Favorite? Lavagulin Ardbeg Laphroaig Other? Vote View Results Favorite? - Results (0 votes) Lavagulin % (0 votes) 0 Ardbeg % (0 votes) 0 Laphroaig % (0 votes) 0 Other? % (0 votes) 0 Show Voting Form Been on a Scotch kick lately. Ive enjoyed tastings from all the big 3 Islays but am hard pressed to pick a favorite. I think its a tossup between Lavagulin and Ardbeg, but theyre all so different its hard to choose.