https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/poll/2088-devil-division-round-1-magus-vs-knuckles-the-echidna
This is still one of the most shocking round 1 upsets we've ever had. Many people thought Magus could beat Sonic, and yet here he was, losing to Knuckles. Even someone like me, who thought he was a fraud, didn't think he was this overrated. The Oracle average was a little over 60% for Magus, and nobody in the Oracle, BOP, or Guru picked Knuckles to win this match.
When the match started, things seemed to going according to plan. Magus was at around 58.5% at the freeze, but on the next update, he dropped a full two percent. 20 minutes in, he was under 55% now, and people began to acknowledge he might be in trouble against Squall. As he continued to stall, then we began to think Magus might actually lose this. After all, Sonic had a great day vote, and CT had a terrible one.
The first cut for Knuckles came an hour and a half into the match. The peak lead for Magus was 646 votes two and a half hours in, and then the comeback began. Knuckles had the leak five hours later and left Magus in the dust. The lead actually peaked at around 2700 votes, and then Magus cut off about a thousand votes toward the end to make it look slightly less embarrassing. Regardless, this was a historic upset. Only 35% of the site had Knuckles winning this one. Naturally, the board immediately began rooting for Knuckles to beat Squall next round, but more on that when the time comes.
Magus would only finish in 1st place again one time after this, and that was his round 1 match in 2013.
http://i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/080/145/638.png