Board 8 > turbopuns mafia topic 1: not your dad's puns

(+) Yeah! (+)

eaedwards6400 posted...

Meta_Knight123 posted...

You guys do flips when someone dies right?

Have you played a game where they don't?

We don't do flips in video mafia all the time.
---

Meta_Knight123 posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Meta_Knight123 posted...

You guys do flips when someone dies right?

Have you played a game where they don't?

We don't do flips in video mafia all the time.

In fact we recently played matrix six, and think that it feels kinda town sided in video mafia, mainly because flips.
---

@MK: That nerfed vanilla statement was a joke? Well okay welp, I thought you were completely serious and read into it on the assumption you were serious. Can't really fault me for that.

Also I feel like I should point out to you, before it gets confusing, that Leafeon = Red13. He posts using both accounts.

And Nana I wanna know what Gran's town tell is. Personally I don't really care for any of those posts against MK, because his initial post said that either of us could be scum, but it slowly morphed into "MK is scum, Ben is town", when it could have easily went the other way as well. But maybe gran could provide a reason for that
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

##Unvote

MK feels very genuine and I am leaning town. However, I will keep an eye on that "nerfed vanilla" because what could possible be nerfed about a vanilla?

##Vote: Ben

Perhaps, I am reading this incorrectly but in Chrono Cross (a game in which you were scum) you were acting similar to the way that you are acting now. You are making sure you are present but you aren't really coming up with anything. Can you give me anything of substance or anything that resembles substance?

Nanahara715 posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Nana and Terra are you going after PJ because of Chrono Cross because the rules say we aren't supposed to do that

I... what? This post makes no sense to me.

I wouldn't say I'm "going after" PJ. Im voting for him and didn't even give reasoning, so this seems like a defensive overreaction to a vote on not-the-guy-overreacting. Don't like the post.

The bolded part is a joke because Puns rules say that we aren't supposed to meta. Also, voting for someone is going after someone at least I thought it was. However, the underlining point of bringing this up is that you said that you are voting for him [PJ] and you didn't give any reasoning. Care to share?

You think my posts are filler or something?

I think Leafeon, Terra, MK, and Doom are all likely town. The first two for role claims, MK was previously for his claim but is now solely on posts, and Doom I don't even remember why, I just have his name written down
---

if it werent for the post above, I'd call that a textbook scummon
---

Ben what do you think of Ulti
---

oh yeah I re-read his posts page 2. I only like him because he gave me teh gold star oh towniness
---

Yeah that's basically what I was saying but I do like the insight you just gave. That's fine for now.

##Unvote
##Vote: Nana

Basically, I know you haven't showed up yet but I want to see why you voted for PJ.
---

Nanahara715 posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Nana and Terra are you going after PJ because of Chrono Cross because the rules say we aren't supposed to do that

I... what? This post makes no sense to me.

I wouldn't say I'm "going after" PJ. Im voting for him and didn't even give reasoning, so this seems like a defensive overreaction to a vote on not-the-guy-overreacting. Don't like the post.

Earlier eaed
---

benjamin3740 posted...

@MK: That nerfed vanilla statement was a joke? Well okay welp, I thought you were completely serious and read into it on the assumption you were serious. Can't really fault me for that.

Also I feel like I should point out to you, before it gets confusing, that Leafeon = Red13. He posts using both accounts.

And Nana I wanna know what Gran's town tell is. Personally I don't really care for any of those posts against MK, because his initial post said that either of us could be scum, but it slowly morphed into "MK is scum, Ben is town", when it could have easily went the other way as well. But maybe gran could provide a reason for that

Man, I hate this line. I'm getting pulled away a lot and need to reread, but I'd be willing to gamble on Ben as scum
---

I will grant you, Ben that you seem even more naive than you did in Chrono Cross
probably doesnt help that I actively avoided looking too much at you back then
---

##Unvote
##Vote: VI

VI is actually around. VI, is there any reason to voting Ulti besides the "he's the most useless player for either team" argument you made earlier.
---

Oh you both are here. Oops.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

oh yeah I re-read his posts page 2. I only like him because he gave me teh gold star oh towniness

This is in reference to why i wrote Doom down.

