Current Events > Anybody here review a journal paper before? Unsure how to rate from 1 to 5.

Topic List
Page List: 1
Jabodie
06/27/21 10:17:06 AM
#1:


I've written out my comments for revision, but I have to rate it based on "award quality." I've emailed my advisor for advice, but I was curious if anybody had any input since I know some academics are on here.

The big thing here is I'm not sure what "award" would mean in this context, or really how to determine how likely a paper would win one. 3 is "average paper/not likely award caliber", 5 is "exceptional/award quality." Anybody else seen this before?

---
<insert sig here>
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1