idk, ask me 5 minutes later and this list could be flipped around some. vriska through kanaya are p. much a lock. nepeta gets brownie points for being a kitty. the rest of the trolls are either meh or gamzee.
--
There is no shame in not knowing; the shame lies in not finding out
Not really surprising that Vriska/Karkat/Terezi make up most non-semi people's top 3s, but nice to note- I vaguely recall a lot of people who ended up despising Vriska for being too good a villain or some nonsense.
--
"Biting is excellent- it's like kissing only there's a winner."
I don't actually dislike any but the bottom 2. Feferi beats Tavros via ancestor since frankly, other than get abused by Vriska and have awkward rap related shenanigans, I find him generally unlikeable. Feferi at least has troll romance? Top 3 are in a league of their own.
I am in a constant flux of not deciding how much I like Vriska. She can be anywhere as high as right below Terezi and anywhere as low as right above Tavros (where she is now). It totally depends on my mood with her. Right now my inclination is to rank her low.
Eridan and Sollux are the only trolls I dislike. They're both kind of unlikeable dicks and not in an endearing way, although Eridan has a saving grace in that his patheticness is sometimes funny and he killed a lot of people. Feferi's the only troll I have no feelings for at all.
As for Gamzee, haters gonna hate. Gamzee's hilarious. Who cares that he's not dead, boohoo.
--
"As the size of an explosion increases, the number of social situations it is incapable of solving approaches zero." -Vaarsuvius, Order of the Stick
Feferi is the worst. She is just so dull. Sollux is pretty cool, but he's useless and he's not too terribly interesting in chatlogs. Aradia is likable, but I can't think of anything where I really went "hell yeah aradia". Aside from FEDORA and Make her pay. Nepeta is funny and has a pretty great relationship with Equius. It doesn't help her case that she basically serves as fanservice to catgirl-lovers. Bleh. Tavros. Rap session with Dave and Gamzee. So good. Relationship with Jade and Vriska is pretty great, too. I'll be honest. Before GANON's pics, Equius would probably be where Aradia is. Seriously, those pics are so good. Plus, those sunglasses and Seek the highb100d is so great. Kanaya has SNARKY HORSE**** feud with Rose, which is pretty damn awesome and she just kind of ties everyone together. and dat kanpire. Eridan is ****ing hilarious, has an excellent design, has one of the best themes of the trolls, has a great typing style, and just generally everything about him is great. And wwizard Eridan is so amazing, because god damn, he made Homestuck a lot more fun. Pretty much everything I said about Eridan can apply to Gamzee. Except I really loved Gamzee, ever since he first showed up. Just everything he did. His convos are so amazing (Eridan/Gamzee convo is just so good. I show it to anyone who dare says that Gamzee/Eridan are bad characters). Sober!Gamzee really made things great and god DAMN, I love Gamzee. Just everything he does is so "**** YEAH GAMZEE". Do I really need to explain on the Karkat/Terezi/Vriska trio. Karkat gets top for being the funniest character in Homestuck, as well as being a rather dynamic character. Terezi gets second due to PW bias, Dave convos, and just everything. Vriska gets third, because...well, she's better than everyone else but not better than Karkat and Terezi.
--
Rank 9, Dr. Peace? Pffft, nothing compared to Rank 1, Dr_Football! when thinking of Krystal, does GMUN's pants get overcrowded? ~ GMUN
I like how Feferi is pretty near bottom on every list. I realise she (or, at least, her Lusus) did have plot importance, but she still feels a bit like Hussie went "jesus do I really have to make an another troll".
Eridan, on the other hand, feels a lot less tacked on, even if most people do hate him! Score one for team Semi(*)?
*that's a joke Semi wouldn't be on a team without strangling the other members
--
"Biting is excellent- it's like kissing only there's a winner."