Current Events > Who is the best playable Persona girl?

Topic List
Page List: 1
Kyle1022
03/10/21 11:14:22 PM
#1:


Vote for the best










Didn't have space for the navigators or spinoff characters. So if you're really feeling Fuuka, Rise, Futuba, Labrys, Sophia, or even Metis, write them in

It's definitely Chie. Short + brown hair + sporty + likes meat =

I feel like voting for FeMC is almost cheating, but she's a great option too

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
YugiNoob
03/10/21 11:16:02 PM
#2:


Rise because inputs

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vap3IhI4MUE

---
Bun bun :3
... Copied to Clipboard!
AvantgardeAClue
03/10/21 11:16:43 PM
#3:


Aigis

Manages to be both a compelling supporting character AND compelling protagonist in The Answer

---
Sometimes I say things and I'm not voice acting.
... Copied to Clipboard!
QueenCarly
03/10/21 11:17:12 PM
#4:


... Copied to Clipboard!
slmcknett
03/10/21 11:17:33 PM
#5:


Makoto > Yukiko > Haru

---
Watch "Final Fantasy XV Abridged" and "Kingdom Hearts Abridged" right here!
https://www.youtube.com/user/mcknett3
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyle1022
03/10/21 11:33:00 PM
#6:


Makoto is winning

She is easily the worst of all those choices

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
EmbraceOfDeath
03/10/21 11:47:36 PM
#7:


QueenCarly posted...
Makoto followed by Chie

---
PSN/GT: BigDaffej
... Copied to Clipboard!
slmcknett
03/11/21 12:27:12 AM
#8:


Kyle1022 posted...
Makoto is winning

She is easily the worst of all those choices
Your choice was Chie, so... lol

---
Watch "Final Fantasy XV Abridged" and "Kingdom Hearts Abridged" right here!
https://www.youtube.com/user/mcknett3
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyle1022
03/11/21 12:29:06 AM
#9:


Makoto STILL sucks even though she's a brunette with a nice ass. That's honestly hard to do

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
fuming
03/11/21 12:29:53 AM
#10:


Mako-chan is life
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyle1022
03/12/21 6:15:22 AM
#11:


No

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
luigi13579
03/12/21 6:20:51 AM
#12:


Maya!
... Copied to Clipboard!
spikethedevil
03/12/21 6:21:31 AM
#13:


Someone else who forgets P1 and 2 ;_;. Also not enough love for Naoto here.

---
A garbage pod!? It's a smegging garbage pod!
... Copied to Clipboard!
BreezyExcursion
03/12/21 7:57:36 AM
#14:


makoto

---
gm
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyle1022
03/12/21 2:37:02 PM
#15:


Atlus doesn't even care about P1 or P2 so why should I?

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
Scarecrow17
03/12/21 2:41:10 PM
#16:


Makoto is best girl. Chie smells like shit.

---
His foundation lie in the holy mountain. Selah.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Shotgunnova
03/12/21 2:59:54 PM
#17:


Chie 4 Lyfe

---
Take me down from the ridge where the summer ends
And watch the city spread out just like a jet's flame
... Copied to Clipboard!
monkmith
03/12/21 3:01:19 PM
#18:


obviously aigis.

---
Taarsidath-an halsaam.
Quando il gioco e finito, il re e il pedone vanno nella stessa scatola
... Copied to Clipboard!
MaxEffingBemis
03/12/21 3:05:50 PM
#19:


Why do people hate Makoto

---
She took pity on me, horizontally, but most likely because of my band
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyle1022
03/12/21 3:20:11 PM
#20:


MaxEffingBemis posted...
Why do people hate Makoto
Her hairstyle is awful, she has weird red eyes, she's a Mary Sue goody two-shoes, she's an asshole to Ryuji in their combo attack, and her social link is awful and not even about her

Again, she sucks despite being a brunette with a nice ass. That's almost impossible to do, yet she manages

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
MaxEffingBemis
03/12/21 4:11:28 PM
#21:


