Current Events > Reminder since you have may forgotten: the MCU isn't cinema

Topic List
Page List: 1, 2
Zithers
07/03/20 11:07:07 PM
#1:


Since theaters are closed and new movies trickle in via streaming services or virtual cinemas with little fanfare, I feel it is important to remind you all that the MCU is not cinema, nor are various other franchise films that Hollywood keeps making and giving $300m advertising budgets to.

It is also important to remind you that "cinema" much like thousands of other words in the English language has various definitions. You may go to Google and see the following:

a theater where movies are shown for public entertainment; a movie theater.
or
motion picture usually used attributively

However, and this is certainly not common knowledge, those who consider themselves movie enthusiasts have a separate definition of "cinema." I guess it could be seen as a parallel to people who separate books into literature and not literature. Personally, I like to default to Steven Soderbergh's definition of the term, which he gave during a keynote speech at the San Francisco International Film Festival several years ago:

Now we finally arrive at the subject of this rant, which is the state of cinema. First of all, is there a difference between cinema and movies? Yeah. If I were on Team America, Id say Fuck yeah! The simplest way that I can describe it is that a movie is something you see, and cinema is something thats made. It has nothing to do with the captured medium, it doesnt have anything to do with where the screen is, if its in your bedroom, your iPad, it doesnt even really have to be a movie. It could be a commercial, it could be something on YouTube. Cinema is a specificity of vision. Its an approach in which everything matters. Its the polar opposite of generic or arbitrary and the result is as unique as a signature or a fingerprint. It isnt made by a committee, and it isnt made by a company, and it isnt made by the audience. It means that if this filmmaker didnt do it, it either wouldnt exist at all, or it wouldnt exist in anything like this form.

This expands cinema into realms outside of feature films of course: TikTok, Vine, YouTube, television, etc. Now, under this definition, we cannot say that Marvel, nor any other number of generic blockbusters Hollywood produces each year, is cinema. It is a term reserved for works that allow a filmmaker to work on their own terms, without the restraints of appealing to every quadrant, China, etc. It's also okay to like these movies. Just don't act like they're worthy of being in the same discussion as real cinema.

Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.

BTW you can watch the rest of Soderbergh's speech here. Or you can look up a transcript (the URL I copied it from is too long). It's pretty interesting. He's a smart guy.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?reload=9&v=ZQrFSUwFwUM

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
RevivedPacifist
07/03/20 11:08:37 PM
#2:


we are all dying every day

---
Life is suffering
... Copied to Clipboard!
The23rdMagus
07/03/20 11:09:19 PM
#3:


While I appreciate precise language, I don't particularly care about splitting hairs like that.

---
~Drewnami~
A beacon of Light from a burning screen.
... Copied to Clipboard!
armandro
07/03/20 11:09:45 PM
#4:


glad some on this website actually has good taste

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
MrKapowski
07/03/20 11:10:00 PM
#5:


Reminder since you may have forgotten: TC is a welcher

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Vamp_Aubrey
07/03/20 11:10:41 PM
#6:


MrKapowski posted...
Reminder since you may have forgotten: TC is a welcher

big if true

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zithers
07/03/20 11:10:44 PM
#7:


RevivedPacifist posted...
we are all dying every day

It's true. Soderbergh even touches on this in his speech. If the collective works of Shakespeare can't prevent genocide, then what's the point of art?

Check it out brah!!

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Balrog0
07/03/20 11:11:54 PM
#8:


The23rdMagus posted...
While I appreciate precise language, I don't particularly care about splitting hairs like that.

I simply disagree with TCs conclusion. If a commercial can be cinema so can s marvel movie. I'm sure the Russo brothers pushed marvel not the other way around, for instance.

---
But to you who are listening I say: Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who mistreat you.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Vamp_Aubrey
07/03/20 11:12:06 PM
#9:


... Copied to Clipboard!
KiwiTerraRizing
07/03/20 11:13:39 PM
#10:


Neither is bbw Porn but Im gonna keep watching it.

