Board 8 > Dead by Daylight Mafia Topic 1: Happy Halloween!

(+) Yeah! (+)

PunishedBen posted...

And no, I don't think they're the type who rolls mafia and gets to see what the mafia PM looks like and then decides to play 4d chess with that post. Don't even try it, Lopen

I really hate this because who the fuck are you to say what scum has or has not been told

htaeD posted...

Here is another picture

Are they siblings? They look so close, so young

red13n posted...

I thought Sultan was scum last game for being inattentive and quiet. Hes the opposite here but I don't think I'm suddenly going to start immediately thinking hes scum for that.

Last game I pretty much was inactive beacuse of champs I tried a gambit to get atleast an action off before I died obviously didn't work

PeaceFrog posted...

I really hate this because who the fuck are you to say what scum has or has not been told

On the other hand it makes Ben look too naive. Though I suppose he could be projecting knowledge he should not have.
PeaceFrog posted...

Are they siblings? They look so close, so young

Yeah from the same litter, about 4 months old now.
We specifically wanted instead of one who would always be alone.

Hope Lea is okay unlike her not to have posted yet

If either sbell or igcd are scum then i think Ben is too and he just showed a bit too much of his hand. As town he only knows that scum knows what SOLO QUEUE is, but can't know if scum was told anything beyond that.

My girlfriend has been wanting to get a second cat... but the one we have is already plaguing my allergies enough. I wonder if getting new vent filters or something for the house will make it easier to tolerate, because i feel bad that we are depriving this girl of a friend.

Cat allergies are a curse indeed.

2 things real quick before I start my day and try to do a more thorough read back of the last 50ish posts.

The red flag with ulti is his acting like green clearing me early actually matters (spoiler alert. it never has).

Dumey gets zero negative feels from me regarding his miller question and I do not like how he was forced into defensive mode. I will say that dumey loves to bus me and knows I'm an easy target as scum, I think a town dumey immediately sees a different open to this game for me and signs on to my almost assuredly town status. So negative points here in wanting to keep the option open to say I'm scum this early.

that last point on dumey isn't super concrete and would not be enough to make me want to lynch him. I'm more concerned with those thst would crucify him for asking about a miller claim.

htaeD posted...

Why ask Red about his traits and role name first? Why not ask about his flavor?

Pretty sure Red never claims flavor unless forced to, so the lack of flavor didn't really bother me. Also we know next to nothing about flavor split and I would assume that scum has a safe list, so I don't really care whether he has a fitting flavor or not. What I was more interested in was if he was XY Miller, or something funky like Misunderstood YZ. Just for the record, since role fishing for Miller Power was the primary criticism, the event that it is the latter could still mean it is something like Misunderstood Y Vanilla and not immediately some power. That's why I was asking if it was role or trait.


wallmasterz posted...

Isquen stated this first post and some of us have referenced this. Apparently this idea just sprung to mind organically/organically for you >_>

While this is a good point and I agree with your reading of the opening post now, I'm gonna admit that I think I glossed over the "All Players have been notified" bit, because I already knew from my role.

But now with that detail clarified, I wonder if the people with strong town reads on SBell or IGCD because of their first posts would think differently, KNOWING that they were told before the game that SOLO QUEUE was the name of Town. Does it still seem genuine, or is it more possible for it to be manufactured.

I'll note that I'm not throwing suspicion on SBell or IGCD here, just questioning people like Ben who seem willing to hard clear them just because he had a similar thought from before the game even started.

Also Wallz, I did make another post about other thoughts already too. Let's not play the "Talk about more than just one thing" game on Page 3 when I have already mentioned the only two things to happen this game so far. Just sounds lazy.

Oh also, I did want to say I don't like how Red never bothered to respond to me at all, letting other people fight his battles. He didn't even respond to call me an idiot for asking a dumb question or anything. I remember when Red in a previous game claimed his role that needed to hammer to power up, and was super combatative with me in particular because I was calling him out (or it was something else before he claimed his real thing, the point is Red was very active in defending his claim then). And now he's content to let other people talk for him? Slight scum lean on Red because I know as scum he likes to sit back and let town talk themselves into a corner.

Obellisk posted...

I think a town dumey immediately sees a different open to this game for me and signs on to my almost assuredly town status

Respectfully, I think if you look back at my previous games, I am ALWAYS resistant to easily give someone "assuredly town" status. I don't like hard clears on behavior alone. Way too easy to get trapped by a lucky scum player who happened to make a good post.

To your credit though, I think an SBell who thinks he's secure and "assuredly town" enough to humble brag about it probably is more of a town SBell tell. :)

EDumey posted...

Way too easy to get trapped by a lucky scum player who happened to make a good post.

Sbell is the unluckiest scum player.

htaeD posted...

Cat allergies are a curse indeed.

