Board 8 > Board 8 Song of the Fortnight Club - #12

(+) Yeah! (+)

Executive decision to get the next 2 weeks rolling - surely we can at least keep a schedule of every other week, right??? If you're a Monday, Tuesday or Wednesday person, just post your song as soon as you're able.

Fortnight 11 Playlist:
https://open.spotify.com/user/the_stricken_one/playlist/64u62I3lktYvnBD0lgb1L4#_=_

Last fortnight's winner: Let it Snow (mycro) and BLEACH (brohan) are tied with 2 votes each, but there's still time to vote there if you can!
https://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/76114337

We're missing 4 or 5 votes.

Schedule:
Monday: Bane_Of_Despair (1), Snake5555555555
Tuesday: MycroProcessor (possibly 1 pending), jcgamer107
Wednesday: VeryInsane (1), mcflubbin
Thursday: digi (2), Seginustemple (2)
Friday: Terastodon, Shaduln (2)
Saturday: Steiner (2), MysticBrohan (possibly 1 pending)
Sunday(ish)- rest of week: Poll/Discuss!
---

oh ok
---

wow

jacked
---

see this is what happens when you guys can't fuckin listen to 12 songs in 2 weeks I get the topic manhandled away from me
---

I will protest

I want the tri weekly song club
---

How about Yearly song club would that make it work
---

Bane_Of_Despair posted...

How about Yearly song club would that make it work

No we need to add a week each time
---

I thought anyone could start the new topic...? Trying to keep things on track.
---

Bane_Of_Despair posted...

How about Yearly song club would that make it work

I would still probably wait until December 31st to listen to all the songs, tbqh.
---

mcflubbin posted...

Bane_Of_Despair posted...

How about Yearly song club would that make it work

I would still probably wait until December 31st to listen to all the songs, tbqh.

more like january 2nd
---

Gonna go with a trusty personal favorite this week. Now that holidays are over too I won't be late like last topic.

Eve 6 - Enemy

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cAsgPoevBWw
---

whoops forgot I still needed to post a song since it's all out of wack. Here's one I've been sitting on because I was unsure but here goes. Absolutely love the vocals on this, and for all of the band's stuff. Just a super super great band, and especially with this album they really show a lot of cool influences. They kind of ended but started back up with 2 of the members and aren't quite how they used to be, but they still have 2 fantastic albums.

Envy on the Coast - Numb

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A5SauK8DuvI
---

Kirin J Callinan - S.A.D.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QgBSAs5gwGk

Luniz - I Got Five On It

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSC9cgvtkRs
---

Lucy Dacus - Night Shift

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WDZdT04ls4
---

I've decided my rule is "no artist repeats within a calendar year"

The White Stripes - Apple Blossom

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6CMwGk22qHM
---

Also I was thinking - if we submitted votes as 1st, 2nd, 3rd (3 points for 1st, 2 points for 2nd, 1 for 3rd) we'd be less likely to end in a tie, even if not everyone voted.
---

trying to get me to listen to more than one song? nice try
---

Ty Segall - Feel

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VETPFH1mTls

He's got an album coming up again in a few weeks. Had trouble thinking of which one to bring up but I'll go with this one

Do we even really have to put them on our day anymore now that it's two weeks?
---

I like jcgamers idea about voting first, second, third. Mainly because my rec got a grip of second place votes last week

haven't listened to anything yet but I'll be very surprised if anything tops I Got Five On It, that one brings me back

Lena - Traffic Lights

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a4IZxku8N7w
---

jcgamer107 posted...

Also I was thinking - if we submitted votes as 1st, 2nd, 3rd (3 points for 1st, 2 points for 2nd, 1 for 3rd) we'd be less likely to end in a tie, even if not everyone voted.

i like this
---

Main reason I didn't suggest doing that was because a chunk of the voters just put one song and don't rank. But if we can get that to happen then yea sure
---

wow i only just realized i never put in my vote for showbiz last week
---

Bane_Of_Despair posted...

Envy on the Coast - Numb

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A5SauK8DuvI

This is a very pleasing track to listen to. The instrumental mix is wonderful and I can hear every individual piece clearly and crispy. Makes the drums and bass stand-out a lot too. Really enjoyed the lyrics and vocals.

Seginustemple posted...

