Board 8 > Eff 2019 Mafia: Topic 4 - The Oscars That Nobody Hosted

(+) Yeah! (+)

Nvm answered my own question it was still HB lol

---

Based on the play of Lea Chris and Puns I don't believe they are in a chat group.

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Nvm answered my own question it was still HB lol

So can you answer my questions? What makes you have a scum lean on me? Did you read Chris' post about me and my response to it?

---

Puns denied me killing igcd or scare last night. He is probably scum!

---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Well I was asked last night my thoughts on Mzero and I didn't have any but him going from voting red to "Chris why didn't you save red" is just plain funny. MI is probably town barring hilarity and there are only 3 people on red due to MI deciding that he was awesome at a game he clearly is not awesome at oh sorry that was critique I am now going to be accused of being a hater.

Also Scare is just straight up spinning falsehoods about Red. Him going "WHERE DID I GO WRONG!?" when I am right here being like "I kept pointing out small things all day that made Red likely town."

I felt I was more engaged with him than you were yesterday based on your own statements of how you were feeling. And I had questions for you about him I dont recall you responding too

Also boom bye scum was an mu meme :p

---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

So can you answer my questions? What makes you have a scum lean on me? Did you read Chris' post about me and my response to it?

Well i didnt like some of your interactions yesterday but i dont know if thats really enough though i did like your response to chris.. i drop it for now. I think ill need to go do some re reading a bit i feel like im still behind even tough i read...

##unvote: God

---

So we have a mayor and a politician??


---

Leanansidhe posted...

I am Elijah Cummings, TOWN Politician

I can recruit two players to form a subcommittee. The subcommittee can then vote on who to ~bonus lynch~. I had a shortlist of players I like talking to and then picked some of them based on vague town feelings or capacity for intrigue. I really like this minigame that's created, it reminds me of Resistance or the like. Will Chris or Puns be scum and tip their hands by being scummy about their kill targets, or by using their secret knowledge?! So far no.

So beware, lest you find yourself DAY VIGGED by the Cabal

##Vote: IGCD

...and you didn't pick me and mi

How dare you

---

Yes and a quadvoter who can apparently do it more then once??

Or maybe not? Havent got a vote count yet to see if thar actually is a thing

---

So I wasnt going to say anything because I figured it was more of a trap by chris again but lea saying it with that much detail makes me surprised

And being the number 1 guy on masonry stuff I would like to ask you guys to same time something to confirm

---

Leanansidhe posted...

You and MI barely talk on Discord when we played Diplomacy, and also were scummy D1 :(
I definitely thought when I got this role that'd what it'd be tho. Funny how me and MI can both basically control who gets lynched. So poetic.

Okay that game I partially didnt understand and then it was like no fun after so while fair also bad barometer :(

---

gonna wait on puns to confirm this tbh

Still seems fake.

---

Fastbreak posted...

So I wasnt going to say anything because I figured it was more of a trap by chris again but lea saying it with that much detail makes me surprised

And being the number 1 guy on masonry stuff I would like to ask you guys to same time something to confirm

What good does same time confirming do?

---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

What good does same time confirming do?

If they are actually in a chat or not

You have seen me and ben run around enough to know it can be useful to know

---

Fastbreak posted...

If they are actually in a chat or not

You have seen me and ben run around enough to know it can be useful to know

Ok, but them being in a chat is not alignment indicative.

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

It might be a silly read but you know who wanted to kill 5tar majority of the Day God. So maybe god still wanted to kill 5tar.. might be the best explanation unless maybe they guessed he was a power player and guessed wrong?

Not silly. Just bad.

Its just bad logic really.

---

If they do end up being in a chat what is your opinion in where it puts them alignment wise?

---

Subcommittees can be made up of dems and Republicans. So really there is no reason to believe that the threesom is all one alignment.

Assuming we are to believe this. Mind you, faking a masonry is one thing, faking three is way too big of a gamble.

---

Hey Lea, does your "lynch" end the day?

---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Ok, but them being in a chat is not alignment indicative.

They made it sound like its permanent though and having a confirmed townie voice active through eventual death is good to know

Remember when dead chris was talking through alive han and none of us knew so nobody paid extra attention

---

I can't talk after death unfortunately.

---

Obellisk posted...

Hey Lea, does your "lynch" end the day?

No

---

turbopuns3 posted...

Is there a piece missing from that last sentenced, I'm confused

By the way let's say this trio thing is a thing right now

Puns why are you calling attention to this?

---

Obellisk posted...

