Poll of the Day > Sekiro > Elden Ring

(+) Yeah! (+)

For the sake of moving on I'll just give you guys the W on this point. I've addressed many of your talking points already, I'm bored of it.

Anyone care to bring a new argument to the table or address any points that no one has even bothered to try to argue against?

Sahuagin posted...

(note that if you have indeed stumbled into a playstyle that trivializes the game, that may well be a problem with the game. I think we mostly doubt that you found something quite that extreme, but would welcome a demonstration.)

The fuck am I supposed to demonstrate? I picked up a morning star put wild swings on it. It was that easy. This is my third time stating i just stumbled into it, you could have saved a lot of time because you have brought literally nothing new to the discussion, same as adjl and kyubi. You guys doubt me? Sorry but that's on you

Mensis posted...

Fight me

Why? I completely agree

In my opinion Too human > Elden ring > Seikero

I finished Too human as every class solo, and as berzerker like 3 times.

Love that game and kept my 360 for a few years only to reply it. Didn't like any other games on my 360 enough to play them.

Elden ring is/was fun but I never finished it. I had 2 chars I played pretty far into it with, but both got
rediculously powerfull. One had the moonsword that just destroyed thing (probably patched by now) and the other was just focused on pure physical damage weapons and still destroyed everything.

It was very long, with tons of exploring and eventually little to no challenge so I just stopped playing it. I mean to go back some year and hopefully actually finish it.

Seikero I just got tired of, don't even know how far into it I was because it's been too long. Just didn't have the fun of other souls like games to me.

Sadly I actually liked Dark souls 1-3 more than Elden Ring eventually....it started off awesome, but it just didn't have the lasting power let alone the ability to make me enjoy replaying it that the dark souls games did. I've played all 3 of the main souls series (not counting demon souls which I played a bunch too) and bloodborne multiple times.

Elden ring is probably longer for a playthrough than any of them, but lost me before I played through it even once.

Mensis posted...

The fuck am I supposed to demonstrate?

I doubt you've trivialized the game as much as you say you have. maybe bleed is that OP, I dunno I rarely use it even in DS.

note that much of ER is not really very hard. many of the side bosses are extremely easy. there are just specific points that may be more challenging, particularly near the end. and certain parts will be harder or easier depending how you approach it.

the point was, not everyone values what you value. different values give different impressions of the same game.

I'm not attacking you, I'm trying to communicate with you, but if that's not what you're here for (what are you here for?), then never mind.

To what end is this line of communication? Like holy shit I have nothing more to say about this particular thing. You guys turned the topic into telling me I'm playing wrong when it was meant to be about comparing two games by the same developer. Is that really such a hard thing to get?

Maybe you should just lock this topic?

Mensis posted...

I picked up a morning star put wild swings on it. It was that easy. This is my third time stating i just stumbled into it, you could have

well now i know you're just saying shit, because flails are a woefully unusable weapon in elden ring

SoreChasm posted...

Maybe you should just lock this topic?

Thought about it. It was fun fighting about the topic at hand but this conversation is exhausting, they just too hung up. I said I was ready to fight in the op, but damn yall I even gave you the W and you won't drop it.

And I said morning star. You think it's unusable? Sounds like you're just bad.

i mean yeah, i am bad

but i still platinumed elden ring and sekiro

majority of hammers in elden ring are useless even still, morning star being one of em

actually morning star is probably the worst considered hammer in the game. it's a paper weapon, in that it looks perfect on paper, but it has very low reach and its damage is lackluster for anything past the peninsula - even with innate bleed

That's cool. ER is the only From game I've played that I haven't platted. Not saying I won't but I don't even know what it entails.

Ok fine I may have buffed with BFB. Wild swings makes the bleed go off in seconds, if you have the black flame buff the health just plummets. You can call bs all day or just try it yourself Mr elden ring

basically just beating every boss, getting all the "legendary" weapons, and seeing all the endings

the last one can be savescummed but i never bothered and just beelined the others with ng+