Lurker > DoomTheGyarados

Anyway 3-4 scum left and I will grab a red bull after the movie. Poor death.
---

Sir Chris

benjamin3740 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I legit passed out. Gj corrik.

In aquaman. More later. But gj corrik.

Corrik VOTED. That's all Corrik did. He did not push DYL at all or even ask him to claim prior to deciding to vote him.

Saying GG Corrik feels fake to me. Gotta say

He wanted praise vs I was nice.

Okay.

And hey, if Plum is actually town, I'll give Corrik town points. But at the moment he's not, and Corrik's involvement in lynching DYL was nothing more than a vote, which would have happened no matter who he voted for in the case of scum/scum

Blocker though? Pretty nice roll.
---

Sir Chris

benjamin3740 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I legit passed out. Gj corrik.

In aquaman. More later. But gj corrik.

Corrik VOTED. That's all Corrik did. He did not push DYL at all or even ask him to claim prior to deciding to vote him.

Saying GG Corrik feels fake to me. Gotta say

He wanted praise vs I was nice.
---

Sir Chris

I am scum irl but not in game I guess.

Also lol plum.
---

Sir Chris

red13n posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

red13n posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

red13n posted...

Johnbobb posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Frankly I'm surprised that scumteam DIDN'T kill Chris

yeah, admittedly pretty weird.

I almost never see a game where Chris makes it past N1 anymore

Chris is probably just scum. He finished on a splinter and hardly particpated for him tbh. His biggest contribution was asking people for information on a dumb list with one known scum.

Lol

weak response.

I am in the movies shh

what the hell are you browsing on your phone while in the movies? bad form.

0 light. No one can see
---

Sir Chris

red13n posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

red13n posted...

Johnbobb posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Frankly I'm surprised that scumteam DIDN'T kill Chris

yeah, admittedly pretty weird.

I almost never see a game where Chris makes it past N1 anymore

Chris is probably just scum. He finished on a splinter and hardly particpated for him tbh. His biggest contribution was asking people for information on a dumb list with one known scum.

Lol

weak response.

I am in the movies shh
---

Sir Chris

red13n posted...

Johnbobb posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Frankly I'm surprised that scumteam DIDN'T kill Chris

yeah, admittedly pretty weird.

I almost never see a game where Chris makes it past N1 anymore

Chris is probably just scum. He finished on a splinter and hardly particpated for him tbh. His biggest contribution was asking people for information on a dumb list with one known scum.

Lol
---

Sir Chris

I legit passed out. Gj corrik.

In aquaman. More later. But gj corrik.
---

Sir Chris

No need to talk sk. Both shots claimed. Stop.
---

Sir Chris

Going to get to*
Wow chris lol
---

Sir Chris

Anyway just got off work and I am dead. I am not goubfvtobgetvto day 1 due to circumstances of work boo.

We are in a good position to narrow our poe though.
---

Sir Chris

Johnbobb posted...

one thing I've learned from this is that anybody can fit anything. Some are better fits than others, but I could make an argument for probably a dozen P5 characters being SKs.

Name 5
---

Sir Chris

To be clear the poe I use is progressive. Which means I eliminate based off of the day. Ed lynch is top priority so I let others go.
---

Sir Chris

Got any names beyond plum for me?
---

Sir Chris

Depends. Usually either gets the role or 3 town roles. Both powerful.
---

Sir Chris

Sheep007 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Sheep007 posted...

Bleh I still have weirdly few (i.e one) scumreads on the Ed train even after re-evaluation. I dunno if I'm just off this game or scum were really ready to bus Reg/completely uninvolved in the main trains.

Why would scum bus their godfather detective?

Odds of godfather being used are moderately low, and investigation roles, while somewhat strong, aren't amazing for scum. I don't really think a role comes into scum bussing too heavily unless it's a wincon role regardless I'm definitely leaning scum on Plum too which means at least one was bussing, and I don't think almost all scum were off a train (I think Town on Red and probably Corrik, although I'm still very undecided on the latter, for example.).

What detective is super strong for scum. Stopped reading there. This post is just a hard no.
---

Sir Chris

Also who has not answered if they are a phantom thief?
---

Sir Chris

Sheep007 posted...

Bleh I still have weirdly few (i.e one) scumreads on the Ed train even after re-evaluation. I dunno if I'm just off this game or scum were really ready to bus Reg/completely uninvolved in the main trains.