As for Ulti, he's someone I'd kill today if it was ending now. Havent gotten a town-tell from him, and I dont care for his posts going after VI because I dont get the logic
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

##Unvote
##Vote: VI

VI is actually around. VI, is there any reason to voting Ulti besides the "he's the most useless player for either team" argument you made earlier.

Is there any reason not to vote for him
---

We're calling scum based on just 7 posts.
---

Oh he made a post about notifications and did nothing for a couple hours then got mad that I called him out on doing nothing

See told you he's obvscum
---

Nanahara715 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

@MK: That nerfed vanilla statement was a joke? Well okay welp, I thought you were completely serious and read into it on the assumption you were serious. Can't really fault me for that.

Also I feel like I should point out to you, before it gets confusing, that Leafeon = Red13. He posts using both accounts.

And Nana I wanna know what Gran's town tell is. Personally I don't really care for any of those posts against MK, because his initial post said that either of us could be scum, but it slowly morphed into "MK is scum, Ben is town", when it could have easily went the other way as well. But maybe gran could provide a reason for that

Man, I hate this line. I'm getting pulled away a lot and need to reread, but I'd be willing to gamble on Ben as scum

I was just trying to ask why you think Gran is town. Because I hadnt seen town in his posts. It's not meant to insinuate he even has a town tell. I worded it cutsey for some reason
---

htaeD posted...

I will grant you, Ben that you seem even more naive than you did in Chrono Cross
probably doesnt help that I actively avoided looking too much at you back then

These and similar posts from death suck. I feel like he is trying to call Ben scum but also wants to exonerate him, and otherwise has posted a decent amount with little to show.

##Vote: Death
---

htaeD posted...

I will grant you, Ben that you seem even more naive than you did in Chrono Cross
probably doesnt help that I actively avoided looking too much at you back then

Naive in what way? If someone is obvtown then I will say it. I've only been wrong about...Corrik. In that one game >.>
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

Yeah that's basically what I was saying but I do like the insight you just gave. That's fine for now.

##Unvote
##Vote: Nana

Basically, I know you haven't showed up yet but I want to see why you voted for PJ.

Wait, is this your first mafia game or something? Why did you single out Nana out of all the random votes on page one?
---

By the way, one thing I find very odd in retrospect from Chris was him saying that calling people Town is a Towny move. I would think he knows better, as scum LOVES to ingratiate themselves with Town by calling them Town. Particularly if it's not on strong basis, so they can justify taking it back whenever convenient. Therefore I also mistrust Chris.

Apologies for lack of extensive quoting, am phone-posting from work.
---

Also, MK, Gran, and Death all come across as town to me. I was right as early as day 2 last game, and if I'm right this game as well, I have Death's town vs scum game pegged down pretty tight.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

I think Leafeon, Terra, MK, and Doom are all likely town. The first two for role claims, MK was previously for his claim but is now solely on posts, and Doom I don't even remember why, I just have his name written down

Damn, if all I have to do to get you to think I'm town is to claim something early, I know what to do net time I roll scum
---

Terra-enforcer posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

I think Leafeon, Terra, MK, and Doom are all likely town. The first two for role claims, MK was previously for his claim but is now solely on posts, and Doom I don't even remember why, I just have his name written down

Damn, if all I have to do to get you to think I'm town is to claim something early, I know what to do net time I roll scum

You wouldnt say you're a powerful role as scum. I dare you to next time though
---

Terra-enforcer posted...

Also, MK, Gran, and Death all come across as town to me. I was right as early as day 2 last game, and if I'm right this game as well, I have Death's town vs scum game pegged down pretty tight.

And what is your super death towntell?
---

Is it normal for Eaed to vote someone any time he has a question for them?

It was kinda weird to me that he didnt ask all the questions at once if they were on his mind, but instead waited till he wanted to move his vote
---

Has anyone here played with eaed before? I don't think he ever answered my question about how much mafia experience he has. He comes across as somewhat noobie to me (even though I'm assuming this can't be one of his first games). I don't like any of his votes. The first one against MK was incredibly weak, and the second two don't make much sense.
---

Sceptilesolar posted...

htaeD posted...