I have them and I swear cats know beacuse cats love me lol

Pretty sure Red never claims flavor unless forced to, so the lack of flavor didn't really bother me. Also we know next to nothing about flavor split and I would assume that scum has a safe list, so I don't really care whether he has a fitting flavor or not. What I was more interested in was if he was XY Miller, or something funky like Misunderstood YZ. Just for the record, since role fishing for Miller Power was the primary criticism, the event that it is the latter could still mean it is something like Misunderstood Y Vanilla and not immediately some power. That's why I was asking if it was role or trait.

Ah
I somehow never took notice of Reds quirk to never claim flavor. Explains why nobody payed attention to it much.
I suppose your question is fair then as well since I see that you were questioning what the flavor split is.
Without giving anything away I can at least say my own flavor PM doesnt make the split super clear either.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

I have them and I swear cats know beacuse cats love me lol

They do. Whenever my and my friends played DND, my cats wanted to sit on the allergic one.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Anyways I didn't read the opening posts like usual and I'm inquiring now to figure out what "Trait" is even supposed to mean and what mine is even supposed to be because I feel like I have way more questions than answers about something that's apparently part of the game.

Your failure to segue back to the above leaves me to believe it was purely theater.

Feel honored Crescent, I almost never vote day 1.

##vote: crescent

Obellisk posted...

Your failure to segue back to the above leaves me to believe it was purely theater.

Feel honored Crescent, I almost never vote day 1.

##vote: crescent

I did note this post of Crescents, because she was obviously involved in the conversation about reading the role PMs and coming to conclusions about them, but apparently had to go back and review the traits? That seemed contradictory to me. Not 100% sure how I feel about it though.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Scum big mad town is all vibing.

Town big mad town is all vibing.

Get off my generator. We gotta split up and work on multiple objectives! (I have never played DBD but I have watched other people play here or there.)

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]

HI LEA glad you're not dead

EDumey posted...

KNOWING that they were told before the game that SOLO QUEUE was the name of Town. Does it still seem genuine, or is it more possible for it to be manufactured.

I have typed out like 10 different responses to this and I fear that each one will get me modkilled. Sooo... yeah. farts.

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


Yo, can you give me 2 memes that sums up what you've absorbed from this game so far?

Obellisk posted...

Your failure to segue back to the above leaves me to believe it was purely theater.

Feel honored Crescent, I almost never vote day 1.

##vote: crescent

Oh I got a response overnight, I just have no inclination to share what that response was at this time. It reeks of the host trying too hard.

PeaceFrog posted...

If either sbell or igcd are scum then i think Ben is too and he just showed a bit too much of his hand. As town he only knows that scum knows what SOLO QUEUE is, but can't know if scum was told anything beyond that.

My girlfriend has been wanting to get a second cat... but the one we have is already plaguing my allergies enough. I wonder if getting new vent filters or something for the house will make it easier to tolerate, because i feel bad that we are depriving this girl of a friend.

Disagree. I think Ben is much more likely to be scum if SBell and IGCD are both town.

##unvote

*pulls out a chair for Crescent*

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


Ben, is Lea mega giga ultra confirmed town now, or merely confirmed town?

Hmm. You're viewing it as, excited Ben wanted to piggy back off of their confirmed* town status in hopes that it would rub off on him?

* I don't think either of them is confirmed at all and at best it's 1% in their favor vs a null tell.

I'm a bit disturbed that unvote came so easily given the grandstanding that came when it was made but I also don't think it's a scum SBell play.

Crescent-Moon posted...

I'm a bit disturbed that unvote came so easily given the grandstanding that came when it was made but I also don't think it's a scum SBell play.

Sbell has also been horrifically bad & unlucky in his scum games so i don't blame him for trying something different if he is scum.

He hasn't lost the vibe check today so far, I'll give him that much.

PeaceFrog posted...

Hmm. You're viewing it as, excited Ben wanted to piggy back off of their confirmed* town status in hopes that it would rub off on him?

* I don't think either of them is confirmed at all and at best it's 1% in their favor vs a null tell.

I'm viewing it as scum Ben deciding to be cute and immediately buddying up to two town at the start of the game for no actual justification.

PeaceFrog posted...

Sbell has also been horrifically bad & unlucky in his scum games so i don't blame him for trying something different if he is scum.

He hasn't lost the vibe check today so far, I'll give him that much.

Speaking of vibe checks, this post doesn't pass one.

Well hopefully Ben comes back and give us more than he has

Crescent-Moon posted...

I'm a bit disturbed that unvote came so easily given the grandstanding that came when it was made but I also don't think it's a scum SBell play.

You said something which just hit perfectly for me and I dont think as scum you answer as you did.

Sultan, I'm not really concerned with hopefully, nor am i interested in pushing ben just because he didn't give enough.

I want to hear Peaf's thought process as it goes from "I get the bad vibes from Ben too" without explaining why to "If SBell or IGCD is scum Ben is scum", given he doesn't mention SBell or IGCD in a single post before this and it only exists to tie them as scum to Ben instead of calling Ben scum directly.