Subcommittees can be made up of dems and Republicans. So really there is no reason to believe that the threesom is all one alignment.

Assuming we are to believe this. Mind you, faking a masonry is one thing, faking three is way too big of a gamble.

If they are all scum and they bank on town believing this, it gets 2 of them a free pass when one is lynched. I don't see why they would reveal this as town because on the flip side it gives scum ammunition to lynch them all in an attempt to get the scum in the trio.

---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

No

Do you all three have to be unanimous?

---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

If they are all scum and they bank on town believing this, it gets 2 of them a free pass when one is lynched. I don't see why they would reveal this as town because on the flip side it gives scum ammunition to lynch them all in an attempt to get the scum in the trio.

Are you saying it's a ploy and scum extra kill is a free lynch.?

---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I can't talk after death unfortunately.

Have your fun then

---

Fastbreak posted...

Have your fun then

There was an Oh at the beginning there that got deleted somehow

---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

If they are all scum and they bank on town believing this, it gets 2 of them a free pass when one is lynched. I don't see why they would reveal this as town because on the flip side it gives scum ammunition to lynch them all in an attempt to get the scum in the trio.

There's no way scum Chris/Lea/Puns all get together and decide that's the way they want to play the game.

---

Obellisk posted...

Do you all three have to be unanimous?

Yes

---

Obellisk posted...

Are you saying it's a ploy and scum extra kill is a free lynch.?

We don't know for sure there is an extra lynch yet and if there is, I don't see why it couldn't be their extra kill. I only saw 1 kill from night 1 and no one has come forth to claim being poisoned or anything like to show a different version of an extra kill.

---

Meow1000 posted...

There's no way scum Chris/Lea/Puns all get together and decide that's the way they want to play the game.

What makes you so sure of this. The beginning of the game basically consisted of everyone bragging about the times they were scum and pulled ridiculous gambits to win games. This falls directly into that theme.

---

I want to point out that I wasn't bragging about my past escapades. I was actually just complaining that because of that event nobody ever wants to believe me about even the most mundane things

Anyway yeah I was recruited into a chat by lea, and chris is there also

I was mostly just rusing with the vote on Chris there, to stir up reactions and give him something to work with to leverage into some fun secret dayvig type play where we used the lynch without revealing that anyone other than Chris was involved

I did not expect him to blow up and spoil one of the most fun things ever. Boo.

I was gonna say that this is totally something lea and puns would do and *maybe* could convince chris to do

But I dont think it's a scum trio so no sense in playing that game now

---

But why did you question Lea ambiguously dropping both your names in the topic?


---

Obellisk posted...

Assuming we are to believe this. Mind you, faking a masonry is one thing, faking three is way too big of a gamble.

How is faking a three-way Masonry any different from faking a two-way? You just say "hey, I recruited these guys into a mason chat" and then they both go along with it.

turbopuns3 posted...

I want to point out that I wasn't bragging about my past escapades. I was actually just complaining that because of that event nobody ever wants to believe me about even the most mundane things

Anyway yeah I was recruited into a chat by lea, and chris is there also

So why do your existing posts on the day seem counter to this informatino?

---

Best case scenario is they are scum and waste the extra kill... I mean lynch on me.

---

I got ninja'd.

Anyway, this is an interesting way to balance Scum extra kill.

---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

So why do your existing posts on the day seem counter to this informatino?

How are they counter? I don't know either of their alignments

HanOfTheNekos posted...

How is faking a three-way Masonry any different from faking a two-way? You just say "hey, I recruited these guys into a mason chat" and then they both go along with it.

You are doubling up on people playing along. There is a greater risk is what I'm saying.

---

You could always fake one with me

I'll never say no

And the confirm word is always popcorn

---

Meow1000 posted...

But why did you question Lea ambiguously dropping both your names in the topic?

I don't know Lea's alignment, Lea contradicted something she said previously about her read of me, that seemed odd to me, so I asked about it? I don't see what the private chat has to do with it

turbopuns3 posted...

I don't know Lea's alignment, Lea contradicted something she said previously about her read of me, that seemed odd to me, so I asked about it? I don't see what the private chat has to do with it

It looks like Lea wasn't doing it to call either of you by an alignment, she was blatantly hinting what she was going to later claim with an ambiguous statement.

---

The hunch by the way was the past several times I've seen Chris be town he has had some write-up at the start of day 2 even though he expects to be dead a lot of the time.

Here not only did he not have a write up, but he didn't even so much as remark on the fact that he was alive at all. Neither in game nor in the chat