Current Events > Woman falsely arrested while pregnant due to facial recognition technology

(+) Yeah! (+)

A Detroit woman is suing the city and a police detective after she was falsely arrested because of facial recognition technology while she was eight months pregnant, according to court documents.

Porcha Woodruff, 32, was getting her two children ready for school on the morning of Feb. 16 when six police officers showed up at her doorstep and presented her with an arrest warrant alleging robbery and carjacking.

Woodruff initially believed the officers were joking given her visibly pregnant state. She was arrested.

"Ms. Woodruff later discovered that she was implicated as a suspect through a photo lineup shown to the victim of the robbery and carjacking, following an unreliable facial recognition match," court documents say.

The robbery victim told police that on Jan. 29 he met a woman whom he had sexual intercourse with. At some point in the day, they went to a BP gas station, where the woman "interacted with several individuals," according to the lawsuit.

They then left for another location, where the victim was robbed and carjacked at gunpoint by a man whom the woman had interacted with earlier at the BP gas station. The victim told police his phone was returned to the gas station two days later.

The lawsuit, filed Thursday in U.S. District Court for Eastern Michigan, names Detective LaShauntia Oliver, who was assigned to the case, as a defendant.

When Oliver learned that a woman had returned the victim's phone to the gas station, she ran facial technology on the video, which identified her as Woodruff, the lawsuit alleges.

"Detective Oliver stated in detail in her report what she observed in the video footage, and there was no mention of the female suspect being pregnant," the lawsuit says.

When a man was arrested driving the victim's car on Feb. 2, Oliver failed to show him a picture of Woodruff, according to court documents.

The victim was also shown a lineup of potential suspects and identified Woodruff as the woman he was with when he was robbed. Oliver used an eight-year-old picture of Woodruff in the lineup from an arrest in 2015, despite having access to her current driver's license, according to the lawsuit.

On the day Woodruff was arrested, she and her fianc urged officers to check the warrant to confirm whether the woman who committed the crime was pregnant, which they refused to do, the lawsuit alleges.

Woodruff was charged with robbery and carjacking and released from the Detroit Detention Center at around 7 p.m. on $100,000 personal bond.

Her fianc took her to a medical center, where she was diagnosed with a low heart rate due to dehydration and was told she was having contractions from stress related to the incident.
On March 6, the Wayne County Prosecutor's Office dropped the case for "insufficient evidence," according to the lawsuit.

In a statement Sunday, the prosecutor's office said the case was dismissed, which emphasizes that a judge made the final decision, not prosecutors.

The prosecutors office said the warrant that led to Woodruffs arrest was on solid ground. The warrant was appropriate based upon the facts, it said.

The office said it was dismissed because the victim failed to appear during a preliminary hearing, which was intended to ensure there's sufficient evidence to prosecute. A victim's unwillingness to appear or testify, however, is not an automatic trigger for dismissal.

Evidence can often still carry a case. And it's not clear if prosecutors in this case requested dismissal.

The office confirmed that facial recognition prompted police to include the plaintiff's photo in a six-pack, or array of images of potential suspects in the warrant package.

Detroit Police Chief James E. White said he reviewed the allegations in the lawsuit, which he said are "very concerning."

"We are taking this matter very seriously, but we cannot comment further at this time due to the need for additional investigation," he said in a statement. "We will provide further information once additional facts are obtained and we have a better understanding of the circumstances."

Full Article: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/detroit-woman-sues-city-falsely-arrested-8-months-pregnant-due-facial-rcna98447

https://i.imgur.com/nx0Am3v.jpg

This legit feels like the plot to a Brooklyn 99 cold open

Hitchcock: "We caught that carjacker chief!"
Holt: "...This woman is 8 months pregnant."
Scully: "She was the only one we could catch."

Think I read that not a single case has been solved using this type of software/tech. At least in the US.

Especially for people of color, it's incredibly inaccurate and just causes huge headaches for everyone. I wouldn't be shocked if it has resulted in the deaths of people, since black people are far more likely to die in any confrontation with the police than white people.

UnfairRepresent posted...

Hitchcock: "We caught that carjacker chief!"
Holt: "...This woman is 8 months pregnant."
Scully: "She was the only one we could catch."

I can picture this so vividly

this is fucked up

seriously fuck this technology and fuck the copaganda in media trying to depict this technology as good

This reeks of lazy pig work by these oinkers

check the warrant like they said

fucking idiots

So how do the cops get our names/faces for the facial recognition? Dont think many consent to giving this info willingly to the cops.

BlueTigerLion posted...

So how do the cops get our names/faces for the facial recognition? Dont think many consent to giving this info willingly to the cops.

Social media sites probably sell it to them

BlueTigerLion posted...

So how do the cops get our names/faces for the facial recognition? Dont think many consent to giving this info willingly to the cops.

They have access to driver's license photos.

Amakusa posted...

So how do the cops get our names/faces for the facial recognition? Dont think many consent to giving this info willingly to the cops.

They have access to driver's license photos.

Plus she had already been arrested

Considering that the 8 year old photo was the one they showed the victim, it's very possible it's the same one on file for this face recongition thing

More like racial recognition technology

RchHomieQuanChi posted...

More like racial recognition technology

zing

After the last few stories on here it could've ended alot worse than falsely arrested.

bigtiggie23 posted...

After the last few stories on here it could've ended alot worse than falsely arrested.

Jeez :/

Another instance of AI used in legal cases not being the best idea.

Wherethisfeom posted...

Who could've expected this

Anyone who's interacted with a traffic camera ticket, which is half as smart as any of these facial recognition AI.

UnfairRepresent posted...

On the day Woodruff was arrested, she and her fianc urged officers to check the warrant to confirm whether the woman who committed the crime was pregnant, which they refused to do, the lawsuit alleges.

And yet I get in hot water when I say that the police in this country should be treated as an invading army. This is literal terrorism perpetrated by the boys in blue.

Gritty posted...

This reeks of lazy pig work by these oinkers

check the warrant like they said

fucking idiots

Reminds me of the Ned Kelly movie with Heath Ledger.

I dont suppose I could see those warrants?
(cop pulls out gun)
Heres your warrants.

The difference being that the 19th century Victoria Police actually got investigated and cleaned up. US police can still behave that way and nothing gets done about it.

RchHomieQuanChi posted...

More like racial recognition technology

Sad that this isn't joke. The tech was made by white guys who used mainly white people as recognition models.

indica posted...

Sad that this isn't joke. The tech was made by white guys who used mainly white people as recognition models.

Regardless of who makes it, if most of the country is white, it's gonna be less accurate with minorities

UnfairRepresent posted...

Regardless of who makes it, if most of the country is white, it's gonna be less accurate with minorities

But it still fits perfectly with all the other ways black people are unfairly targeted by US police.