Kyle1022 posted...
Her hairstyle is awful, she has weird red eyes, she's a Mary Sue goody two-shoes, she's an asshole to Ryuji in their combo attack, and her social link is awful and not even about her

Again, she sucks despite being a brunette with a nice ass. That's almost impossible to do, yet she manages
Im halfway through her social link right now and I kind of agree. But everything else I disagree with

---
She took pity on me, horizontally, but most likely because of my band
... Copied to Clipboard!
Turbam
03/12/21 4:13:17 PM
#22:


Makoto already won the best Persona girl poll :V

---
~snip (V)_(;,;)_(V) snip~
I'm just one man! Whoa! Well, I'm a one man band! https://imgur.com/p9Xvjvs
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyle1022
03/12/21 4:17:57 PM
#23:


You can only disagree with one thing I said because the rest is objective

She has red eyes, period. It's weird because barely anyone both IRL and in these games has red eyes. Whether you like this or not is up to you

She is a Mary Sue and a goody two-shoes by definition. Whether you like this or not is up to you

She's an asshole to Ryuji in their combo attack when everyone else acts like friends. Even Joker and Crow act more friendly towards each other

Her hairstyle being awful is the only opinion there. But I bet a lot of Makoto fans would prefer her with a more normal hairstyle, like in all the fan art online

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
Duck_Hunt_Man
03/12/21 4:18:10 PM
#24:


luigi13579 posted...
Maya!


---
Who died and made you ****ing king of the zombies?
Washington Football Team: 7-10
... Copied to Clipboard!
Turbam
03/12/21 4:19:43 PM
#25:


Oh man
Gotta get the meltdown crew in here. TC mad because his waifu is losing
@Bestoffuture
@Reis
@Veggeta_X
@Heartomaton
@Rathinor

---
~snip (V)_(;,;)_(V) snip~
I'm just one man! Whoa! Well, I'm a one man band! https://imgur.com/p9Xvjvs
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyle1022
03/12/21 4:21:54 PM
#26:


Nah honestly I like them all well enough. It's just that Makoto is by faaaar the worst lol

Well except Fuuka. Old Fuuka sucks because her voice is sooo bad. New Fuuka voiced by Wendee Lee is fine though

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
monkmith
03/12/21 4:44:00 PM
#27:


Kyle1022 posted...
She has red eyes, period. It's weird because barely anyone both IRL and in these games has red eyes. Whether you like this or not is up to you
tifa has red eyes and everyone loves her...

i agree with everything else you said though.

---
Taarsidath-an halsaam.
Quando il gioco e finito, il re e il pedone vanno nella stessa scatola
... Copied to Clipboard!
YugiNoob
03/12/21 4:49:12 PM
#28:


Nothing wrong with weird eyes :3



---
Bun bun :3
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kain Highwind
03/12/21 5:06:34 PM
#29:


Kyle1022 posted...
Her hairstyle is awful, she has weird red eyes, she's a Mary Sue goody two-shoes, she's an asshole to Ryuji in their combo attack, and her social link is awful and not even about her

Again, she sucks despite being a brunette with a nice ass. That's almost impossible to do, yet she manages
her hairstyle and eyes are hot

---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Rathinor
03/12/21 5:40:15 PM
#30:


Turbam posted...
Oh man
Gotta get the meltdown crew in here. TC mad because his waifu is losing
@Bestoffuture
@Reis
@Veggeta_X
@Heartomaton
@Rathinor
Hahahahaha! He's gonna bring in the sock puppet alts to raise his numbers!
... Copied to Clipboard!
CM_Ponch
03/12/21 5:40:58 PM
#31:


Makoto and Ann

---
SW-8316-3213-4720
... Copied to Clipboard!
Pitlord_Special
03/12/21 5:43:48 PM
#32:


I havent played P5

The persona 3 MC is very powerful though so Id say theyre the best

---
Posted from my iPhone 8
... Copied to Clipboard!
#33
Post #33 was unavailable or deleted.
Smackems
03/12/21 5:46:18 PM
#34:


