Current Events > The "Mandela Effect" about Darth Vader's line makes me mad.

Topic List	Page List: 1
Damn_Underscore 06/09/19 5:19:02 PM #1:	Why would he say "Luke I am your father" when he is refuting a statement made by Luke. "Luke I am your father" would only make sense if he said it out of nowhere, which doesn't make sense to begin with. --- Shenmue II = best game of all time Shenmue = 2nd best game of all time <cite>Damn_Underscore posted [p:923020568] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>Why would he say "Luke I am your father" when he is refuting a statement made by Luke. "Luke I am your father" would only make sense if he said it out of nowhere, which doesn't make sense to begin with.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
0xDEFECADE 06/09/19 5:20:04 PM #2:	that isn't what he says? --- 1101 1110 1111 1110 1100 1010 1101 1110 <cite>0xDEFECADE posted [p:923020641] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>that isn't what he says?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Gafemage 06/09/19 5:21:17 PM #3:	It is pretty weird how seemingly 80% of people who've seen the movie adhere to a misquote that sounds considerably dumber than the actual line. --- https://imgur.com/1EOFcjn https://imgur.com/epjd8zk <cite>Gafemage posted [p:923020698] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>It is pretty weird how seemingly 80% of people who've seen the movie adhere to a misquote that sounds considerably dumber than the actual line.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Duncanwii 06/09/19 5:21:21 PM #4:	0xDEFECADE posted... that isn't what he says? He says No, I am your father IIRC. --- Hello, I like video games and comedies. Let's be friends. :) <cite>Duncanwii posted [p:923020705] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote><cite>0xDEFECADE posted...</cite> <quote>that isn't what he says?</quote> He says No, I am your father IIRC.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Umbreon 06/09/19 5:21:41 PM #5:	A lot of people who quote that probably didn't see the actual movie. --- This is a mobile account, forgive any errors. ~DYL~ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kTEX3YdEi7s <cite>Umbreon posted [p:923020735] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>A lot of people who quote that probably didn't see the actual movie.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Damn_Underscore 06/09/19 5:22:04 PM #6:	0xDEFECADE posted... that isn't what he says? The conversation is (maybe not exact) "Obi-Wan never told you about your father" "He told me enough. He told me you killed him." "No, I am your father." - Why would he say "Luke I am your father" there? --- Shenmue II = best game of all time Shenmue = 2nd best game of all time <cite>Damn_Underscore posted [p:923020770] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote><cite>0xDEFECADE posted...</cite> <quote>that isn't what he says?</quote> The conversation is (maybe not exact) "Obi-Wan never told you about your father" "He told me enough. He told me you killed him." "No, I am your father." - Why would he say "Luke I am your father" there?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Gafemage 06/09/19 5:22:07 PM #7:	0xDEFECADE posted... that isn't what he says? The actual line is "no, I am your father". The common misquote is "Luke, I am your father". ~~I think~~ --- https://imgur.com/1EOFcjn https://imgur.com/epjd8zk <cite>Gafemage posted [p:923020774] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote><cite>0xDEFECADE posted...</cite> <quote>that isn't what he says?</quote> The actual line is "no, I am your father". The common misquote is "Luke, I am your father". I think</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
0xDEFECADE 06/09/19 5:23:22 PM #8:	darn I just wanted to see if youd get riled up. good to know though because it was a long time ago --- 1101 1110 1111 1110 1100 1010 1101 1110 <cite>0xDEFECADE posted [p:923020857] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>darn I just wanted to see if youd get riled up. good to know though because it was a long time ago</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
The Admiral 06/09/19 5:25:07 PM #9:	Does anyone actually believe that was the line? I thought that was just people trolling. --- - The Admiral <cite>The Admiral posted [p:923020952] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>Does anyone actually believe that was the line? I thought that was just people trolling.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Schwarz 06/09/19 5:26:13 PM #10:	Tommy Boy is probably partly to blame for this one --- I'm a loner, Dottie. A rebel. <cite>Schwarz posted [p:923021010] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>Tommy Boy is probably partly to blame for this one</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Skye Reynolds 06/09/19 5:29:33 PM #11:	It's from people quoting the movie in other movies and TV shows. By adding Luke, you get that it's directly referencing Star Wars. It wouldn't make sense to have a goof-off speaking into a fan, "No, I am your father." Like, what? Is he telling the fan he's the fan's father? By adding the name drop, we know it's referencing something even if you're the only person who's never seen Star Wars. It also keeps them from any copyright problems which might come from directly lifting the line. Luke is a common name, so they could always defend that they're talking about someone else who just happens to be named Luke. It's like Wizard of Oz. A character says "fly, my pretties" or "I have a strange feeling we're not in Kansas," and you know they're referencing Wizard of Oz even though neither line was spoken. <cite>Skye Reynolds posted [p:923021237] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>It's from people quoting the movie in other movies and TV shows. By adding Luke, you get that it's directly referencing Star Wars. It wouldn't make sense to have a goof-off speaking into a fan, "No, I am your father." Like, what? Is he telling the fan he's the fan's father? By adding the name drop, we know it's referencing something even if you're the only person who's never seen Star Wars. It also keeps them from any copyright problems which might come from directly lifting the line. Luke is a common name, so they could always defend that they're talking about someone else who just happens to be named Luke. It's like Wizard of Oz. A character says "fly, my pretties" or "I have a strange feeling we're not in Kansas," and you know they're referencing Wizard of Oz even though neither line was spoken.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
