seeing the plain obvious is not the game. Basically you've come to a really poor conclusion based off of nothing good. I am willing to bet the instances where a newbie scum walks in and says "that's not what town's alignment is!" and "villains can be town too!" is really low. Unforced error and weird train of thought. He clearly had the perspective of "villains can be town" else why even blurt out the random stuff? No he is town and you aren't examining the game in a good way tbh
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

No he does not. He is wrong in conclusion about me but his tone matches up.

##vote: Red

Let's murder this one first.

chris the hell.

And no he doesnt. Especially when he deferred to scare there.

Han was all "listen to me han is always right" the last few games. Deferring to Scare feels like...its out of my scumbook, tbh, and the scumlist of 3 was lacking his usual "hey kill this person" confidence.

Unless he was in last game and was drastically different, but I doubt it.
---

Oh, chris ninja.

@UltimaterializerX

New topic if eaed isnt around?
---

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/77242289
---

Chris, you're acting ultra-defensive of Geno. It seems a little fishy to me. Do you have a reason as to why beyond being "obviously town"?
---

While Geno is relatively new, he is not that newbish... Chris.

Though I do believe his claim.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

And like, really, I've posted 3 times. Making this conclusion makes no sense at this time.

This is the other part of it. Because you were around earlier and posted nothing.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

Chris, you're acting ultra-defensive of Geno. It seems a little fishy to me. Do you have a reason as to why beyond being "obviously town"?

To be fair that sounds like a pretty good reason to defend someone.

Bump for reads on day 1
---

Pirate_Harris posted...

Bump for reads on day 1

Will this topic instantly be deleted soon after it hits 500, or do we get some grace period to finish the game?
---

Hbthebattle posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

Bump for reads on day 1

Will this topic instantly be deleted soon after it hits 500, or do we get some grace period to finish the game?

It won't be instantly deleted. Just archived and then after a day it will be gone
---

NO MORE POSTING IN THIS TOPIC s
---

2
---