---
Trucking Legend Don Schneider!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Balrog0
07/03/20 11:14:17 PM
#11:


KiwiTerraRizing posted...
Neither is bbw Porn but Im gonna keep watching it.

False, bbw porn can easily be cinema according to this topic

---
But to you who are listening I say: Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who mistreat you.
... Copied to Clipboard!
PatrickMahomes
07/03/20 11:14:49 PM
#12:


Come back to the discord

---
NFLB 2020 Summersim Roster mk. 1 (12-4) (ELIMINATED): https://imgur.com/4Pvr5rT
NFLB 2020 Summersim Roster mk. 2 (3-2): https://imgur.com/BBhN2z3
... Copied to Clipboard!
SmidgeIsntBack
07/03/20 11:16:57 PM
#13:


Luv 2 gatekeep things I enjoy. I'm absolutely crazy about drawing lines in the sand between my favorite things and your favorite things.

---
Podcast/Audiobook Board https://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/1364-
View my ASCII art and others' at https://thenewhotness.info/
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zithers
07/03/20 11:19:00 PM
#14:


SmidgeIsntBack posted...
Luv 2 gatekeep things I enjoy. I'm absolutely crazy about drawing lines in the sand between my favorite things and your favorite things.

The gate to cinema is open for you to enjoy. Never been easier. Criterion Channel, Mubi, Turner Classic Movies, along with digital marketplace rentals on Google Play, iTunes, and Amazon have thousands of titles to enjoy outside of the lamestream Hollywood purview.

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
MabusIncarnate
07/03/20 11:20:05 PM
#15:


Welchers are the worst

---
Ten million dollars on a losing campaign, Twenty million starving and writhing in pain. =~=;
Vicious_Dios Original - https://tinyurl.com/y9fpdoll
... Copied to Clipboard!
Lonestar2000
07/03/20 11:20:54 PM
#16:


Shut the fuck up and fuck off TC, no one fucking cares.

---
Rumble Roses. Someone enters the room. Them: O_O Me: What?! I always play games without my pants on!- Inmate 922335
#ImpeachToadDickTrump
... Copied to Clipboard!
The23rdMagus
07/03/20 11:20:55 PM
#17:


KiwiTerraRizing posted...
Neither is bbw Porn but Im gonna keep watching it.
...reluctant high five...

---
~Drewnami~
A beacon of Light from a burning screen.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Balrog0
07/03/20 11:28:59 PM
#18:


Zithers posted...
The gate to cinema is open for you to enjoy. Never been easier. Criterion Channel, Mubi, Turner Classic Movies, along with digital marketplace rentals on Google Play, iTunes, and Amazon have thousands of titles to enjoy outside of the lamestream Hollywood purview.

Which commercials are cinema iyo @Zithers

---
But to you who are listening I say: Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who mistreat you.
... Copied to Clipboard!
#19
Post #19 was unavailable or deleted.
Balrog0
07/03/20 11:32:47 PM
#20:


ImAMarvel posted...
I'm going to laugh like crazy when the MCU makes theaters profitable again

Or when some conformists like Broadway get back into theater

---
But to you who are listening I say: Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who mistreat you.
... Copied to Clipboard!
BruceWayneJr
07/03/20 11:36:30 PM
#21:


shouts out to my grape juice OG lookin' at you

---
Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zithers
07/03/20 11:39:55 PM
#22:


Balrog0 posted...
Which commercials are cinema iyo @Zithers

Don't have cable so can't really say. Although I do like the Corona beach Christmas commercial actually...

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zithers
07/03/20 11:40:24 PM
#23:


ImAMarvel posted...
I'm going to laugh like crazy when the MCU makes theaters profitable again

Well yeah, cinema doesn't make a whole lot of money these days.

