He does shatter brick with his bare hands (well, gloves but w/e) and throw/punch Bowser around like a ragdoll without any of those powerups, so he's a lot stronger than average guy mcdude
True, but the Low tier also self-describedly includes Badass Normals. While Mario has superhuman strength and mobility, I would say his ranged options and durability aren't up to snuff. I was going to make a comparison to John Wick, until I remembered that, based on these rules, Wick might not have access to any weapons at all. I will say, though, that Mario probably wouldn't even be able to land a single hit on The Player, and while it is a style mismatch, I still don't feel like they belong in the same tier as such (and the latter isn't misplaced).
Mario has legitimate superhuman feats. He lives in a cartoony world where normal physics do not apply.
@scarletspeed7 what tier would you say that Constatine is in? What I found focused mostly on his manipulation which I don't think would be as relevant to this format, so I put him in low based on a pretty poor understanding of his powers
Those two shouldn't be low either. Especially Kenshiro, the guy's nearly invulnerable ---