I will grant you, Ben that you seem even more naive than you did in Chrono Cross
probably doesnt help that I actively avoided looking too much at you back then

These and similar posts from death suck. I feel like he is trying to call Ben scum but also wants to exonerate him, and otherwise has posted a decent amount with little to show.

##Vote: Death

I'll be more clear, I am leaning town on Ben based on what I see and feel right now
but I am also admitting to myself that I want to compare his posts to his past play

... eaed, you did archive the previous topic somewhere didnt you?

Or was that a general gamefaqs archive?
---

Terra-enforcer posted...

Has anyone here played with eaed before? I don't think he ever answered my question about how much mafia experience he has. He comes across as somewhat noobie to me (even though I'm assuming this can't be one of his first games). I don't like any of his votes. The first one against MK was incredibly weak, and the second two don't make much sense.

Oh Eaed goes back a looong way
---

Sceptilesolar posted...

Terra-enforcer posted...

Also, MK, Gran, and Death all come across as town to me. I was right as early as day 2 last game, and if I'm right this game as well, I have Death's town vs scum game pegged down pretty tight.

And what is your super death towntell?

Definitely not going to out it just now. Especially not this early on.

benjamin3740 posted...

You wouldnt say you're a powerful role as scum. I dare you to next time though

I was just hinting at having a power role. If all I have to do is have a power role and that alone makes me look town, I'll make sure to find a way next time :)
---

htaeD posted...

Terra-enforcer posted...

Has anyone here played with eaed before? I don't think he ever answered my question about how much mafia experience he has. He comes across as somewhat noobie to me (even though I'm assuming this can't be one of his first games). I don't like any of his votes. The first one against MK was incredibly weak, and the second two don't make much sense.

Oh Eaed goes back a looong way

Ah, good.

##Unvote

##Vote: Eaed
---

He jumped off me reaaallly fast, when all i did was re-state things I already did in previous posts (Which is why i didnt understand the reason for the initial vote either)
---

also I am cheating on mafia right now by posting from work, so forgive a little distraction
---

benjamin3740 posted...

@MK: That nerfed vanilla statement was a joke? Well okay welp, I thought you were completely serious and read into it on the assumption you were serious. Can't really fault me for that.

Also I feel like I should point out to you, before it gets confusing, that Leafeon = Red13. He posts using both accounts.

And Nana I wanna know what Gran's town tell is. Personally I don't really care for any of those posts against MK, because his initial post said that either of us could be scum, but it slowly morphed into "MK is scum, Ben is town", when it could have easily went the other way as well. But maybe gran could provide a reason for that

It's almost as if my first post about it was a knee jerk and then I started thinking about it more as I woke up.

Oh wait, it was, and the only way it read as him town to you potential scum was as a joke post and not as a semi serious claim. Reading it as a serious claim meant he was either trying to get you calling him town and defending him or you were both scum and it was coordinated. Seeing as that seems to not be the case.

##Unvote: Meta
---

htaeD posted...

Terra-enforcer posted...

Has anyone here played with eaed before? I don't think he ever answered my question about how much mafia experience he has. He comes across as somewhat noobie to me (even though I'm assuming this can't be one of his first games). I don't like any of his votes. The first one against MK was incredibly weak, and the second two don't make much sense.

Oh Eaed goes back a looong way

Yeah but he hasn't changed that much since his first game
---

Nanahara715 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

@MK: That nerfed vanilla statement was a joke? Well okay welp, I thought you were completely serious and read into it on the assumption you were serious. Can't really fault me for that.

Also I feel like I should point out to you, before it gets confusing, that Leafeon = Red13. He posts using both accounts.

And Nana I wanna know what Gran's town tell is. Personally I don't really care for any of those posts against MK, because his initial post said that either of us could be scum, but it slowly morphed into "MK is scum, Ben is town", when it could have easily went the other way as well. But maybe gran could provide a reason for that

Man, I hate this line. I'm getting pulled away a lot and need to reread, but I'd be willing to gamble on Ben as scum

Excuses for absence, very little overall presence. Nana plays day 2 or dies.
---

htaeD posted...

