Board 8 > Mafia Discussion REDUX Part 1: The Boys (and Girls) Are Back In Town

(+) Yeah! (+)

greengravy294 posted...

Yeah but if literally Chris' game attracts drama then whose hosting is "good enough" to actually respect the game? It's very disheartening for me to idly watch. That's all I'll say on the matter.

Anyway to speak of hosting, Persona 5 mafia, at least from me, is canceled. Set up wise at least. If anyone wants the flavor and my set up let me know (pm/discord). This community obviously can't field a 21 man game, which is sad, but I don't truncate my setups.

also welcome back steven (not puns, you got the wb 3 years ago)

I'll just take it over since you already sent me the setup to cohost
---

Corrik posted...

Gotta get him brownie points for bringing his own alt in to defend himself and arguing against his alt with his main.

Of only he was that attentive in game
---

i believe in you articuno2001
---

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Corrik posted...

Gotta get him brownie points for bringing his own alt in to defend himself and arguing against his alt with his main.

Honestly, a board 8 memory I will remember forever.

I did laugh out loud when Corrik Phoenix Wright OBJECTION'D him right in his face and he was just like "uh uh I don't know what you're talking about I'm sure it is just a coincidence".
---

I feel like I'm missing the story here
---

greengravy294 posted...

I feel like I'm missing the story here

Read the game, gravy. God.
---

well alright, i guess so
---

Corrik posted...

greengravy294 posted...

I feel like I'm missing the story here

Read the game, gravy. God.

I'm starting to feel like this is your catchphrase.
---

Holy shit day 1 is hilarious

A+ would read again
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

Those who mentioned interest in hosting:
Suprak
Ben
ChoasTony
Ashethan
MZero
Shad
Death
IGCD

Am I missing anyone?

I have been waiting to host English Literature mafia for like 8 years, again.

Corrik posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

TotallyNotMI posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

MI, you should've told me you were at gencon

Ahh! Do you go every year? We tend to go every other but we're discussing going again next year too since some friends of ours are.

My brother goes. I live in cinci so it's not a bad drive to go to just hang out, tho

Is Columbus zoo really the biggest in the United States animal wise?

This is kinda a weird question to ask me when I said I live in Cincy, and not Columbus, but...

I haven't been to all the zoos in the nation. Columbus zoo is pretty big, and it's huge when you include its branches that aren't a part of the zoo (like the Wilds), but personally the place feels less like a zoo and more like an amusement park. Great gorilla and polar bear exhibits tho.
---

Did you want to go after Chris' game, Han? If you've been waiting that long (I honestly never remember you hosting) you can go next if you're ready.
---

May need a replacement in my game.

The only name I remember on this replace list is @dowolf
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

May need a replacement in my game.

The only name I remember on this replace list is @dowolf

Still available if nobody else is...
---

Wolf or sheep? Hehe

Maybe I'll let him have my account, then he can be a wolf in Sheep's clothing.
---

PM me
---

been busy all day, go me >_>
---

Corrik posted...

Corrik | topic 6 page 1 | #037

dowolf posted...

Corrik, you voted for PJ yesterday after your scan alledgedly confirmed him town. Hell, you were the first person to vote him! Also, if Azure were playing as FFD himself, why would the associated food be something that's "yuck"? Also: are wings FFD's favorite food? (semi-serious question here)

At any rate, this isn't even a debate.

I trust Fett 100%, and see no need for him to claim.

From: Corrik
11. I think Dowolf should stump

scum wants me to do something.

good to know.

From: Fett
Dowolf, if you're town and you stump.......... That has potential to cost us the game, here and now.

I AM AWARE.

Wait what? Are you not reading right? My scan fit ZELL DINCHT (granted it took awhile to see how Hot Dogs fit with Zell, but it did). I did not confirm him Town at all. In fact, the food didn't confirm his Flavor either. It just fit his flavor.

Dowolf, obviously you missed something so let me go back to it.

I do not know what Yuck! means. I got it for both PJ's scan and for what I thought was Plum's but ultimately was Azure's Scan.

Like I said, I have theories for what it means... and I now can safely throw one of those theories out.

Theory 1. Yuck! means they are foods FF doesn't like. - This is Debunked now knowing that Azure ended up being my target actually.

Why is it debunked? Because I got back wings for FF himself and FF can't obviously find Wings yucky if it is what I brought back for stealing from... FF himself.