Kirin J Callinan - S.A.D.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QgBSAs5gwGk

Liked the sort of experimental nature of it and the satirical lyrics.

digiiiiiiiii posted...

Luniz - I Got Five On It

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSC9cgvtkRs

It wasn't bad, the flow was catchy, but the beat got repetitive and I didn't really like the content of the lyrics.

MycroProcessor posted...

E.G.G. a.k.a. COSIO - EU over Progress

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sqEkPVpItp4

Seems like some good background music, didn't excite but it was a fine track.

mcflubbin posted...

Lucy Dacus - Night Shift

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WDZdT04ls4

Really powerful, I feel the emotion in the lyrics and vocals and I really enjoy the more fierce emotional tone shift it takes later on in the song.

jcgamer107 posted...

I've decided my rule is "no artist repeats within a calendar year"

The White Stripes - Apple Blossom

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6CMwGk22qHM

The vocals are a lot of fun, hard not to enjoy this delivery. Just a nice simple tune.

LiquidOshawott posted...

Ty Segall - Feel

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VETPFH1mTls

That was badass, I really dig the guitar work a lot.
---

Terastodon posted...

Lena - Traffic Lights

Instantly recognizable, I like the production of the track a lot and the beat gets you moving. The texture of her voice is pleasant too.
---

I Monster - Daydream In Blue (BBC Radio 2 Session)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rG8y4f3gA68

easily the superior version of this track
---

Opeth - Windowpane

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qEaf9LqIUZQ

a lot of people probably know this one but i've been listening to it a bunch this week so here you go
---

just need Shaduln
---

Week 12 Spotify playlist (except for Mycro, VI, and Shad's song. First two because they aren't on Spotify, Shad's because he hasn't posted quite yet):

https://open.spotify.com/user/the_stricken_one/playlist/0lYoizmhuYO20WbXGsuhgL
---

Sorry I've been dumb this week.

Warning (specifically for Digi): Dubstep is in this song.

Protostar & MakO - No Fire (feat. Rachel Hirons)
https://open.spotify.com/track/6ZaiiaMZoUDR2nPtWKWxt5

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4G10QL3VBrw

I really enjoy the chorus, which starts the first time at 2 minutes.
---

Shad's is now on Spotify playlist
---

i listened to numb and apple blossom on spotify because the YT videos didn't work for me.

Eve 6 - Enemy

thought this was a rather boring alt rock song. it wasn't terrible but it was pretty bad.

Envy on the Coast - Numb

i was expecting another shitty post-hardcore song because that's a genre this band plays according to wikipedia (as well as "active rock" - wtf is that?) but surprisingly it wasn't. it sounded more like something a bar band would play. ok, towards the end there were some earrapey screams but i'll forgive those. this isn't something i would ever put on - it's too boring for that - but it wasn't bad. harmless rock song i guess.

E.G.G. a.k.a. COSIO - EU over Progress

first of all, this must be the worst name for a band/artist (?) ever. it's even worse than when a friend of mine in high school called his band "e eleven seven." at several points this tune uses the same chord progression as attract from ridge racer revolution, which is one of my favorite VGM songs, so that was a huge positive. i'm sure there's a million other songs that use this progression and i probably shouldn't try to say something technical about music with next to no expertise, but hey, that's what it reminded me of! but yeah, overall this was an incredible jazz fusion-ish track. adored it from start to finish.

The White Stripes - Apple Blossom

oh hey, it's the siblings-but-not-really again with a song from the album with a dutch title. as i said before i like the white stripes but i'm not a fan of this - i'd rather hear them play music in the style (see what i did there?) they usually do. rock bands doing music hall just isn't a great idea - the beatles should have never recorded maxwell's silver hammer either.

Ty Segall - Feel

damn, this was great! pretty simple rock song but for some reason i really connected to it. if i had longer hair i'd headbang to this for sure. loved the first guitar solo too, it actually reminded me of some of frank zappa's shorter guitar solos from the early '70s, and coming from me that's high praise. well, zappa usually had amazing musicians to accompany his solos and these guys aren't on that level, but to a certain extent you can still make the comparison, i think. anyway, fantastic pick.