I'll be more clear, I am leaning town on Ben based on what I see and feel right now
but I am also admitting to myself that I want to compare his posts to his past play

... eaed, you did archive the previous topic somewhere didnt you?

Or was that a general gamefaqs archive?

Just the Gamefaqs archive Log Faqs or something like that.
---

Terra-enforcer posted...

Sceptilesolar posted...

Terra-enforcer posted...

Also, MK, Gran, and Death all come across as town to me. I was right as early as day 2 last game, and if I'm right this game as well, I have Death's town vs scum game pegged down pretty tight.

And what is your super death towntell?

Definitely not going to out it just now. Especially not this early on.

Uh, what? What possible incentive would you have?
---

Terra, I admittedly missed your question where did you post it?
---

eaed please explain why Ulti shouldn't be lynched
---

I just simply felt he didn't do anything wrong yet. Is a complaint about the notification system really lynchable over?
---

Anyways, because I can, Gran is likely something like a backup sensor or some other inordinately powerful town role where having one is good but two is asininely powerful, to the point where there isn't a legit reason for a legit backup. As such, there probably isn't an actual sensor to backup and as a result can never activate, and as such he's just a named vanilla.

Offchance something funky like "Mafia backup Godfather" when no such Godfather exists to begin with, and as such is a named Goon.
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

I just simply felt he didn't do anything wrong yet. Is a complaint about the notification system really lynchable over?

Your vote is on me. Have I done something wrong?
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

Terra, I admittedly missed your question where did you post it?

I could go back and search up and down to see what I originally posted it, OR you could just answer the question that you read when I reposted it. Both of my questions actually since they should both be on this same page (assuming you're a 50 ppp person)
---

Nanahara715 posted...

Anyways, because I can, Gran is likely something like a backup sensor or some other inordinately powerful town role where having one is good but two is asininely powerful, to the point where there isn't a legit reason for a legit backup. As such, there probably isn't an actual sensor to backup and as a result can never activate, and as such he's just a named vanilla.

Offchance something funky like "Mafia backup Godfather" when no such Godfather exists to begin with, and as such is a named Goon.

Where do you pull these crazy meta-role theories from?
---

Nanahara715 posted...

Anyways, because I can, Gran is likely something like a backup sensor or some other inordinately powerful town role where having one is good but two is asininely powerful, to the point where there isn't a legit reason for a legit backup. As such, there probably isn't an actual sensor to backup and as a result can never activate, and as such he's just a named vanilla.Offchance something funky like "Mafia backup Godfather" when no such Godfather exists to begin with, and as such is a named Goon.

Why do you care?

Scum would love to find out if there are any virtual Vanilla Town. If they don't have to claim power it's so much easier for them. I would this prefer they not be educated on the matter.
---

VeryInsane posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

I just simply felt he didn't do anything wrong yet. Is a complaint about the notification system really lynchable over?

Your vote is on me. Have I done something wrong?

That is a good point but the difference between what I was trying to do and what you are doing is that I had my vote on you because I had a question for you. You have a vote on Ulti and simply stating that he is scum with nothing to back it or even a reason for it.
---

Sceptilesolar posted...

Nanahara715 posted...

Anyways, because I can, Gran is likely something like a backup sensor or some other inordinately powerful town role where having one is good but two is asininely powerful, to the point where there isn't a legit reason for a legit backup. As such, there probably isn't an actual sensor to backup and as a result can never activate, and as such he's just a named vanilla.Offchance something funky like "Mafia backup Godfather" when no such Godfather exists to begin with, and as such is a named Goon.

Why do you care?

Scum would love to find out if there are any virtual Vanilla Town. If they don't have to claim power it's so much easier for them. I would this prefer they not be educated on the matter.

Why do I care about what?

I'm positing my theory for why I believe Gran is town. The whole fucking point of the game is to find and lynch scum, and part of that is eliminating players from your scum pool.
---

UltimaterializerX posted...

Nah I'm good!

##Unvote
##Vote: Ulti

If he's not going to play then he can die. This reminds me of pj last game where he just blatantly chose to contribute nothing.
---