Board 8 > Percussion Mafia Topic 8 - Day 4 starts here

(+) Yeah! (+)

Though a claim wouldn't hurt anything, maybe you can explain it better.

---

Basically, Lea claimed stump. Mzero claimed 1 shot Deathproof. Claims seem at odds. Lea tried to get us to Lynch herself instead of scum on a scum-scum Lynch then tried to detail the Lynch elsewhere.

Then Lea claimed there was no safe list randomly.

Then Lea claimed stump, failed miserably at the mechanics of what the role entails, and eventually got it figured out.

Add that to doing shit all as a player the whole game also.

---

DamionDL posted...

Though a claim wouldn't hurt anything, maybe you can explain it better.

it seems she said it how it is. essentially becomes tree stump after death, can continue to post but can't vote or be targeted or anything. lasts for two days.

Plus, the cop was shot last night and it is theorized if godfather was left they might have left the cop alive to try and scan the godfather inno and killed tange instead to Ace in the hole to victory. If alrdy scanned inno, more incentive to shoot him.

---

Dels posted...

interesting to see people shading an inno scanned person then!

but ok

what's the deal with panth?

We're at the point in the game where there's decent likelihood of someone with a beneficial scan being scum, and Lea's play was awful.

---

lea what did you do >_>

this role isn't that hard to understand

Dels posted...

it seems she said it how it is. essentially becomes tree stump after death, can continue to post but can't vote or be targeted or anything. lasts for two days.

She never mentioned the role having a time limit... But I feel like scum Dels would have no reason to say something different from her.

---

Dels posted...

lea what did you do >_>

this role isn't that hard to understand

then can you explain it to us

---

Dels posted...

lea what did you do >_>

this role isn't that hard to understand

Lea spent most of the game wanting to be lynched and was playing in an actively anti-town manner for much of it.

---

Hey Tange, if you're around, I'm still interested to know why you immediately claimed your scans on Panth instead of letting him give one more claim.

---

Lea's play makes even less since if she dies for good after two days tbh.

---

Dels posted...

lea what did you do >_>

this role isn't that hard to understand

She said town wouldn't lose if it was 2-2 town to scum if she was dead and one of the two. Then I was like yes they would in every game possible even if u weren't dead... And town would lose if it is 3-2 town to scum with Lea as a dead town involved.

Then she was like oh yeah sure that's how it works.

---

DoubleTangicide posted...

then can you explain it to us

i... just did?

Okay o dont like being called somone who fell off a cliff. It was fucking easter weekend and i was off of work i wanted to spend time with my wife ao sue me. Ive been on the over night shift at work and playing at work i was trying to be active last night but was actually busy for the first time since Covid 19 has started!

Anyways i really dislike Plum and 5tars play. I feel like that the attack brought on to me from that slot has been nothing but an attempt to get me misslynched the facts have been wrong, refusing to accept that i have been confirmed my role but then backed tracked to just say no no just confirmed tracker is all i meant.

Plum also came in with the same claim as uwimm and it didnt feel genuine they came up with a quick claim beacuse i caught them doing to lea. I dont really like the 2nd motion detector claim either

---

Also just for transparency's sake, I am the only unclaimed in the game despite the fact that all the other unclaimed claimed yesterday.

Uwnim and Plum are claimed motion detectors (Day 2, Day 3)
Sultan is claimed tracker (Day 1)
Tange is claimed detective (Day 3)
Corrk is claimed "Bomb Scanner" (I forget the actual name of the role he claimed) (Day 3)
MZero is claimed "Deathproof". Hinted at a couple of points, claimed Day 3. Says he has a 1-time immunity to any form of dying.
Death claimed miller to motion detectors (Day 3)
Damion claimed vanilla (Day 3)
I claimed confirmable, but I see no reason to claim any further (Day 3)
Panthera is scum.
You're either scum or the role Lea claimed.

I'm missing someone. We have 12 in the game, but that's 11 players.

---

Oh DYL. DYL has some weirdo power that lets him post at night, which he has completely wasted twice, and has used shortly after all three deadlines despite not being present anywhere close to any of them.