Theory 2. Yuck! means they are food El Fuerte doesn't like. This is possible, I guess? But, I don't think there is anyway FF could know what El Fuerte likes unless he just is using a list he made in accordance of his thoughts with the game. Hot Dogs and Wings are pretty simple/common. Maybe El Fuerte would like more extravagant foods? I don't know.

Theory 3. Yuck! means Town. Now obviously this has the same knock against it that I initially had against it when after Night 1 I didn't know if I could consider it accurate to be meaning Yuck! meant scum.

What was the knock against it? Well, there was a legit Cop already. We lynched him. Thus, me having a inno/guilty variation to the scan seemed unlikely. It would be a redundant role. Obviously, yuck! to me sounds like it would be saying someone is Scum. And, I considered that after Night 1 but did not trust it due to what I said before about Arti turning up cop in relation to it.

So, I doubt this yuck! part refers to inno/guilty. But, it must be noted if it was referring to inno/guilty then obviously PJ was Town, so it would mean Azure is Town also. I don't think we should assume that is right.

Theory 4. My character is looking for non-yucky food and when he finds some something will happen with my character/role? Possible, but what exactly would happen? My flavor mentions nothing of this.

Theory 5. Yuck! is literally tacked on for no reason. It is there to mess with me and for me to spend hours wondering what the heck it means - all to FFDs amusement. This could be an example of another thing that ultimately means nothing in this game? Probably likely this is right.

Wtf did I just post in this game...

oh god

that fucking game.

where Chris, by sheer force of will, got town to lynch someone over confirmed scum.

also i didn't know i was untargetable.

so stupid.
---

Suprak the Stud posted...

Did you want to go after Chris' game, Han? If you've been waiting that long (I honestly never remember you hosting) you can go next if you're ready.

Not that soon. But when I do get this game finalized, I'd like to host it.

And I hosted the like, 46 player Super Smash Bros. Brawl Mafia that had a big night-action mess-up that caused me to end the game in like, day 3 >_>
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

And I hosted the like, 46 player Super Smash Bros. Brawl Mafia that had a big night-action mess-up that caused me to end the game in like, day 3 >_>

Mmmmm yes please this sounds like fun
---

[Redacted] about [Redacted] I'll have more to say at [Redacted]
---

Zachary Quinto just said he likes Mafia on Jimmy Fallon LUL
---

oh god

that fucking game.

where Chris, by sheer force of will, got town to lynch someone over confirmed scum.

also i didn't know i was untargetable.

so stupid.

It is times like this where I remember I am pretty good at this mafia thing and not just my own hype machine...!
---

Yuck!
---

jcgamer107 posted...

Zachary Quinto just said he likes Mafia on Jimmy Fallon LUL

Someone send him a tweet lol
---

Dane cook does too
---

Scum just won the 132 person sports mash over on MU.

I tried so hard. And came so far. But in the end, like 40 townies potatoed.
---

Yeah I'm just not sure on how to approach mash
---

Hey, can I get one of your usernames as someone I should say referred me for MU please?
---

IfGodCouldDie
---

ScareChan posted...

Yeah I'm just not sure on how to approach mash

As town, I just try to have fun and catch a couple scum. Basically just wait until someone says or does something weird, then check their ISO. Bad shots are always good to inspect, but you'll get a lot of "don't care whatever" townies in there too. You're not going to catch every scum and you're likely not even going to interact with a third of the game, but you can still use whatever strategy you normally do to catch a scum or two.

As scum, sit back and wait for the inevitable victory, I suppose.
---

What would you guys say the average quality of MU is like?
---

Someone email me when signups for the next game start. Im never here anymore
---

Sheep007 posted...

What would you guys say the average quality of MU is like?

Probably around the same as here. Plenty of good players, plenty of people who don't have real interest in playing but sign up anyways. Some toxicity but over pretty good I think.
---

Sheep007 posted...

What would you guys say the average quality of MU is like?

I subbed into a championship game and even though the rest of the scum team and I were at a significant disadvantage(everyone that was on town had a history of playing together and every member of the scum team was having their first game on MU) I apparently blew away most of the game and a few on lookers with how good i was. And i suck compared to most of the players here. I would consider myself lower mid tier here.
---

Sheep007 posted...

What would you guys say the average quality of MU is like?