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
#24
Post #24 was unavailable or deleted.
Solid Snake07
07/03/20 11:44:58 PM
#25:


Sure they are

And I dont particularly care for them

---
"People incapable of guilt usually do have a good time"
-Detective Rust Cohle
... Copied to Clipboard!
SmidgeIsntBack
07/03/20 11:48:14 PM
#26:


Zithers posted...
The gate to cinema is open for you to enjoy. Never been easier. Criterion Channel, Mubi, Turner Classic Movies, along with digital marketplace rentals on Google Play, iTunes, and Amazon have thousands of titles to enjoy outside of the lamestream Hollywood purview.

this is a weird response to me saying Andrei Tarkovsky's Nostalgia and Boo 2! A Madea Halloween occupy the same medium and that no amount of Venn diagrams will be able to clearly label just one as Mature Cinema For Mature Cinephiles Such As Myself

---
Podcast/Audiobook Board https://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/1364-
View my ASCII art and others' at https://thenewhotness.info/
... Copied to Clipboard!
ThanksUglyGod
07/03/20 11:49:43 PM
#27:


Zithers posted...
Some nerd shit

... Copied to Clipboard!
Blackstar110
07/03/20 11:58:05 PM
#28:


Hi zithers

---
-Shred
... Copied to Clipboard!
BettyWhite
07/04/20 12:03:07 AM
#29:


Michael Bay is a cinematic genius.

---
Life is pain and misery
beat skeet to asian street meat
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zithers
07/04/20 12:14:36 AM
#30:


ImAMarvel posted...
Yes but the MCU and capeshit will save theaters as a whole when everything opens up again. And then when people are willing to go see superhero movies on the big screen again, they're going to be far more willing to see literally everything else, including smaller-budget, arthouse movies. Just you watch.

I mean, I kinda doubt it given the trauma people are experiencing over the pandemic. People will probably go to the movies less and make it even more focused on only seeing mega budget stuff.

SmidgeIsntBack posted...
this is a weird response to me saying Andrei Tarkovsky's Nostalgia and Boo 2! A Madea Halloween occupy the same medium and that no amount of Venn diagrams will be able to clearly label just one as Mature Cinema For Mature Cinephiles Such As Myself

I never said anything about maturity or quality. Cinema can be bad or juvenile. Michael Bay or Zack Snyder for example have unique visions that seem generally unimpeded.

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
BettyWhite
07/04/20 12:22:18 AM
#31:


What's your favorite super hero movie Zithers? If any. I'm wagering... Hmm.. Batman(1989)

If you were held at gun point and had to watch something from the MCU what would it be?

---
Life is pain and misery
beat skeet to asian street meat
... Copied to Clipboard!
BallaLeonHall
07/04/20 12:24:21 AM
#32:


Continue to fight the good fight.

I am but a simple lurker. I am old and tired, unable to change anything. Take my likes and thread bumps as it is all I can spare.

---
Zantetsuken!
... Copied to Clipboard!
SmidgeIsntBack
07/04/20 12:29:14 AM
#33:


Zithers posted...
I never said anything about maturity or quality. Cinema can be bad or juvenile. Michael Bay or Zack Snyder for example have unique visions that seem generally unimpeded.

And I never said anything about Madea's maturity or quality (the Mature Cinephiles comment is just what this topic smells like), I used it as an example because it is one of those "generic Hollywood blockbusters" pushed out on a conveyor belt, despite being written and produced by Tyler Perry like the rest of the series.

you also keep responding to me but have yet to answer what commercials you think are cinema

---
Podcast/Audiobook Board https://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/1364-
View my ASCII art and others' at https://thenewhotness.info/
... Copied to Clipboard!
MabusIncarnate
07/04/20 12:33:21 AM
#34:


BallaLeonHall posted...
Continue to fight the good fight.

I am but a simple lurker. I am old and tired, unable to change anything. Take my likes and thread bumps as it is all I can spare.
I like you

---
Ten million dollars on a losing campaign, Twenty million starving and writhing in pain. =~=;
Vicious_Dios Original - https://tinyurl.com/y9fpdoll
... Copied to Clipboard!
Turtlebread
07/04/20 12:34:16 AM
#35:


If you actually care about this pretentious bullshit youre probably a chronic fart sniffer.

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zithers
07/04/20 12:44:55 AM
#36:


BettyWhite posted...
What's your favorite super hero movie Zithers? If any. I'm wagering... Hmm.. Batman(1989)

If you were held at gun point and had to watch something from the MCU what would it be?