Why would scum bus their godfather detective?
---

Sir Chris

htaeD posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Shad was not on my list.

Death may well be town. He missed a bunch of stuff as town last game.

I like to think I am doing better now <.<

Shad isnt on my list.
---

Sir Chris

Now if I am getting really into meta here: the fact that igcd messed up his vote at the end suggests a rush. If he is scum he would know he would be voting to save Regaro. So maybe town?

Just things that aren't by themselves pure good reads but make me think.

I've seen little reason to like anything about sheep or dyl tbh.
---

Sir Chris

Shad was not on my list.

Death may well be town. He missed a bunch of stuff as town last game.
---

Sir Chris

Basically I am done playing like board 8 chris on board 8 no fire. No 'gut' just analysis and progression.
---

Sir Chris

red13n posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Plum could totally be scum. Not discounting it. But if not him claiming today let's scum have free info. Pass. We arent lynching him.

Death
Igcd
Dyl
Sheep

I think those are the four we want to hone in on. Everyone rank 1-4 with 1 being scummiest. Give reasoning. Give me data points to think on.

"hey everybody rank these 4 people I don't have data". You have a full, pretty active days worth of data. This feels lazy. I don't trust lazy Chris.

What is this? You have a whole days worth of data. No fire? No gut or anything? Just a list of 4 "hey everyone talk".

I don't need fire I am in problem solving mode. Also Thursdays are my TV show day which you know. I work 14 hours. Today I have been posting from work all day. I am getting people to give content. There is value in people posting.
---

Sir Chris

Bluntly I am also ok with all four full claiming. Ed lynch being solved is the best thing for us solve early, dissect the rest.
---

Sir Chris

Plum could totally be scum. Not discounting it. But if not him claiming today let's scum have free info. Pass. We arent lynching him.

Death
Igcd
Dyl
Sheep

I think those are the four we want to hone in on. Everyone rank 1-4 with 1 being scummiest. Give reasoning. Give me data points to think on.
---

Sir Chris

The goal is to lynch or clear through scans/interactions everyone on that ed lynch btw
---

Sir Chris

Plum isnt claiming today. Or being lynched. Ed voters only.
---

Sir Chris

IfGodCouldDie posted...

So Chris, I hope you paid attention to that. Death tried to come in and coattail you on me but once you stopped interacting with me so did he.

He is in my poe too.
---

Sir Chris

I don't quite agree. I am not saying you were wrong but dyl is a weak town player so expectations need to be lowered. Also missing power claim information is either null or a slight town lean as scum collectives tend to post about powers on the scum board.

He is firmly in our poe but not exactly who I want lynched. Make similar posts of plum and igcd please. I liked your thought process. Fantastic work.
---

Sir Chris

I am at work, could you please quote yourself actually? It would be a big help.
---

Sir Chris

Please hold.
---

Sir Chris

Hbthebattle posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

IMO both Plum and Sheep are scummy, but Im voting today for the one on the Ed lynch.

HB-kun. Free advice. Until the final minute your final vote isnt important. Explore. Leave no stone unturned. Share ideas and let others share with you.

Chris, this simply isnt true. So many scum escaped through ties, having our votes settled and firm long before the deadline prevents scum from weaseling their way out of it, which is esp. dangerous with the anonymous vote.

Of course scumhunting is important, and we should do it, but the voting should be set before deadline.

I mean to say just because you have a vote on someone doesnt mean you can just shrug and say we are not lynching another person. Your solving today has been weak. You are town but you could be more useful. Friendly advice.
---

Sir Chris

IfGodCouldDie posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Igcd please explain the purpose of your counter vote on me today?

To show you I can vote you the way you voted me.

Yes it is.

Oh I didn't realize that says, "I am voting you to show you I can."

Well you can't possibly mean the reasoning behind it, because I voted for you because you were a vital vote that allowed a member of the mafia to avoid a lynch, whereas my slot was doing its best to ensure that outcome.
---

Sir Chris

Oh and Shaduln stepping up to the plate claiming a Phantom Thief isn't enough to purely town clear him but I will remove him from the PoE today. I also see a replacement is pending so we'll remove the idler for today because that slot should have renewed life going forward.

