Board 8 > Video Game Console Mafia - Topic 2: Mono Got Atari

(+) Yeah! (+)

Hey let's kill Ulti

ctesjbuvf posted...

I'm caught up.

To whoeever asked if Sultan was in Dota 2 mafia, unlike what was answered a few posts later, the answer is yes, he was, he was scum and got lynched day 1.

Uhh, what? Like, I barely have a read. If this is because I said I agreed with his points the most from the like two pages that were there when I first posted, then that's definitely barely a tell. Often enough scum is more logical and town makes no sense, so it's hardly that important. This is a weird thing to ask.

Yeah I interpreted that post as a townread on him.

Sultan you should ask sheep to clarify if you have to kill anyone or not. Maybe you can pass on the ability. If so then I agree with death the group should have some input if you allow it and we should know our full range of choices

I picked Mzero beacuse he has seemed way more comical than I've ever seen him and it just doesn't seem town Mzero to me I also chose earlier. I can change who I point it at btw. Just has to be in before I get killed.

I wanted shock factor so maybe I was being a bit selfish

I mean I doubt I get night killed but we could as a group decide who to point it at.

Oh I can choose to not point it to

Based on that it sounds like this supposed role can forego a kill by not naming a target at all since a day hammer could happen before it even makes up its mind,

Also think there's a nonzero chance MZero got scummoned by that claim.

Sultan is probably town.

Him being so defeatist was the only thing that actually bothered me, but if this is his role it looks a bit better.

ctesjbuvf posted...

Sultan is probably town.

Yeah I agree. So let's kill someone else. How about Ulti?

Sultan is probably town but he has a four vote bandwagon and is destined to die as he has zero competition.

UnderUrMattress posted...

Also think there's a nonzero chance MZero got scummoned by that claim.

dude i posted 20 minutes ago

Sultan said it himself that he wouldnt get shot in all likelihood

But that just means that this is a role scum could claim to live forever

oh you said "got"

either way I was around the whole time so

MZero posted...

can you explain what exactly made you read Dumey and Wallz town based on their reactions?

as I recall wallz basically posted a picture

MZero posted...

I'm MZero and I support this lynch

There's over an hour gap between these posts and you conveniently come back after a claim that is aimed towards killing you.

htaeD posted...

Sultan said it himself that he wouldnt get shot in all likelihood

But that just means that this is a role scum could claim to live forever

Decent point but idk I'd rather go somewhere else. May I ask how you feel about Ulti now?

I definitely think theres a chance sultan is town. But theres also a chance hes telling the truth about his role, but not his alignment. Scum extra kill that only activates if said scum dies is a real possibility. Some of sultans comments and explanations have been so questionable and I struggle with that

And not to mention, lynching sultan is by far the best chance at activating reds permanent power-up, which I believe is real because I trust an uncountered cop claim.

htaeD posted...

Sultan said it himself that he wouldnt get shot in all likelihood

But that just means that this is a role scum could claim to live forever

I'm you could still lynch me and I'll just end up shooting Mzero

It is a role that would enhance standard town selfishness (I know that feeling all too well, trust me)
And it is a role that I feel we should lynch eventually.
Though maybe not today.
I dont know..

are you really playing the scummoned card after one hour

wallmasterz posted...

Scum extra kill that only activates if said scum dies is a real possibility.

Uh from what I've been told this is a banned thing to do. You're pushing town for making the right lynch thats not cool

wallmasterz posted...

I definitely think theres a chance sultan is town. But theres also a chance hes telling the truth about his role, but not his alignment. Scum extra kill that only activates if said scum dies is a real possibility. Some of sultans comments and explanations have been so questionable and I struggle with that

And not to mention, lynching sultan is by far the best chance at activating reds permanent power-up, which I believe is real because I trust an uncountered cop claim.

For what it's worth, I townread Sultan for factors not related to his claim lol.

MZero posted...

are you really playing the scummoned card after one hour

Sure why not

Why were you active lurking for a whole page and then respond to that one post where you're potentially in trouble?

Ulti hasnt impressed me when it comes to answering my questions
(he did say I was town now, but that was one word)

I do think he has not put his foot in his mouth yet either tho, so if he is scum he has improved.
But he is weird. He chooses unexpected things to comment on.

wallmasterz posted...

I definitely think theres a chance sultan is town. But theres also a chance hes telling the truth about his role, but not his alignment. Scum extra kill that only activates if said scum dies is a real possibility. Some of sultans comments and explanations have been so questionable and I struggle with that

And not to mention, lynching sultan is by far the best chance at activating reds permanent power-up, which I believe is real because I trust an uncountered cop claim.

that would be a messed up role as scum imo

town should never be punished for lynching correctly

htaeD posted...

Ulti hasnt impressed me when it comes to answering my questions
(he did say I was town now, but that was one word)

I do think he has not put his foot in his mouth yet either tho, so if he is scum he has improved.
But he is weird. He chooses unexpected things to comment on.

