Board 8 > Community Mafia Topic 10 - Night Kill School

(+) Yeah! (+)

PunishedBen posted...

Why the he'll third party and not scum?

Third-party gives a better excuse for why you've been so diligent and accurate about clearing town interactions. Like I said before, if you're scum, you deserve an Oscar for how well you've been presenting evidence and arguments for people.

Plus, your condition for becoming Bulletproof is just downright bizarre. That's the main thing that's been bugging me about your role.

Speaking of protection: Ulti has spent ages insisting a doctor existed and that there had to be more protection in 19 than just Kirby, but completely contradicted himself and is immediately trying to lynch the doctor.

I mean how hard is this really.

Kirby321 posted...

Because you're going to get yourself lynched Corrik-style if you don't be honest right now :P
Plus, something doesn't add up.

I'm Jailer.
Blade is Doctor.
And you're apparently Bulletproof.

That feels like a lot of protection for town.

Why in God's name would you reveal that.

I can only assume this is nefarious

I want to vote Kirby right now because I don't understand it

ctes needs to claim as well

TotallyNotMI posted...

...Buddy as *bulletproof* neighborizer?

No kill it

##Vote: Ben

I wouldn't jump the gun just yet. I want to hear from Chang and MZero, too.

Because maybe I am just being overly paranoid about a town Ben. Don't trust just my opinion. I just don't like when people continue to be secretive during a massclaim when Corrik being deceptive screwed us over already.

PunishedBen posted...

Why in God's name would you reveal that.

I can only assume this is nefarious

I want to vote Kirby right now because I don't understand it

Well good to know I was right about Ben.

Scum has absolutely zero reason to do what Kirby does on day 2.

UltimaterializerX posted...

##Unvote
##Vote: Ben

I cede to the flavor experts.

lol bus vote

Hmph. I am wary of trusting doc and jk together. Hell I'm wary of trusting any protection with jk.

Honestly i was sort of expecting blade was going to claim bg.

Blade I trust you right now and have zero interest in lynching you today

but please take a breath. Take a break if you need to. Stay clear headed.

Leafeon13N posted...

Hmph. I am wary of trusting doc and jk together. Hell I'm wary of trusting any protection with jk.

Honestly i was sort of expecting blade was going to claim bg.

Oh I don't even blame you on that from a setup meta standpoint.

I think scum really fucked up on day 1 by wasting whatever they used on Lopen.

TotallyNotMI posted...

Blade I trust you right now and have zero interest in lynching you today

but please take a breath. Take a break if you need to. Stay clear headed.

Uh I'm basically telling you who the scumteam is.

And it looks like Ben just claimed scum AGAIN so lol

Man why was I not neighborized.

I am offended by that being basically the only person on the board that has never been neighborized nor in a mason chat.

I will say one serious thing. Kirby seemed like the most obvious n2 kill to me so that's an interesting neighbor.

Oh and who's the guy who immediately launched personal attacks on me when I said Ben claimed scum the first time? That was Peaf.

This is too easy.

i mean tbh it made sense to me that ben wouldn't claim if that was a real town role because exactly this would happen lol

When did the neighborizing happen.

Meow1000 posted...

Well good to know I was right about Ben.

Scum has absolutely zero reason to do what Kirby does on day 2.

Notice how i DIDN'T vote Kirby? Because logic is telling me that too. I just don't understand why Kirby thinks that's a good idea to reveal. It could have stopped a kill and clinched the game.

PunishedBen posted...

Why in God's name would you reveal that.

I can only assume this is nefarious

I want to vote Kirby right now because I don't understand it

Scum is missing a nightkill, is down two members, and until SBell, town has only lost Vanillas so far.

I don't see a reason to hide info at this point in the game. You're not going to get shot when Doctor and Jailer are both openly claimed right now.

he's not going to get shot he's going to get lynched lol

PunishedBen posted...

Notice how i DIDN'T vote Kirby? Because logic is telling me that too. I just don't understand why Kirby thinks that's a good idea to reveal. It could have stopped a kill and clinched the game.

i mean honestly what is the soonest you think scum would kill a neighborizer right now? You'd be so low priority.

changmas posted...

i mean tbh it made sense to me that ben wouldn't claim if that was a real town role because exactly this would happen lol

I would have claimed. AFTER I definitively stopped a kill, or if I had good info from a dead player, like who Kirby role blocked tonight.

ctesjbuvf posted...

Man why was I not neighborized.

I am offended by that being basically the only person on the board that has never been neighborized nor in a mason chat.

I will say one serious thing. Kirby seemed like the most obvious n2 kill to me so that's an interesting neighbor.

I wouldn't claim for Chang so I could pop a save on Kirby night 2 that no one would've expected came from me. Kirby was the "obvious" kill, but scum's been pretty clearly power hunting.

We currently have 4 ways to stop a kill being claimed.

Ben walk me through the logic of each of your choices

I kind of feel like town Ben would have neighborized me to try to get a feel for my alignment after having me in his POE consistantly

Leafeon13N posted...