So our targets today are:

IGCD
DYL
Sheep
Death
Johnbob
Mzero
Plum

My strong preference is someone on the Eaed lynch. Now here's the thing IGCD, you need to stop being stubborn because you are within the PoE that I have declared for the day so even if you are town your lynch helps solve the game for me. This isn't how to play mafia, please cease on being a detriment to the game. It's not fun or fair to anyone.
---

Sir Chris

IfGodCouldDie posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Igcd please explain the purpose of your counter vote on me today?

To show you I can vote you the way you voted me.

Yes it is.
---

Sir Chris

Just so I can put him (or is it her I forget with some people) in again because that post is FABULOUS.

https://usercontent2.hubstatic.com/14197651.jpg
---

Sir Chris

I am taking Ashe out of my confirmed town circle.
---

Sir Chris

IfGodCouldDie posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Igcd please explain the purpose of your counter vote on me today?

To show you I can vote you the way you voted me.

Why do you think I don't know how mafia works?

Death, that a very small window. I think my read is right.

What?

Second line had nothing to do with you. First line why do you think I dont know you can vote for me?

I never said you didn't?

You said you voted me to show me you could. Ergo, I needed to be shown. Ergo, I didn't know.
---

Sir Chris

IfGodCouldDie posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Igcd please explain the purpose of your counter vote on me today?

To show you I can vote you the way you voted me.

Why do you think I don't know how mafia works?

Death, that a very small window. I think my read is right.

What?

Second line had nothing to do with you. First line why do you think I dont know you can vote for me?
---

Sir Chris

Hbthebattle posted...

IMO both Plum and Sheep are scummy, but Im voting today for the one on the Ed lynch.

HB-kun. Free advice. Until the final minute your final vote isnt important. Explore. Leave no stone unturned. Share ideas and let others share with you.
---

Sir Chris

masterplum posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

No nuanced on me "being town", eh Plum?

masterplum posted...

Not a phantom thief, but I hate this line of questioning. I would have argued against it before people started answering the question.

Corrik makes good posts then does stupid things like calling Chris town. Corrik has no f***ing idea if Chris is town. Nobody does. He is Chris and has played 24 hours.

I'm not sure if that makes him more or less likely to be scum

Im talking about why I said nuanced, not that you arent nuanced >_>

Other people read this exchange and tell me if this plum sentence is wrong or if I need a red bull.
---

Sir Chris

No nuanced on me "being town", eh Plum?

masterplum posted...

Not a phantom thief, but I hate this line of questioning. I would have argued against it before people started answering the question.

Corrik makes good posts then does stupid things like calling Chris town. Corrik has no f***ing idea if Chris is town. Nobody does. He is Chris and has played 24 hours.

I'm not sure if that makes him more or less likely to be scum

---

Sir Chris

masterplum posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

masterplum posted...

god, can you not get yourself killed here for no reason

Worry about yourself. Why don't I get day 1 chris status from you? This is day one from me. Where is the sheeping at

We have scum flipped which gives me more to go on. I trust you day 1 blind but once people flip it gets more nuanced

My slot voted the scum. Why is it nuanced?
---

Sir Chris

Phantom thieves are the main cast name.

There is 100% a town thief
---

Sir Chris

masterplum posted...

god, can you not get yourself killed here for no reason

Worry about yourself. Why don't I get day 1 chris status from you? This is day one from me. Where is the sheeping at
---

Sir Chris

IfGodCouldDie posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Igcd please explain the purpose of your counter vote on me today?

To show you I can vote you the way you voted me.

Why do you think I don't know how mafia works?

Death, that a very small window. I think my read is right.
---

Sir Chris

Igcd please explain the purpose of your counter vote on me today?
---

Sir Chris

htaeD posted...

Not at all no.

Also Chri asking for a moment makes me excited indeed.

Ok maybe you are town because as soon. As I posted that I was like "what a town chris thing to do" lol
---

Sir Chris

DoomTheGyarados posted...

htaeD posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Scum had to have sent that command near instantly when it went up. Anyone who posted has to be town tbh

The most curious thing to me is that the anonymous voter let it come to a tie at all.

*tilts head*

Moment.

Just went back. Igcd tied it last second. Scum would not have blown a one use ability like that (I am assuming) in order to tie and make regaro look awful anyway. Not weird. Logical.
---

Sir Chris

htaeD posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Scum had to have sent that command near instantly when it went up. Anyone who posted has to be town tbh

The most curious thing to me is that the anonymous voter let it come to a tie at all.

*tilts head*

Moment.
---

Sir Chris