His progression on you is
"Looks bad"
"Marth voted him never mind"
You: "hey Ulti you tend to read me right, what's going on here"
Ulti: "nvm you're town"

Maybe not, then. I dont know much about whats banned and not in online mafia. Assuming sheep knows thats typically banned, Sultan is either lying about the role as well as alignment or hes town.

If you think Sultan has that role you should think he's town. If he's scum he's not vengeful at all and it's a bluff to scare and I'm not sure what that would say about MZero.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Shh not a doctor

Anyways the reason why i didn't wanna claim is it be alot more fun for the shock factor.

But I am an arcade cabinet town Vengeful QuickDraw.

Basically I pick someone to point my gun at and if I die I shot the person my gun is pointed at.

Right now it's pointed at Mzero

You should not be saying who you are pointed at.

I was ninja'd by a small handful of people.

Scum likely wouldn't want to lynch Sultan because they feel he is an extra kill in their favor.

I think he was subtly stinkpushing both of us at the same time, but seems to have zero conviction towards either of us being mafia and he backpedaled the read on you after being called out.

htaeD posted...

Actually wait, why keep this secret at all?
Why not let town choose who to point at?

Astronomically bad take.

UnderUrMattress posted...

His progression on you is
"Looks bad"
"Marth voted him never mind"
You: "hey Ulti you tend to read me right, what's going on here"
Ulti: "nvm you're town"

Yes thats why I wanted a follow-up on that

Though I guess Ulti is working right now? Still think he should be able to answer in due time,

Corrik7 posted...

Astronomically bad take.

Alright enlightened Corrik. What would you have done with this role?

htaeD posted...

Alright enlightened Corrik. What would you have done with this role?

Modkilled myself with it pointed at you. (I'm kidding I'm kidding. Take the joke)

Oh wait I see what you mean
But I meant that we would direct his target if we lynch Sultan

ctesjbuvf posted...

If you think Sultan has that role you should think he's town. If he's scum he's not vengeful at all and it's a bluff to scare and I'm not sure what that would say about MZero.

If Sultan is scum MZero is probably lock scum in my eyes lol. The fact that he immediately called it bullshit without engaging on the matter at all is sus.

That all being said, I don't think we live in that timeline. But if I'm boo boo the fool and sultan is mafia, I'm voting MZero tomorrow and tabbing out lol.

Corrik7 posted...

Modkilled myself with it pointed at you. (I'm kidding I'm kidding. Take the joke)

I did chuckle

Corrik7 posted...

Scum likely wouldn't want to lynch Sultan because they feel he is an extra kill in their favor.

Actually a good point. Maybe I'll change it or maybe I won't. Or maybe I won't point it at all.

This sounds town like from Corrik

But yeah Sultan Corrik is right about that.
If you arent lynched (and arent scum)
Dont keep it pointed at whoever you say you last pointed it at.
Keep scum guessing.

htaeD posted...

But yeah Sultan Corrik is right about that.
If you arent lynched (and arent scum)
Dont keep it pointed at whoever you say you last pointed it at.
Keep scum guessing.

He still is likelier to point at town, so he remains a likely extra kill in their favor. He could choose right, but odds are in favor, especially night 1 of him choosing wrong.

UnderUrMattress posted...

Sure why not

Why were you active lurking for a whole page and then respond to that one post where you're potentially in trouble?

i didnt feel like responding to anything else

Corrik7 posted...

He still is likelier to point at town, so he remains a likely extra kill in their favor. He could choose right, but odds are in favor, especially night 1 of him choosing wrong.

Likelier, but I cant see scum taking the risk

I will say that once he said he was pointing at MZero, there's been no additional momentum to kill him and even people talking to him like he's town.

MZero posted...

i didnt feel like responding to anything else

Who would you lynch if not sultan?

this is what I think we should do. Majority lynch sultan and if he flips town, offer a salute to him letting town cop get a permanent power up (there is seemingly zero chance we get to eight votes on anyone else).

Let sultan shoot whoever he decides to, if hes telling the truth.

wallmasterz posted...

this is what I think we should do. Majority lynch sultan and if he flips town, offer a salute to him letting town cop get a permanent power up (there is seemingly zero chance we get to eight votes on anyone else).

Let sultan shoot whoever he decides to, if hes telling the truth.

I hate that this is probably what is going to happen.

UnderUrMattress posted...

I will say that once he said he was pointing at MZero, there's been no additional momentum to kill him and even people talking to him like he's town.

Im undecided on mzero. That being said, theres been no additional momentum to kill sultan for hours and sultan shared who he was pointing at when he shared his claim, so I dont think the timing really says much

UnderUrMattress posted...

I hate that this is probably what is going to happen.

You hate town cop getting a permanent power up, or sultan getting to pick who he kills