Lucy Dacus - Night Shift

i thought this was going to be a boring folk song but it wasn't. i liked the shift to rock and i quite liked the rock part, as simple as it was. but as a whole the song was kind of overlong - i think the rock portion would have been more powerful if it had been shorter. decent, though.
---

Luniz feat. Michael Marshall - I Got 5 on It

great pick, one of my favorite one hit wonder songs (well, according to wikipedia luniz had another top 20 hit song in the UK i've never heard of, but you know). i may agree with snake that the lyrics aren't good and maybe the rapping isn't amazing, but when the beat is this sick i'm not going to complain.

Kirin J. Callinan - S.A.D.

i wasn't into this. kinda reminds me of that DMX christmas song from last time in that it's SUPPOSED to be really funny but... i just wasn't laughing? someone in the youtube comments mentions gnther - good comparison, but i found ding dong song to be a lot more amusing than this. interesting that kirin j. callinan used to be in a band called mercy arms that apparently played dream pop, though. i love dream pop so perhaps i WILL like them!

Lena - Traffic Lights

this was ok i guess. don't have much to comment, i didn't love it but it was a decent little pop song.

Protostar & MakO - No Fire (feat. Rachel Hirons)

i like dubstep but it should be consumed in small doses - when i listen too long to it i get bored. i wouldn't call this pure dubstep, though, it's more like... dubstep-electropop. or maybe this does qualify as normal dubstep and i just don't know it because i know nothing about this genre. but yeah, good song.

Opeth - Windowpane

damnation is one of my favorite albums (like, ever - not just by opeth) but this isn't one of my favorite tracks on it - i feel like it's a bit too long. still a great song, though. i especially love those crosby, stills & nash-ish harmonies towards the end.

I Monster - Daydream in Blue (BBC Radio 2 Session)

eh. love me some trip hop but i don't enjoy this super cliche chord progression. the trip hop-ness of it made it above average for me, though.

------

Vote: EU over Progress

2nd) Feel
3rd) I Got 5 on It

Windowpane
No Fire
Night Shift
Traffic Lights
Daydream in Blue
Numb
Apple Blossom
S.A.D.
Enemy
---

MysticBrohan posted...

I Monster - Daydream In Blue (BBC Radio 2 Session)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rG8y4f3gA68

easily the superior version of this track

Very chill song, enjoyed the vocals very much which carried the song for me.

Steiner posted...

Opeth - Windowpane

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qEaf9LqIUZQ

a lot of people probably know this one but i've been listening to it a bunch this week so here you go

Beautifully put together, each individual section and part is filled with a vibrancy that simply pleases the ears. The vocal harmonies are a nice touch.

Shaduln posted...

Sorry I've been dumb this week.

Warning (specifically for Digi): Dubstep is in this song.

Protostar & MakO - No Fire (feat. Rachel Hirons)
https://open.spotify.com/track/6ZaiiaMZoUDR2nPtWKWxt5

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4G10QL3VBrw

I really enjoy the chorus, which starts the first time at 2 minutes.

I'm not that big into dubstep at all, and the elements definitely overwhelm this song. The vocals are cool though.
---

Vote: Opeth - Windowpane
2. Numb
3. Feel

Night Shift
Traffic Lights
S.A.D.
Apple Blossom
Daydream in Blue
No Fire
EU over Progress
I Got Five on It
---

Snake you should def check out both Envy albums, they're one of those bands I can consistently listen to
---

Definitely plan on it, enjoyed Numb quite a bit!
---

plan on listening either today or tomorrow
---

Envy on the Coast - Numb
This is one of those songs I really enjoy though I can't say why. When I first started to listen I thought it was going to be kinda boring, but I just found it to be really easy to listen to. I might check out some more of them.

Eve 6 - Enemy
Wait, Eve 6 had more than one song? After listening to this, I kind of understand why they didn't get bigger than they did. Not that this is bad, it's just fairly generic. I was listening to the intro, pretty excited to see what they did with the chorus, but it just kinda kept going. I don't dislike the song, but it's just kind of...there?

Kirin J Callinan - S. A. D.
"Just another song about drugs". Yeah ok. This is interesting to listen to, but I wouldn't say I enjoy it. I'm glad you posted it, but at the same time I never need to listen to it again. I'm not sure how else I can explain it.