I'd like to see a good reason why SBell or IGCD flipping scum, especially given I now have slight townleans on both of those too irregardless of my scumread on Ben. I don't understand what showing too much of his hand is even supposed to mean in this context, and would even wager that very "logic" makes more sense if the two are both town with him.

Then Peaf goes on to immediately attempt to dissolve the specific reason I townleaned SBell. I don't like this progression at all.

Far to early reads list beacuse I'm bored

Ashethan- very meh null but on the scum end
Chaeix / jc- town i think JC has probably been the most genuine player so far this game.
Corrik7 / Corrik- Corrik is being day 1 corrik so null
Crescent-Moon- if she is scum shes very good at it. This resembles the Town Crescent that i remember
EDumey / Dumey- meh? I think i get where Dumey is coming from with the questions but i also see where Creasent is coming from when it comes to be a little bit of fishing
Forceful_Dragon / FD- has he posted yet?
htaeD / Death- so far so good
IfGodCouldDie / IGCD- so far i think these jabs he has thrown look pretty town like.
Lea- odd for her to be so inactive but it is probablyNI
Obellisk / Sbell- town sbell alot of the things he is doing doesnt seem like something scum sbell woul do
PeaceFrog- another Meh? Just feels flat so far.
PunishedBen / Ben- dont like ben only pop ins have been very underwhelming and wrong
red13n / Leafeon13n- red is always a hard read but I'm thinking Null but on the town end

UltimateBrohan / Brohan- I got nothing
UltimaterializerX / Ulti- ulti clearing half the game for a bad reason Is something I can see both Ultis doing but I'm leaning town here
wallmasterz / Wallz- I'm disappointed so far in wallz it could just be his scum game and not being comfortable

There have been 2 topics of discussion and Cats.

Sultan, there is no way you could possibly think that list even out of boredom could be considered content.

Hello Peafro.

Just looking for a little engagement, what do you think about my post #160? Is this just a normal Red vibe to not respond? He was definitely in the topic and responded to multiple other posts after Cresecent and I went back and forth. Or would you expect him to be a little more direct with me?

Cats?!

WHERE

Full disclosure I had Corrik on ignore, forgot I had him on ignore, and forgot he was even in this game until Sultan just brought his name up. It's since been fixed.

Obellisk posted...

There have been 2 topics of discussion and Cats.

Sultan, there is no way you could possibly think that list even out of boredom could be considered content.

Their has been a bit more than that but like I said far to early

Crescent-Moon posted...

Full disclosure I had Corrik on ignore, forgot I had him on ignore, and forgot he was even in this game until Sultan just brought his name up. It's since been fixed.

It's "See you D2 Corrik" this game because I didn't let him see D2 last game. :)

And I died for it. Oops.

Crescent-Moon posted...

I want to hear Peaf's thought process

Yeah you're not going to get any essays from me this morning. Sorry not sorry. If you want to hear my Ben thoughts, they come into play with my reply to dumey below. Take care.

EDumey posted...

Hello Peafro.

Just looking for a little engagement, what do you think about my post #160? Is this just a normal Red vibe to not respond? He was definitely in the topic and responded to multiple other posts after Cresecent and I went back and forth. Or would you expect him to be a little more direct with me?

Yes it is normal red as both alignments. I thought death was leaning town until he responded to that post of yours. I don't like how he approached it, so thank you for giving me that context on him even though i know it wasn't your intent.

I don't think any of our other Lea-game-mates are in this game so i don't expect anyone else to really understand your point about Miller in that way. I got what you were going for, and is the reason why i didn't like Ben assuming something about what scum would or wouldn't be told about town. It felt to me like it was a parallel to saying "oh there's NO WAY scum could know that there's NO MILLER guys, of COURSE we have to trust that they're both being truthful here!!!"

PeaceFrog posted...

Yeah you're not going to get any essays from me this morning. Sorry not sorry. If you want to hear my Ben thoughts, they come into play with my reply to dumey below. Take care.

So... Basically you're calling Ben scum but you want to see if SBell or IGCD is scum so you can justify calling Ben scum without any reason to believe either of them are scum? Got it.

Come to think of it, it's actually pretty wild that I already have 3 scumreads in this game.

Wonder how long until I get shot~

Nope. Conditional arguments, friend. Not absolute. But thanks for having a good time with it.

Obellisk posted...

There have been 2 topics of discussion and Cats.

Sultan, there is no way you could possibly think that list even out of boredom could be considered content.

Also I totally disagree with you.

I already have four townreads (You, IGCD, Red, JC), and three scumreads (Dumey, Ben, Peaf).

Crescent-Moon posted...

Also I totally disagree with you.

I already have four townreads (You, IGCD, Red, JC), and three scumreads (Dumey, Ben, Peaf).

Oh i dont mean you cant possibly have any reads. I meant it specifically to making a full player list as Sultan chose to do.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

wallmasterz / Wallz- I'm disappointed so far in wallz it could just be his scum game and not being comfortable

Dad?