creativeme 06/09/19 5:35:30 PM #12:	Schwarz posted... Tommy Boy is probably partly to blame for this one yea i think this is some of the problem. this and most people just never really seeing the original movie or not seeing it in decades and just going with the common misconception. <cite>creativeme posted [p:923021528] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote><cite>Schwarz posted...</cite> <quote>Tommy Boy is probably partly to blame for this one</quote> yea i think this is some of the problem. this and most people just never really seeing the original movie or not seeing it in decades and just going with the common misconception.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
The Popo 06/09/19 5:37:08 PM #13:	https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BEMCe6svqd8" data-time=" --- Live action Hungry Hungry Hippos though, now that was a sport. ~Aeon Azuran <cite>The Popo posted [p:923021650] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BEMCe6svqd8" data-time="</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Sir Will 06/09/19 5:37:47 PM #14:	Luke makes for a better quote. It gives context. --- River Song: Well, I was off to this gay gypsy bar mitzvah for the disabled when I thought 'Gosh, the Third Reich's a bit rubbish, I think i'll kill the Fuhrer' <cite>Sir Will posted [p:923021710] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>Luke makes for a better quote. It gives context.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Antifar 06/09/19 5:38:17 PM #15:	The Admiral posted... Does anyone actually believe that was the line? I thought that was just people trolling. I definitely grew up thinking it was Luke --- kin to all that throbs <cite>Antifar posted [p:923021759] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote><cite>The Admiral posted...</cite> <quote>Does anyone actually believe that was the line? I thought that was just people trolling.</quote> I definitely grew up thinking it was Luke</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Guerrilla Soldier 06/09/19 5:38:59 PM #16:	https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YOOb_o06adA" data-time="&start=11 --- Disclaimer: There's a good chance the above post could be sarcasm. Die-hard Oakland A's fan --- Keep the A's in Oakland! <cite>Guerrilla Soldier posted [p:923021829] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YOOb_o06adA" data-time="&start=11</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ROBANN_88 06/09/19 5:39:14 PM #17:	i think people only quote it as "Luke" because that makes it much clearer what reference you are making if said without any other context --- https://imgur.com/cUNC8DI <cite>ROBANN_88 posted [p:923021859] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>i think people only quote it as "Luke" because that makes it much clearer what reference you are making if said without any other context</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Flockaveli 06/09/19 5:39:18 PM #18:	You killed my father. No, I am your father. --- I'm in Chicago, I'm shaking my head. <cite>Flockaveli posted [p:923021867] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>You killed my father. No, I am your father.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
CountDog 06/09/19 5:40:29 PM #19:	Do people really not watch it AND misquote it? --- http://kinomania.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/gran-torino-clint-eastwood.jpg http://verleih.polyfilm.at/how_arnold_won_the_west/arnold%20thumbs%20up.jpg <cite>CountDog posted [p:923021987] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>Do people really not watch it AND misquote it?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Skye Reynolds 06/09/19 5:45:34 PM #20:	The Admiral posted... Does anyone actually believe that was the line? I thought that was just people trolling. I've seen people try to argue that it was, "No, Luke. I am your father." <cite>Skye Reynolds posted [p:923022405] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote><cite>The Admiral posted...</cite> <quote>Does anyone actually believe that was the line? I thought that was just people trolling.</quote> I've seen people try to argue that it was, "No, Luke. I am your father."</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Funkydog 06/09/19 5:45:48 PM #21:	You missing out the comma in the incorrect quote but not the right one irks me far more than it should. --- https://imgur.com/BGbZK <cite>Funkydog posted [p:923022421] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>You missing out the comma in the incorrect quote but not the right one irks me far more than it should.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
The Admiral 06/09/19 5:46:23 PM #22:	Skye Reynolds posted... The Admiral posted... Does anyone actually believe that was the line? I thought that was just people trolling. I've seen people try to argue that it was, "No, Luke. I am your father." Rotten Tomatoes actually lists that as the quote. Or, rather, one of like three versions of that quote. --- - The Admiral <cite>The Admiral posted [p:923022480] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote><cite>Skye Reynolds posted...</cite> <quote><cite>The Admiral posted...</cite> <quote>Does anyone actually believe that was the line? I thought that was just people trolling.</quote> I've seen people try to argue that it was, "No, Luke. I am your father."</quote> Rotten Tomatoes actually lists that as the quote. Or, rather, one of like three versions of that quote.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Tyranthraxus 06/09/19 5:48:23 PM #23:	Flockaveli posted... You killed my father. No, I am your father. That's not what he says. "Obi-Wan never told you what happened to your father." "He told me enough! He told me you killed him!" "No, I am your father." --- It says right here in Matthew 16:4 "Jesus doth not need a giant Mecha." https://imgur.com/dQgC4kv <cite>Tyranthraxus posted [p:923022632] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote><cite>Flockaveli posted...</cite> <quote>You killed my father. No, I am your father.</quote> That's not what he says. "Obi-Wan never told you what happened to your father." "He told me enough! He told me you killed him!" "No, I am your father."</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
