Board 8 > Persona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut

(+) Yeah! (+)

Sheep007 posted...

Johnbobb posted...

I'd rather hear some arguments for and against sheep while he's here

wish DYL would show up; B8 specials on people that aren't around to defend themselves end up helping scum 99 times out of 100

This would not be a special. This would be someone not turning up to defend themselves and fairly getting lynched. Refusing to lynch someone just because they aren't around just sets a bad precedent and allows scum to idle.

would you still be saying though if you weren't one of the ones on the chopping block?
---

right now it seems like its

me
scare
red
sheep
ben
hb barely
death just got here
chris was here like a half hour ago where did he go?
corrik showed up just to ask if dyl claimed and then left lol

and that's it
---

Gareth presumably hasn't been replaced because nobody is willing to fill the slot. It's probably a scum one, since my PoE and experience with newer scum would indicate he's just bailed. His replacement needs to claim first thing if there is one at all.

MZero is currently fine with me as it fits with my town interpretation of him. As usual, would love more contribution from him.
---

oh also god said he'd be on soon
---

Im here
---

Johnbobb posted...

Sheep007 posted...

Johnbobb posted...

I'd rather hear some arguments for and against sheep while he's here

wish DYL would show up; B8 specials on people that aren't around to defend themselves end up helping scum 99 times out of 100

This would not be a special. This would be someone not turning up to defend themselves and fairly getting lynched. Refusing to lynch someone just because they aren't around just sets a bad precedent and allows scum to idle.

would you still be saying though if you weren't one of the ones on the chopping block?

For starters, I like to be around enough for inactivity to not come into play unless I'm almost completely checked out of a game mentally. Plus I try to be around for EoDs unless they're at completely unreasonable times for me, especially if I'm one of the potential lynches.
---

Sheep007 posted...

Gareth presumably hasn't been replaced because nobody is willing to fill the slot. It's probably a scum one, since my PoE and experience with newer scum would indicate he's just bailed. His replacement needs to claim first thing if there is one at all.

MZero is currently fine with me as it fits with my town interpretation of him. As usual, would love more contribution from him.

This is one of those situations where if I'm vigi I shoot him just to do the host a favor.

Not that you need to do that if you have a shot, but.
---

Dark Young Link posted...

For once in a game I'd love it if I didn't fucking second guess myself.

Not sure if I agree with Chris' assessment that everyone on Reg was town, though I'm not interested in voting for anyone who lynched scum's GF. That anom vote on eaed at the end makes everyone(myself included) look bad, but I'm also wary of the people on splinter lynches.

Excluding eaed obviously, that's John, red, MZero, and Corrik.

Hb [2] - (Scare), (Reg), eaed, Johnbobb
IGCD [1] - red, (Reg), (ben), (DYL)
Johnbobb [1] - MZero
Sheep [1] - Corrik

Some people are talking about SK, I'm not sure why considering there were only two deaths and ben claimed vig(And I don't see anyone accusing him of being that).

I agree with the sentiment of lynching someone on the eaed lynch, knowing that I'm included in those list of suspects. It's just the smart play.

Rereading the eaed voters later tonight. Day two should be far clearer.

That said...

##Vote: Sheep

His vote near the end sealed it for me. I had a bad feeling about him but my dumbass was like "Oh, it's day 1. You're only kind of sure he's scum, maybe blah blah blah".

Reg posted...

Sheep007 posted...

Well then, never mind...

##Unvote
##Vote: Ed

of course you'd wait until four minutes before deadline to help with it

cmon dude

This is a Scum/Scum interaction. Change my mind.

Here's the post DYL made that I didnt like. I bolded the part in particular that's fake. He would not be talking to himself and telling himself "maybe blah blah blah" JUST because it's day 1. If day 1 made him doubt scum read on Sheep, why didnt it make him doubt Ed? It's just not realistic. It's a scum "blame day 1" excuse
---

And he said day 2 should be far clearer.... IS IT CLEAR TO YOU YET, DYL???
---

Sorry just had a much longer nap than expected.

No one is thinking about moving to plum it looks like?
---

Blaming D1 is kinda meh. It's one of my favourite days when it goes well especially around EoD, and it's often got the most potential info to look back on because the good and active players (and everyone) is still alive and able to give their opinions without as many past biases.
---

I have 0 inclination to try to save DYL here.
---

Shaduln posted...

Sorry just had a much longer nap than expected.

No one is thinking about moving to plum it looks like?

I obviously would if it was to save myself but if it's between lynching Plum and DYL I would definitely pick lynching DYL
---

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/77323752
---

Shaduln posted...

Sorry just had a much longer nap than expected.

No one is thinking about moving to plum it looks like?

I would tbh. You kind of forced him into imploding. It;s pretty cut and dry to me
---

But I'm confident on DYL too
---

My only inclination is my usual reservation towards lynching someone who hasnt claimed yet.
But DYL looks the worst right now

What are the votals anyway.
---