---

Also dont nessisarily like deaths claim either why wait that long after 2 people claimed tracking/motion to claim essentially a miller

---

Also Plum and I both replaced into the game at the start of Day 3. I replaced Lolo, who had two posts the entire game, and Plum replaced 5tar, who hadn't posted since early/middle Day 1.

---

Claimed actions that I think are accurate:

Scare claimed an innocent scan on Damion and Lea
Sultan claimed redirected to Uwnim night 1. Tracked Uwnim to Tange. Claimed he tracked Plum to Lea night 2. Claimed he tracked Scare to Plum last night.
Uwnim claimed motion on Tange night 1 (Chris is known to have targeted Tange night 1). Claimed no motion on DYL night 2. Claimed no motion on Damion last night.
Tange confirmed Sultan is "tracker" on night 1 (non-alignment specific scan). Failed night 2 on Scare due to Balla. Confirmed Panthera is not the role he claimed night 3.
Plum claimed no action on night 1, motion on Lea night 2 (Scare claimed he scanned her after this claim), and no motion on Lea night 3.
Corrik claims he was redirected to Uwnim night 1, no bomb. Claims he found a bomb on MZero night 2. Claims no bomb on Sultan night 3.

I think this is accurate.

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Also dont nessisarily like deaths claim either why wait that long after 2 people claimed tracking/motion to claim essentially a miller

Death and Panthera both claimed late, though Panthera's was first. Panthera basically claimed a role that totally invalidated motion detectors and was miller to tracker.

---

Corrik7 posted...

Then Lea claimed stump, failed miserably at the mechanics of what the role entails, and eventually got it figured out.

The one thing that worries me is the idea that intentionally botching the claim does make sense with the fact that she's been acting like she wants to be lynched.

---

Also, Crescent claims to not move... and to be a confirmable role... but hasn't claimed her actual role so the confirmability of it is obviously in question.

---

I am relatively miffed that Mzero and Lea haven't gone after each other this game. I can't see their roles existing together.


---

We arent aloud to use replace metta are we?

---

I wouldn't, Sultan. Unless it's just on mindset meta. Not if it's like outside the game knowledge meta.

---

Its more mindset but i dont wanna accident get modkilled for something stupid

But dels exsplained that role a bit better and i do like that maybe just more or less liking dels a bit

---

Corrik7 posted...

I am relatively miffed that Mzero and Lea haven't gone after each other this game. I can't see their roles existing together.

It's part of why I'm inclined MZero sooner rather than later.

I'm going to fish up a post I made yesterday

---

Crescent-Moon posted... I'm now of the mindset to ignore claims almost entirely and focus the lynch on the player instead. This hasn't only gotten us more or less nowhere, its completely killed game activity because everyone is on information overload. I didn't even remember Sultan claimed a track on Plum until he reminded us a topic later. The first post of the previous page was 14 hours ago. This is not a good thing.

There is something that's been bugging me since yesterday though, especially now that MZero fully elaborated on his claim. Lea's claiming a technically confirmable role that makes no sense for scum to have. MZero is claiming a theoretically confirmable role I don't see scum MZero being bold enough to fakeclaim that should be banned as a a scum role. I immediately considered myself confirmable town when I replaced in because my confirmable power should also be banned as a scum role.

Regardless, at this point I wouldn't be surprised if scum has some sort of monster role out there they should have no business having. I'm thinking "Should be banned as a scum role" probably means nothing to this game. There's no way to make sense of the claiming in this game, and there's not going to be one.

Tange, I'd like you to restate why you're so sure on Scare. You're the only one who seems to be exuding confidence. I feel like testing if its overconfidence.

Corrik is the only one to claim a targeting role, but not claim what the role is, by the way. Keep that in mind if all the claimed ones end up dead and town.

I bolded the important part out of this. Corrik is calling attention to their two claims not meshing up well and that doesn't even factor me in.


---

Well, I don't remember that part. Just that it was confirmable. I figured you were hinting to psychic.