Luniz - I Got 5 On It (feat. Michael Marshall)
I liked this a lot more than I though I would at first, especially the chorus. I still don't really like songs that just use the same minimal beat/notes in the background the whole time (especially for songs that don't have a vocal melody), so that detracts from this one in particular. But I don't hate this being on while I'm working or something.

Lucy Dacus - Night Shift
I enjoy the vocalist, but this song is way too long. The shift (see what I did there) to a heavier feeling at the end was cool, but I was already disinterested in the song by that point. The first four minutes just ruin the rest of it.

The White Stripes - Apple Blossom
The White Stripes always do it for me. I was hooked from the first line, the minor feeling makes me happy. This is the kind of song I could just crank up the volume for and play it a few times over and over.

Lena - Traffic Lights
This is another song I was interested in right away. I had a really good time listening to this one, but I'm not sure there is anything I can point out why. Sounds like something I would hear on the radio (which I know some people might think is an insult, but I don't mean it as one).

I Monster - Daydream in Blue
Now this is how you do a minimal background music song. This guy is fun to listen to. I was curious what they were going to do after the midway point, and I liked the duet.

Opeth - Windowpane
Opeth is always very hit or miss for me, mostly due to their vocals. But surprisingly, I didn't have any issues with the vocals in this one. Instead, I just didn't like the song. I felt like this is one of those examples of a song just going on too long without anything interesting happening.

E.G.G. a.k.a. COSIO - EU over Progress
OK you actually have me interested right away. And then some of the music reminds me of Phoenix Wright a bit...then Mario Kart? And then we get some weird off beat stuff. I feel like this song had a lot of potential and then just went off the rails. I didn't hate it, but it could've been so much better.

Ty Segall - Feel
Has a nice rhythm to it. The vocals aren't my favorite, but the song overall was just fun to listen to. I wish I had more to say about it, but it was just fun.

Apple Blossom > Daydream in Blue > Numb > I Got 5 On It > Traffic Lights > Feel > EU over Progress > Enemy > Windowpane > S. A. D. > Night Shift
---

There are a few songs on Eve 6's Horrorscope that are a bit more weird and experimental (and even more so in their follow-up It's All In Your Head) but I've always enjoyed the message of Enemy a lot. Eve 6 just has that knack for catchy, energetic short-songs with great wordplay and they've always been one of my favorite bands.
---

Up
---

and up
---

ima listen tonight
---

Should technically be final day for this period
---

i did listen last night, my vote is Numb

that's just to get my vote in, i will finish up the writeups when i get off work
---

will be voting tomorrow sorry i'm bad
---

Enemy- I like the verses more than the chorus, chorus is kind of by the numbers and probably the weakest part of the song. It's fine though.

S.A.D. - I like the hook, that's about it for the most part. Song doesn't work for me too much unfortunately, seems a bit too all over and it doesn't all work here.

I Got 5 On It - I gotta say, that's a really high quality beat for 1995. Like doesn't seem super typical for the era, which is really cool. Flow's great, hook's great, message of the song is great BETTER PAY UP FOR MY WEED

EU Over Progress - Listening to this while talking in discord about FFX just made me think about playing Final Fantasy games with this music going. Also made me think about specifically Seymour Battle music too, so props on this song.

Night Shift - really really great lyrics and subject manner, the ending getting a bit louder and building up is a nice effect.

Apple Blossom - this song has always reminded me of the beatles, the melody and the way jack kind of sounds a bit like paul mccartney. It's one of those instances where the simplest melody is the most effective.

Feel - solid ass garage rock, espeically the solo in the middle.

Traffic Lights - she sounds a lot like Ellie Goulding, particularly during the verses. It's solid, nothing super memorable but it works.

Daydream in Blue - a song that has such a strong hook, you can repeat it over and over for practically the entire song and it still works. Add a few flourishes and effects and then bam, you have a cool ass song.

Windowpane - good background music, doesn't really get me going but it's just solid mellow prog rock

No Fire - solid dubstep, a genre I'm actually quite in favor of when done well despite people's misgivings about it. Solid vocals for it, solid drops, nothing too obnoxious. I fucks with it.
---

Real talk the top 4 songs could all be #1, I really like them.

1. I Got 5 On It
2. Feel
3. Night Shift
Apple Blossom
Daydream in Blue
Windowpane
No Fire
Enemy
EU Over Progress
Traffic Lights
S.A.D.
---