Board 8 > Best Mainline Console Super Mario Game Day 1

Topic List
Page List: 1
Whiskey_Nick
05/14/19 5:29:55 PM
#1:


Which game is best? - Results (41 votes)
Super Mario Bros.
2.44% (1 vote)
1
Super Mario Bros. 2
2.44% (1 vote)
1
Super Mario Bros. 3
17.07% (7 votes)
7
Super Mario World
14.63% (6 votes)
6
Super Mario 64
14.63% (6 votes)
6
Super Mario Sunshine
0% (0 votes)
0
Super Mario Galaxy
14.63% (6 votes)
6
Super Mario Galaxy 2
12.2% (5 votes)
5
Super Mario 3D World
4.88% (2 votes)
2
Super Mario Odyssey
17.07% (7 votes)
7
Past Results:

MCU Final
- IW > GotG > Avengers
MCU Phase 3 - IW > Endgame > TR > CW > GotG2 > DS > BP > SMH > CM > AMatW
MCU Phase 2 - GotG > Cap2 > AntMan > AoU > Thor2 > IM3
MCU Phase 1 - Avengers > Cap > IM > Thor > IM2 > Hulk
Best Disney 89-99 - Lion King > Aladdin > Hercules > Mermaid > Beast > Notre Dame > Rescuers > Mulan > Pocahontas > Tarzan
Best non Simpson, Simpson character - Skinner > Moe > Burns > Willie > Bob > Chalmers > Flanders > Hutz > Wiggum > Ralph > McClure > Apu > Smithers > Kirk > Kent > Krusty > Milhouse > CBG > Frink > Muntz
Best AL West Team - Mariners > Astros > A's > Angels > Rangers
Best NL West Team - Rockies > Giants > Diamondbacks > Padres > Dodgers
Best AL Central Team - Tigers > White Sox > Royals > Indians > Twins
Best NL Central Team - Brewers > Pirates > Reds > Cubs > Cardinals
Best AL East Team - Blue Jays > Orioles > Yankees > Rays > Red Sox
Best NL East Team - Mets > Braves > Phillies > Nats > Marlins
Best Friend - Chandler > Ross > Monica > Phoebe > Joey > Rachel
Best Simpsons One Off - Scorpio > Grimes > Banner > Lanley > Coyote > Karl > Larry Burns > Molloy > Cooder > Bergstrom
Best Star Wars Movie - ANH > RotJ > RotS > TLJ > ESB > RO > AotC > TFA > S > PM
Best CBX 1 Seed - Squall > Sephiroth > Sora > Zero > Dante > 2B > Luigi > Geralt
Best CBX 2 Seed - Kratos > Kirby > Aqua > X > Leon Kennedy > Kazuma > Joker > Waluigi
Best CBX 3 Seed - Tifa > Yoshi > Auron > Aloy > Vivi > Alucard > Ryu > Phoenix Wright
Best CBX 4 Seed - Big Boss > Zelda > Nathan Drake > Bowser > Lara Croft > Ganondorf > Monika > Bayonetta
Best CBX 5 Seed - Spyro > Crash > Noctis > Terra > Amaterasu > Metal Sonic > Master Chief > Sans
Best CBX 6 Seed - Velvet Crowe > Commander Shepard > Yuna > Magus > Sully > Jill > Ike > GlaDOS
Best CBX 7 Seed - Tidus > Pikachu > Kefka > DeDeDe > Ellie > Shovel Knight > Shulk > Estelle
Best CBX 8 Seed - Chloe Price > Frog > Garrus > Zidane > Shadow > Neptune > Richter > Ryu H
Best CBX 9 Seed - Lightning > Knuckles > Captain Falcon > Ness > Simon Belmont > Monokuma > PT Red > Ramza
Best CBX 10 Seed - KOS-MOS > Captain Toad > Ocelot > DK > Sub Zero > L Block > Scorpion > Isaac
Best CBX 11 Seed - Godot > Joel > Mewtwo > Vincent > K Rool > Fox > Aya Brea > James Sunderland
Best CBX 12 Seed - The Boss > Cecil > Charizard > Pac-Man > Goro > Master Hand > Chun-Li > Draven
Best CBX 13 Seed - Ridley > Metal Man > Wario > Ezio > Neku > Tails > Riku > Gordon Freeman
Best CBX 14 Seed - Lloyd Irving > Chris Redfield > Lucina > Princess Peach > Yu Narukami > Shantae > D.Va > Geno
Best CBX 15 Seed - Aerith > Bomberman > John Marston > Guile > Dragonborn > Claire Redfield > Isabelle > Quiet
Best CBX 16 Seed - Miles Edgeworth > Rosalina > Hat Kid > Cuphead > Albert Wesker > Primrose > Ryo Hazuki > Cayde-6
---
I am Nick. Go Sens, Bills, Blue Jays! Advokaiser is a Guru
UotY 2015, You should listen to The Show w/ Ngamer and Yoblazer
... Copied to Clipboard!
Whiskey_Nick
05/14/19 5:30:00 PM
#2:


Best Noble Niner - Mario > Solid Snake > Cloud > Mega Man > Crono > Sonic > Samus > Link > Sephiroth
Best Punch Out NES Opponent - Soda Popinski > King Hippo > Super Macho Man > Bald Bull > Glass Joe > Von Kaiser > Piston Honda > Don Flamenco > Great Tiger > Mr. Sandman
Best FF7 Playable Character - Cloud > Cid > Red XIII > Tifa > Barret > Vincent > Aeris > Yuffie > Cait Sith
Best Season 1 Digimon - Gomamon > Gatomon > Gabumon > Tentomon > Agumon > Patamon > Palmon > Biyomon
Best MMX Maverick - Storm Eagle > Armored Armadillo > Chill Penguin > Spark Mandrill > Boomer Kuwanger > Launch Octopus > Flame Mammoth > Sting Chameleon
Best Koopa Kid - Ludwig > Roy > Larry > Lemmy > Iggy > Wendy > Bowser Jr > Morton
---
I am Nick. Go Sens, Bills, Blue Jays! Advokaiser is a Guru
UotY 2015, You should listen to The Show w/ Ngamer and Yoblazer
... Copied to Clipboard!
LeonhartFour
05/14/19 5:32:31 PM
#3:


Galaxy 2 > Galaxy 1 > Mario 3 > Mario World > Odyssey > Mario 64 > Mario 1 > Mario 2 > Sunshine

Never played 3D World.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
TheCodeisBosco
05/14/19 5:35:27 PM
#4:


I've never played Super Mario Galaxy 2. I've also played too little of 3D World so far to properly judge it - though I really dig what I have played. That said, here's my ranking.

SMB1 > Odyssey > SM64 > SMB3 > SMB2 > Galaxy > World > Sunshine
---
Now crack that combination:
27 99 23.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Underleveled
05/14/19 5:37:22 PM
#5:


Do NSMBW and NSMBU not count?
---
darkx
Score: There goes bracket
... Copied to Clipboard!
LeonhartFour
05/14/19 5:40:16 PM
#6:


Underleveled posted...
Do NSMBW and NSMBU not count?


Something had to be cut when you can only fit ten options.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Sheep007
05/14/19 5:47:13 PM
#7:


LeonhartFour posted...
Galaxy 2 > Galaxy 1 > Mario 3 > Mario World > Odyssey > Mario 64 > Mario 1 > Mario 2 > Sunshine

Never played 3D World.

This except also never played Odyssey, 64 swapped with 3 and Sunshine ahead of 1 and 2.
---
Perhaps the golden rock was inside us all along.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Xiahou Shake
05/14/19 5:52:43 PM
#8:


Odyssey > Galaxy 2 > SMB3 > World > 64 > Galaxy 1 > Sunshine > 1 > 2
---
Let the voice of love take you higher,
With this gathering power, go beyond even time!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Ngamer64
05/14/19 6:13:48 PM
#9:


I've learned to NEVER count out Super Mario Sunshine in a GameFAQs poll.


---
Advo bested even The Show hosts in 2018, yowza!
board8.wikia.com | thengamer.com/xstats
... Copied to Clipboard!
KCF0107
05/14/19 6:20:09 PM
#10:


World > SMB3 >= SMB1 >= 64 >= Galaxy 2 >= Galaxy 1 >= 3D World > SMB2 > Sunshine

Yet to play Odyssey

I would rate any game from SMB3 through 3D World a 9-9.5 on a 10 point scale, so it is hard to rank them.
---
KCF can't actually be a real person but he is - greengravy
https://imgur.com/VfpY7tg
... Copied to Clipboard!
MetalmindStats
05/14/19 6:21:11 PM
#11:


64 for the nostalgia. 3 is a very close second, though.
---
Hail the reigning Guru champ, Advokaiser!
You proved yourself more statistically metal-minded than I ever have been - well done!
... Copied to Clipboard!
KokoroAkechi
05/14/19 6:22:20 PM
#12:


It's 3 and I don't think it's really close. I would say the next closest is World but I think the overall design in 3 and overall average difficulty for the audience is pretty much perfect. I think World is a great game, but when I directly compare the two I think 3 is just clearly better.
---
Kokoro's Anime Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCaIA0gY11FQ_Zh6kLSam5OA
Updated: July 27th, 2016.
... Copied to Clipboard!
FakeAccount3000
05/14/19 6:29:57 PM
#13:


More people are saying Odyssey than I expected. It really makes me want to try it. Im not sure it will top Super Mario Bros. 3 for me but thats still some high praise that leaves me hoping to be impressed.
---
Dokkan Battle ID:3175154559 JPN Dokkan Battle ID1270165763
Dragon Ball Legends ID brggv8m3
... Copied to Clipboard!
swirIdude
05/14/19 6:35:18 PM
#14:


Too much love for Odyssey in this poll, but I'm not surprised.
---
Advokaiser picked Cloud in Guru and rained on my bracket.
At least I finished 20th overall!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Shonen_Bat
05/14/19 6:40:08 PM
#15:


Galaxy > Odyssey > 3 > Galaxy 2 > 3D World > World > 64 > Sunshine > Mario 2 > Mario 1

Everything in the top half is amazing and I could see any of the top 3 being #1. Not as enthusiastic about the rest of the list but they're still good games.

I can respect how big of a deal the original Mario Bros was but given the choice I'd rather play any of the others.
---
Hello again.
... Copied to Clipboard!
tennisboy213
05/15/19 5:34:18 AM
#16:


up
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1