Board 8 > ~~Japanese History Mafia~~ Topic 5 - I know not what life is, nor death

(+) Yeah! (+)

Two things

I don't like how sceptile hid the prosty information. I also don't like that he tried to hold it hostage as info.

Town prosty is definitely in the game here. If sceptile is scum he isn't making it up. Scum prosty shouldn't ever be used other than super specific circumstances.


##unvote
##vote:sceptile
---

Plum, are you actually scum? I really don't see how you can be that bad as to think that.
---

Not revealing town power at first is the only sensible decision in my position. I have no doubts about that.
---

You also have failed to explain how you can justify going after me if I'm telling the truth, as the probability argument demonstrates very clearly that I'm not a rational target.
---

The scum team must be super shit to have devised this story to try to keep sceptile alive. Assuming they have a roleblocker, it's probably sceptile.
---

Yes, the scum team devised this story, and that is why no one is backing me up on it at all. You have solved the mystery.
---

They clearly saw its back fire and are staying far away from you
---

Obellisk posted...

They clearly saw its back fire and are staying far away from you

Well, THAT'S probably true. I am voting VI after all.
---

Ya know what would solve this really fucking quick.

A good old fashion mass claim.

We've got 9 unclaimed players, 1 of who is supposed to be a prostitute according to sceptile.

Let's do this!
---

Sounds like a fine idea to me.
---

Sceptilesolar posted...

Plum, are you actually scum? I really don't see how you can be that bad as to think that.

...I'd say the irony was delicious, but I am genuinely afraid of you starting to say childish rhymes at me on the subject of rubber and glue.

On a completely random note, what do people think of Red?
---

Obellisk posted...

Ya know what would solve this really fucking quick.

A good old fashion mass claim.

We've got 9 unclaimed players, 1 of who is supposed to be a prostitute according to sceptile.

Let's do this!

...
---

masterplum posted...

Obellisk posted...

Ya know what would solve this really fucking quick.

A good old fashion mass claim.

We've got 9 unclaimed players, 1 of who is supposed to be a prostitute according to sceptile.

Let's do this!

...

Well if you didn't have plum on your town list before, he better be there now.
---

Why?
---

Personal feeling based on his response.
---

Oh, well, fine. I wasn't sure if you were implying that your suggestion of a massclaim was some sort of trap and you were going to call anyone town who complained. It seems like a fine time for it IMO.
---

By the way

Sceptilesolar posted...

Is there any lynch that will gain traction today except for me? It seems like everyone I want to talk about gets dismissed. I am displeased by that. Not just dowolf, who continues to do nothing except relentlessly tunnel me.

Town does not post this. Sceptile is begging us to lynch Literally anybody Besides him
---

masterplum posted...

By the way

Sceptilesolar posted...

Is there any lynch that will gain traction today except for me? It seems like everyone I want to talk about gets dismissed. I am displeased by that. Not just dowolf, who continues to do nothing except relentlessly tunnel me.

Town does not post this. Sceptile is begging us to lynch Literally anybody Besides him

I said as much later. I always believe in being frank as part of Town, so yes, I would like you to lynch anybody that isn't me. That is the most important outcome here.
---

I just don't get that view as a vanilla in not horrible position. There are far worse lynches fhan "not you"

How about instead of "not you" you find a better target
---

greengravy294 posted...

now i havent really actually followed this game too closely day 2 (obviously!), but votals dont show a single vote on lolo from scare

dunno why he feels so strongly for me randomly.

like sbell voting me is like an sbell thing. i wonder if scare kind of fell into a trap that really wasn't one (but could be if you didn't really know that sbell literally votes me every game im in w/ him).

food for thought i suppose (i mention this simply because i saw the votals and saw scare voting me which i had literally no recollection of).

He voted Lolo Day 1, fwiw.

Anyway I'm home.
---

Anyways, as I was saying...

Does anyone have thoughts on Red? At all?
---

masterplum posted...

I just don't get that view as a vanilla in not horrible position. There are far worse lynches fhan "not you"

How about instead of "not you" you find a better target

No, there is no lynch that will be more harmful to Town than me. I am 100% Town. No one else is. No one is claimed power either. I guess if someone claimed Town prosty I wouldn't want to lynch them, but other than that, I can't be too picky. That's how I think because I know I am Town.

I would like to lynch VI or dowolf though.
---

dowolf posted...

Anyways, as I was saying...

Does anyone have thoughts on Red? At all?

He's been pretty passive. He had no relevant votes prior to today (hammering Pez is pretty clearly not a relevant vote). He's on gravy now, which I think is a fine place to be. I do not have a strong lean on him.
---

dowolf posted...

Anyways, as I was saying...

Does anyone have thoughts on Red? At all?