Chie

I don't understand the makoto love

---
Common sense baked a funk cookie - some dude
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyle1022
03/12/21 5:47:36 PM
#35:


monkmith posted...
tifa has red eyes and everyone loves her...
I didn't know Tifa was from Persona

Rathinor posted...
Hahahahaha! He's gonna bring in the sock puppet alts to raise his numbers!
I don't have alts or care enough to rig a poll on gamefaqs lol wtf

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
ultimate reaver
03/12/21 5:47:45 PM
#36:


ryuji deserves the worst, so that is only a bolster for makoto tbh.

still voted naoto

---
I pray god will curse the writer, as the writer has cursed the world with this beautiful, stupendous creation, terrible in its simplicity, irresistible in truth
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyle1022
03/12/21 5:52:31 PM
#37:


Ryuji is best bro in the series, shut your goddamn mouth

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
#38
Post #38 was unavailable or deleted.
Kyle1022
03/12/21 6:32:17 PM
#39:


I don't mind Junpei, but he throws a bitch fit for half the game. Ryuji is always your brother no matter what

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
#40
Post #40 was unavailable or deleted.
Reis
03/12/21 6:45:39 PM
#41:


monkmith posted...
i agree with everything else you said though.

me too, I legitimately don't understand why people like Makoto so fervently

like with yukiko, who is also awful, I could at least understand because she's a weeb's idealized Japanese waifu but Makoto is awful both personality wise and visually

oh yeah and to answer the topic, aigis easily because of how fleshed out she is. a literal robot is a more compelling character than everyone on this list
... Copied to Clipboard!
fuming
03/12/21 7:19:59 PM
#42:


Kyle1022 posted...
Her hairstyle is awful, she has weird red eyes, she's a Mary Sue goody two-shoes, she's an asshole to Ryuji in their combo attack, and her social link is awful and not even about her

Again, she sucks despite being a brunette with a nice ass. That's almost impossible to do, yet she manages

Red eyes is common in anime, and fits makoto well because she has a sweet demeanor but a fierce intensity behind her. She's a bit of a goody good, but she isn't a mary sue at all. She's mean to Ryuji, but Ann and the MC are also assholes to him all the time because he's very insensitive and usually is just getting back what he gives. It's also a running joke in the series that Ryuji is terrified of her intense side, which is supposed to be funny because she's the goody good and he's the delinquent. Her social link is about her, just less directly. And please don't talk about mako-chans body in such a way, she is a high school girl.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Rathinor
03/12/21 7:42:19 PM
#43:


Kyle1022 posted...
I didn't know Tifa was from Persona

I don't have alts or care enough to rig a poll on gamefaqs lol wtf
Exactly what someone with alts would say
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kyle1022
03/12/21 7:51:36 PM
#44:


ArianaGrandSlam posted...
part of what endears me to the P3 is cast is that theyre not instantly and continuously dickriding the main character from the moment you meet them, like the P4 and P5 casts. They got their own thing going on outside you.

but yeah Ryujis a real ride-or-die, better than Yosuke or Morgana or any of your other male friends.
I understand that and I get it. There are lots of little details in the game pointing at his growth in particular. Like if you check the exam scores after the first exam, it says Junpei is near the bottom, but by the last exam it says he did average. Thats pretty cool. But still, there's a fine line between not dickriding (most of the rest of the cast) and just being an asshole (Junpei half the game)

fuming posted...
She's a bit of a goody good, but she isn't a mary sue at all.
False

fuming posted...
And please don't talk about mako-chans body in such a way, she is a high school girl
Nope, I'm playing P5S

---
PC | Switch | Wii U | Wii | GC | N64 | SNES | NES | PS5 | PS4 Pro | PS3 | PS2 | PS1 | Xbox Series X | N3DS | DSi | GBA | GBC | Vita | PSP
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1