The good are really good the bad are pretty bad and there are a lot of solid players overall
---

Corrik posted...

Alakazam did not play bad in the game he fakeclaimed vanilla as doctor.

You are forgetting where he lied about his save actions because he was too embarrassed to admit he used them on scum. This created a scenario that un-town-cleared someone.l who was otherwise perfectly town cleared.
---

I will say my frostpunk scumteam was the best team I have ever been on. The plays and way they controlled the game were too tier
---

I can't remember the specifics now, but I remember thinking at the time that the common opinion was Zam un-confirmed someone but that it was a misrepresentation based on...something? Idk. I was scum that game so I didn't care as much but I would swear he got a worse rap than he deserved.

turbopuns2 posted...

I can't remember the specifics now, but I remember thinking at the time that the common opinion was Zam un-confirmed someone but that it was a misrepresentation based on...something? Idk. I was scum that game so I didn't care as much but I would swear he got a worse rap than he deserved.

Scare and Foolmo had an interaction that went largely unnoticed on day 2. When i dug it up during night 2 it read clear as day that scare made a very soft protection claim and that foolmo picked up on it, but then foolmo dropped the subject. There were other conversations directing the day at the time so those had the focus.

If foolmo had been scum there is no possible way that scum would not have tried to kill scare that night. Scare survived the night which cleared foolmo.

But then zam shows up and when he finally drops his actions he ends up claiming a save on scare that same night.

Throw in the fact that based on the number of night kills each night it was very possible that kill(s) had been prevented at some point.

Suddenly my iron clad belief in foolmo is no longer ironclad because scare was saved the night a foolmo scum team might have shot him.

..but zam never saved scare that night. He lied for no purpose whatsoever.
---

Suprak the Stud posted...

Scum just won the 132 person sports mash over on MU.

I tried so hard. And came so far. But in the end, like 40 townies potatoed.

he is not lying

i was a wolf and he kept tagging me being like "hey dels can you vote for <scum #1>" and i was like "hmmm your case is okay-ish but eh not really seeing it" "hey dels can you vote for <scum #2>" "nah they just seem like a bad townie"

yeah i got murdered for it. damnit.

At least I now know the limits of Dels' scum game.
---

LMAO yes

my scum game fucking sucked

everyone who knew me was like "dels just clearly isn't playing as well" and i died pretty much asap

at EoD there were w/v wagons and I was like "well uhhhhh i looked at both their ISOs, the V seems fine, i don't really see them as scummy... the w... meh not great either... but just looks like a bad townie to me. i guess i'll vote the v? idk"

i got crucified for it

to be fair i didn't really want to play but the host is a very aggressive recruiter

but this is what made it extra weird that you thought i could be scum because as scum i could not even do like 10% of what i did there

Man, my memory isn't perfect ok? Like I am not a literal robot assassin here.
---

Did you see red saying I played terribly because I didn't catch Corrik that game and then he got reamed by me and corrik the next game? So satisfying.
---

Yeah. I saw it.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Man, my memory isn't perfect ok? Like I am not a literal robot assassin here.

i've had some good scum games here =P (except VI scans me every damn time)

it's just, over there...

you have to fake all the ISOs and research and analysis and it's just... that's sort of the least fun part to fake. =/

Dels posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Man, my memory isn't perfect ok? Like I am not a literal robot assassin here.

i've had some good scum games here =P (except VI scans me every damn time)

it's just, over there...

you have to fake all the ISOs and research and analysis and it's just... that's sort of the least fun part to fake. =/

Ugh but being town over there is soooooo good. It takes like half the time to do all the work I usually do.

@DoomTheGyarados were you in that game? Were you Chris?
---

Dels posted...

Suprak the Stud posted...

Scum just won the 132 person sports mash over on MU.

I tried so hard. And came so far. But in the end, like 40 townies potatoed.

he is not lying

i was a wolf and he kept tagging me being like "hey dels can you vote for <scum #1>" and i was like "hmmm your case is okay-ish but eh not really seeing it" "hey dels can you vote for <scum #2>" "nah they just seem like a bad townie"

yeah i got murdered for it. damnit.

I was very sad you were scum because I wanted another Dels/Suprak townie mash adventure :(

Very rude.
---

no, chris is chris. that wasn't chris.

and yeah towning is great. never playing without modbot or ISOs again.

guess that's the tradeoff.