I dunno, I don't feel his presence like I have in the past few games. Seems to be venting more frustrations than thoughts. Would like to see him post more.
---

Also, Phoenix is the only one who hasn't posted since Sceptile claimed, correct?
---

VeryInsane posted...

Also, Phoenix is the only one who hasn't posted since Sceptile claimed, correct?

Yes, it seems like he would be the only person left who could claim Prosty.
---

I mean, someone else could be it but just don't want to out themselves
---

VeryInsane posted...

I mean, someone else could be it but just don't want to out themselves

If no one claims prosty to defend me and I get lynched, please do not believe any future claims on the matter. It would be so incredibly scummy to let me go down like this.
---

It would be really weird for Scept to announce Prosty if there isn't one.

Only thing I can think of would be if there's a prosty on a scum jack? But that's getting a little needlessly complicated.

Anyways, the reason I said that was because it hit me, heading home from work, that I have literally zero opinion on Red. So yeah.
---

I wonder if SBell has any opinions on Red. He seems to be the only person to have voted him this game.
---

Obellisk 7/20/2017 10:25:59 AM#292
Ok I just read through all of RED which is literally just Page 4 of Topic 2. after his replace in he provided no content other than confusion and in Topic 2 he did nothing until Page 4 where he finally announced he'd caught up, and gave nearly no opinions on anything other than "This person has done nothing, That person has done nothing" Gives a blow by blow of Oddity / Sceptile but not an opinion, mentions the Scare/Chris feud but not an opinion and then throws shade at me for thinking both Scare and Chris are town.


Now lets pretend that I am not SBELL and I am just looking at Red's body of work. It oozes, "I need to post to look like i'm trying and that i've read the game but i need to be careful cause I replaced into someone with a lot of suspicion on them already and I dont want to go down with that ship." I am not throwing counter attacks at Red. Red legit looks BAD when you go through everything he hasn't done this game so far. And now he's not going to be around all day?

I for one have at least put myself out there and formed opinions on some folks. Red played it safe.

##Unvote
##Vote: Red

Topic 2, I post the above.
---

Right, I was just wondering if those thoughts were updated. Not sure if you've mentioned him recently.
---

Less focused on him but interesting what I said regarding him in the past. He could easily be scum.
---

when does day end


and Scept the only link you gave me is one we cant even see
---

ScareChan posted...

when does day end


and Scept the only link you gave me is one we cant even see

And whose fault is that?

Answer: not mine
---

##unvote
##Vote: Scept
---

I'll bite. Is there any reason for you to do that? Or did you just ask me that question because you wanted to lie to me and pretend that you cared about my answer?
---

Too early for mass claim. Protection is dead and roleblocker is unkilled.

I was not expecting that to be the last post in the topic when i got off of work. Come on people.

Sceptilesolar posted...

dowolf posted...

Anyways, as I was saying...

Does anyone have thoughts on Red? At all?

He's been pretty passive. He had no relevant votes prior to today (hammering Pez is pretty clearly not a relevant vote). He's on gravy now, which I think is a fine place to be. I do not have a strong lean on him.

I was pretty much complacent with the Oddity lynch, then a lack of internet deprived me a chance to vote. Mostly the lynch was pretty much in hand, especially yesterday, so a vote would have just pushed close to hammer which i really didn't want to do.

Scare dropping off feels predictable, makes me more comfortable with a gravy lynch.

jesus this activity
still not fully comfortable with a sceptile lynch still, gravy seems to have parked his vote on me without engaging me and scare's involvement has gone from bad to worse
also I am surprised Phoenix didnt post at all after everything he promised
---

using still in the same sentence twice.. I am a monster
---

Scare voting sceptile makes me question this.

Hmmmmmmm

##unvote:sceptile

Perhaps I'm not being pragmatic enough here. With 3 scum left 2 of them had to have acted last night (kill and roleblock)

Killing a person who didn't act is probably a bad idea

##vote:scare

What the hell are you doing all game. Why did you claim I was scum yesterday
---

dont think we have evidence of a scumblocker yet
then again, scum without roleblocker lol

at this rate I feel like if anyone else alive was slept with but is not telling us, they should come forward
---

Plum showing up now believing the prosty tale.
---

You still here plum or did you head out?
---

Votals as of post #296 (SBell)

[3] Sceptile - Dowolf, SBell, (VeryInsane), (Plum), Scare
[2] Death - Phoenix, Gravy
[2] Scare - Death, Plum
[1] Gravy - (SBell), (Scare), Red
[1] VeryInsane - Sceptile
[0] Phoenix - (Plum)
[0] Dowolf - (Sceptile)

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Day ends at 9:00:00 PM EDT tonight (About 13 hours and 50 minutes)
---

Leftv for work.

What do you mean I don't believe the prosty tale?
---

Oh misread that.

I've always bought prosty. I don't believe not getting up means town
---

Do you think town benefits with more information at this point or do you think we ride this out?
---