trappedunderice 06/09/19 5:51:06 PM #24:	https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GQ1mmkKb_BQ" data-time=" --- He should have armed himself if he's gonna decorate his saloon with my friend. <cite>trappedunderice posted [p:923022826] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GQ1mmkKb_BQ" data-time="</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Flockaveli 06/09/19 6:04:21 PM #25:	Tyranthraxus posted... Flockaveli posted... You killed my father. No, I am your father. That's not what he says. "Obi-Wan never told you what happened to your father." "He told me enough! He told me you killed him!" "No, I am your father." Yeah that sounds more right. --- I'm in Chicago, I'm shaking my head. <cite>Flockaveli posted [p:923023701] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote><cite>Tyranthraxus posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Flockaveli posted...</cite> <quote>You killed my father. No, I am your father.</quote> That's not what he says. "Obi-Wan never told you what happened to your father." "He told me enough! He told me you killed him!" "No, I am your father."</quote> Yeah that sounds more right.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
CellBlock7 06/09/19 6:06:38 PM #26:	Im still pissed there apparently never was a genie movie with Sinbad in it. --- A Medicore Time with Tom & Dan BDM 4 Life <cite>CellBlock7 posted [p:923023834] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>Im still pissed there apparently never was a genie movie with Sinbad in it.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Ryo_the_Inferno 06/09/19 6:09:33 PM #27:	I've thought about the logistics of this. This is just my theory, but I'm pretty sure it's accurate. Basically, the movie came out and the line was "No, I am your father". Then, when people started referencing it they added "Luke" to the phrase, whether consciously or unconsciously, to show that the phrase was a reference to the new Star Wars movie that the line was from. It's not really "mandela effect". It's just more people recognize the line as a reference to Star Wars than they recognize it as a line from Star Wars. --- 3DS FC: 3222-6077-2683 <cite>Ryo_the_Inferno posted [p:923024034] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>I've thought about the logistics of this. This is just my theory, but I'm pretty sure it's accurate. Basically, the movie came out and the line was "No, I am your father". Then, when people started referencing it they added "Luke" to the phrase, whether consciously or unconsciously, to show that the phrase was a reference to the new Star Wars movie that the line was from. It's not really "mandela effect". It's just more people recognize the line as a reference to Star Wars than they recognize it as a line from Star Wars.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Wetterdew 06/09/19 6:17:37 PM #28:	It makes sense that people misquote it-- out of context, saying "no, I am your father" doesn't make sense since the "no" implies there was something he is denying. Without the context, I can see why people would leave out the "no" --- Touch fuzzy get dizzy. <cite>Wetterdew posted [p:923024526] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>It makes sense that people misquote it-- out of context, saying "no, I am your father" doesn't make sense since the "no" implies there was something he is denying. Without the context, I can see why people would leave out the "no"</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Guide 06/12/19 12:42:32 AM #29:	Umbreon posted... A lot of people who quote that probably didn't see the actual movie. They would've had to get from people who had seen the movie, though. --- [break the meta] https://youtu.be/Acn5IptKWQU <cite>Guide posted [p:923173517] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote><cite>Umbreon posted...</cite> <quote>A lot of people who quote that probably didn't see the actual movie.</quote> They would've had to get from people who had seen the movie, though.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
scar the 1 06/12/19 1:02:17 AM #30:	As a sub point, it's also weird how people think the emphasis lies on "am". As we can hear in the clip above, it's not "I am your father", it's "I am your father". --- Stop being so aggressively argumentative for no reason. - UnfairRepresent <cite>scar the 1 posted [p:923174225] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>As a sub point, it's also weird how people think the emphasis lies on "am". As we can hear in the clip above, it's not "I am your father", it's "I am your father".</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Bluharvest 06/12/19 1:06:05 AM #31:	I always thought it was "no, luke, I am your father" --- http://gamefaqs.com/916401/b/- \|Come on down for drinks and good company\| <cite>Bluharvest posted [p:923174360] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>I always thought it was "no, luke, I am your father"</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
008Zulu 06/12/19 1:19:32 AM #32:	There are only two people in that scene. Why would anyone somehow think that Vader was talking to someone else? --- Time is a funny thing. There is always too much of it, except when you need it the most. Then there is never enough. <cite>008Zulu posted [p:923174851] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>There are only two people in that scene. Why would anyone somehow think that Vader was talking to someone else?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Verdekal 06/12/19 1:23:56 AM #33:	Look, I have your fodder. --- Don't tease the octopus, kids! <cite>Verdekal posted [p:923174987] in The "... [t:77774128]...</cite> <quote>Look, I have your fodder.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1

Current Events > The "Mandela Effect" about Darth Vader's line makes me mad. (+) Yeah! (+)

Current Events > The "Mandela Effect" about Darth Vader's line makes me mad.