You should really claim though.

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Also dont nessisarily like deaths claim either why wait that long after 2 people claimed tracking/motion to claim essentially a miller

Didnt want to make it easier for scum to find more townpower mostly. Plus day2 only had 1 motion detector claim.

I always have the foolish hope I can get scum to shoot me when I draw a useless claim too.
---

Well either panth had a fake claim or was trying to hide the Bodyguard but i still dont understand why he would use it on me after night 1 yeah night 1 i was only claimed power makes sense but then we had tange and scare that made more sense to protect. I would have went tange but thats just me. I was slightly skeptical of scare so i wanted to try to confrim scare and honestly it was mostly from lea coming back town tbh

---

htaeD posted...

Didnt want to make it easier for scum to find more townpower mostly. Plus day2 only had 1 motion detector claim.

I always have the foolish hope I can get scum to shoot me when I draw a useless claim too.

Good reaponse

---

Dude, Panth is 100% scum. lol

---

I don't see the need to at this point in time. We're also lynching dead obvious scum today as it is.

---

i don't count "becomes tree stump after dying" as "comfirmable"

by that logic, all town roles are confirmable because you get confirmed town when you die and flip town

i can't help the town in any way mechnically after dying so being "confirmed" at that point doesn't help

a "confirmable" role is theoretically one that confirms itself BEFORE dying, so that it can avoid being killed by the town

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Okay o dont like being called somone who fell off a cliff. It was fucking easter weekend and i was off of work i wanted to spend time with my wife ao sue me. Ive been on the over night shift at work and playing at work i was trying to be active last night but was actually busy for the first time since Covid 19 has started!

Anyways i really dislike Plum and 5tars play. I feel like that the attack brought on to me from that slot has been nothing but an attempt to get me misslynched the facts have been wrong, refusing to accept that i have been confirmed my role but then backed tracked to just say no no just confirmed tracker is all i meant.

Plum also came in with the same claim as uwimm and it didnt feel genuine they came up with a quick claim beacuse i caught them doing to lea. I dont really like the 2nd motion detector claim either

i like this guy and i'd suggest letting him take this line of reasoning against plum and 5star further. sounds like good stuff to me.

You become a confirmed town voice, Dels.

---

Dels posted...

i like this guy and i'd suggest letting him take this line of reasoning against plum and 5star further. sounds like good stuff to me.

I have written two day-starting walls on them. Day 3 I opened up by lambasting 5tar, and Day 4 I opened up by doing it to Plum.

Corrik7 posted...

You become a confirmed town voice, Dels.

And yes, this.

MZero technically doesn't have to "die" to be confirmed, either.

---

just to clarify, i do not want to be lynched. ever. because that is against my win condition.

That's a weird thing to say, Dels.

---

Corrik7 posted...

You become a confirmed town voice, Dels.

eh. like i said i see "confirmable" as meaning, in practice, that it's a townie that you can't ever accidentally mislynch because they are able to prove they are 100% town.

but your definition works as well.

i can see how mzero's claimed role is similar to this, at any rate.

Also heya dels.
---

Corrik7 posted...

That's a weird thing to say, Dels.

well people were speculating that lea may have wanted to be mislynched, even to the point of purposefully bungling the claim.

so i'm just clarifying that i don't want to be.

Corrik7 posted...

That's a weird thing to say, Dels.

---

Not that part. The win condition part.


---

Corrik7 posted...

Not that part. The win condition part.

---

town loses if too many town die so getting lynched is against the town's win condition

Dels posted...

well people were speculating that lea may have wanted to be mislynched, even to the point of purposefully bungling the claim.

so i'm just clarifying that i don't want to be.

Lea's own words may as well have been that she wanted to die so she could BS post freely.

---

Dels posted...

town loses if too many town die so getting lynched is against the town's win condition

People think you may be scum so they discount your opinions... you could still be trying to eliminate scum by getting lynched and using your confirmed town voice to help scum win the game.

You stated almost like you have a different win condition. It was awkward.

---

help town* lol

---