The Incredibles obv.

SmidgeIsntBack posted...
And I never said anything about Madea's maturity or quality (the Mature Cinephiles comment is just what this topic smells like), I used it as an example because it is one of those "generic Hollywood blockbusters" pushed out on a conveyor belt, despite being written and produced by Tyler Perry like the rest of the series.

you also keep responding to me but have yet to answer what commercials you think are cinema

I actually mentioned the Corona Christmas commercial earlier. For all I know Tyler Perry is an auteur as well, just not a good one. Haven't seen or read much about his movies tbh.

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
SmidgeIsntBack
07/04/20 1:09:03 AM
#37:


That was my bad for not seeing your post earlier.

---
Podcast/Audiobook Board https://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/1364-
View my ASCII art and others' at https://thenewhotness.info/
... Copied to Clipboard!
SuperShake666
07/04/20 1:12:34 AM
#38:


Watching a few black and white foreign films does not mean you have a film degree.

---
"Look, if I was good at math, I wouldn't be on CE at 2:00 the morning clicking on topics about porn stars ****ing horses." - May 2017, Dash_Harber
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zithers
07/04/20 1:22:39 AM
#39:


SuperShake666 posted...
Watching a few black and white foreign films does not mean you have a film degree.

?

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
FrankGoreHOF
07/04/20 1:26:40 AM
#40:


Tc is correct

---
#FrankGoreHOF
... Copied to Clipboard!
MC_BatCommander
07/04/20 1:27:24 AM
#41:


idgaf, still gonna see 'em

---
The Legend is True!
... Copied to Clipboard!
GameGodOfAll
07/04/20 1:37:49 AM
#42:


They're cinema no matter how much it upsets people. This is some real weird low tier gatekeeping shit I don't get, but whatever. I'm not the one who has a problem with the basic facts.

---
My Words Were True And Sheamus Made You Believe!
https://imgur.com/Fc39f
... Copied to Clipboard!
SH_expert44
07/04/20 1:40:04 AM
#43:


... Copied to Clipboard!
sktgamer_13dude
07/04/20 1:55:24 AM
#44:


MrKapowski posted...
Reminder since you may have forgotten: TC is a welcher

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Laserion
07/04/20 1:58:36 AM
#45:


"cinematic pictures" are pictures that move. See also "moving pictures" = "movie".
---
There is no "would of", "should of" or "could of".
There is "would've", "should've" and "could've".
... Copied to Clipboard!
Paragon21XX
07/04/20 2:08:33 AM
#46:


MrKapowski posted...
Reminder since you may have forgotten: TC is a welcher
TC's opinion = null and void

---
Hmm...
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zithers
07/04/20 3:05:28 AM
#47:


GameGodOfAll posted...
They're cinema no matter how much it upsets people. This is some real weird low tier gatekeeping shit I don't get, but whatever. I'm not the one who has a problem with the basic facts.

I don't see how it's gatekeeping. No one is saying you can only enjoy one or the other. Super weird how simply saying they aren't unique visions triggers people so badly. It's okay to admit you like them. A lot of people do.

Also they aren't cinema. Detailed this in the OP.

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
DrizztLink
07/04/20 3:07:27 AM
#48:


... Copied to Clipboard!
Guerrilla Soldier
07/04/20 3:18:41 AM
#49:


Zithers posted...
It isnt made by a committee, and it isnt made by a company
literally every piece of cinema is made by a committee. each one of them has a massive credits list at the end of all of the people involved in creating it.

and each one is owned and distributed by a company or multiple companies to protect the ip amongst other legal things

that isn't a good way to separate movies and cinema

---
Disclaimer: There's a good chance the above post could be sarcasm.
Die-hard Oakland A's fan --- Keep the A's in Oakland!
... Copied to Clipboard!
PMarth2002
07/04/20 3:21:24 AM
#50:


Zithers posted...
I don't see how it's gatekeeping.

It is when your attitude towards movies you don't think count as cinema is

Zithers posted...
Just don't act like they're worthy of being in the same discussion as real cinema.


---
No matter where you go, there you are.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1, 2