We currently have 4 ways to stop a kill being claimed.

4? What aside from Kirby, me, and the obviously scum Ben?

Kirby321 posted...

Scum is missing a nightkill, is down two members, and until SBell, town has only lost Vanillas so far.

I don't see a reason to hide info at this point in the game. You're not going to get shot when Doctor and Jailer are both openly claimed right now.

I didn't have to reveal the BP ever. It could have lasted till end game. Same strategy as body guard last game. Keep that shit a secret. I'm tired of towns claiming BP. There is never a reason to

i think this is scum ben continuing scum's MO of power hunting by trying to get out more claims

Meow1000 posted...

Kirby was the "obvious" kill, but scum's been pretty clearly power hunting.

Yeah but we didn't know that then, at the time they hadn't had a night kill yet.

Meow1000 posted...

4? What aside from Kirby, me, and the obviously scum Ben?

Kirby is two ways.

PunishedBen posted...

I didn't have to reveal the BP ever. It could have lasted till end game. Same strategy as body guard last game. Keep that shit a secret. I'm tired of towns claiming BP. There is never a reason to

So why did you tell it in a neighbor chat?

ctesjbuvf posted...

Yeah but we didn't know that then, at the time they hadn't had a night kill yet.

Wallz' flip made it ridiculously obvious that Kirby blocked him sending the kill.

changmas posted...

i mean tbh it made sense to me that ben wouldn't claim if that was a real town role because exactly this would happen lol

Did Ben ask you to copy/paste a long poem close to the night action deadline, saying he'd become Bulletproof if you did so?

It doesn't make sense for scum or third-party Ben to be inconsistent in that regard, and I certainly don't think Ben should be lynched today, but does that condition not strike you as extremely odd? The poem part, I mean.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Im Frankie Dart, the cop. Yes, I somehow rolled cop two games in a row.

I made my scans very very obvious, in order I went ctes/Death/SBell. Scanned ctes night 1 because I wanted to just repeat last game. Scanned Death because Death should always be scanned. Scanned SBell because surely scum wont kill him early again.

So were at a very simple game state. We lynch Ben today. If I die tonight, Blade gets lynched tomorrow and no one else. If hes the real town doctor, he is to keep me alive so I can scan again. With any other outcome, he is tomorrows lynch.

aka, if Blade is scum he is now 100% cornered no matter what. If hes angry town, hell end up dead tonight and I get another scan.

So basically Ulti is scum godfather claiming cop actually confirms people got it.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Im Frankie Dart, the cop. Yes, I somehow rolled cop two games in a row.

I made my scans very very obvious, in order I went ctes/Death/SBell. Scanned ctes night 1 because I wanted to just repeat last game. Scanned Death because Death should always be scanned. Scanned SBell because surely scum wont kill him early again.

So were at a very simple game state. We lynch Ben today. If I die tonight, Blade gets lynched tomorrow and no one else. If hes the real town doctor, he is to keep me alive so I can scan again. With any other outcome, he is tomorrows lynch.

aka, if Blade is scum he is now 100% cornered no matter what. If hes angry town, hell end up dead tonight and I get another scan.

so ctes and death are NOT confirmed

Meow1000 posted...

Wallz' flip made it ridiculously obvious that Kirby blocked him sending the kill.

I meant that we didn't know they were power hunting.

also ben are you that confident that no one that you neighborized is scum?

TotallyNotMI posted...

so ctes and death are NOT confirmed

What a shock, Ulti is full of shit.

ctesjbuvf posted...

I meant that we didn't know they were power hunting.

Why do you think I made damn well sure I didn't claim so I could save Kirby

Kirby321 posted...

Did Ben ask you to copy/paste a long poem close to the night action deadline, saying he'd become Bulletproof if you did so?

It doesn't make sense for scum or third-party Ben to be inconsistent in that regard, and I certainly don't think Ben should be lynched today, but does that condition not strike you as extremely odd? The poem part, I mean.

yes, but I googled the poem and it looked mostly harmless to me.

Lopen was cop would be an awful turn of events.

Ulti why have you been using the term confirmed and acting like you're a ridiculous OP role

Meow1000 posted...

Why do you think I made damn well sure I didn't claim so I could save Kirby

All I was saying was that Kirby as a target for neighborizer n2 is weird because you would think there is a good chance he dies.

If I didn't make it clear I was talking about Ben and not you I apologize.

UltimaterializerX posted...

So were at a very simple game state. We lynch Ben today. If I die tonight, Blade gets lynched tomorrow and no one else. If hes the real town doctor, he is to keep me alive so I can scan again. With any other outcome, he is tomorrows lynch.

We are not lynching Ben over Red today.

I'm paranoid of Ben, but that's because he insists on keeping secrets in a massclaim. But I don't think he's scum.

Red has nothing going for him and should be lynched. None of this "keep him alive until he's scanned" bullshit because you clearly aren't gonna scan him :P