Board 8 > Sir Chris Music Mafia 6: Death on Two Legs

(+) Yeah! (+)

HanOfTheNekos posted...

It's possible, since he would be a spent poisoner in this situation and they would want to avoid a possible tracker hitting someone else, assuming that Panth wasn't long for the world.

It would also be explained by them deciding to just shoot Corrik... but that wouldn't happen if they knew he was poisoned.

What other role is possible in this situation? Framer?

On a role town will never scan? I think not. And we have already seen scums scanner.
Busdriver maybe, but Panth wouldnt claim to have just visisted Tony in that instance.
---

Actually.. I think the Occam's Razor argument is the right one here... Eaed is probably town and Corrik said he was bodyguard him... What if scum simply did not believe Corrik's claim and attempted to kill Eaed anyway?

That was my theory already anyway.
Roleblocker is probably the biggest threat to scum right now.
---

htaeD posted...

That was my theory already anyway.
Roleblocker is probably the biggest threat to scum right now.

I think it was the theory for a lot of us by now.

Crescent-Moon posted...

htaeD posted...

Also I checked, and yes Panth admitted to visiting Tony before Scare even defined his bluffed scan.

As far as I recall, Panthera claimed at the first hint of a scan on him, which is one of the biggest reasons I don't trust him. Why as town who saved Tony would he snap claim like that?

It took a bit.
He first joked, treating Scare's comment like a joke.
Then tried to tell Scare his read was wrong, when Scare voted him.
He only admitted to having visited Tony once Puns came in with his scan on Leo.
---

Interesting.. I thought he said it before Puns came in, not after. Why would Puns claiming to track Leo make Panthera claim who he targeted?

Panthera's actions are not helping my headache any.

For it being 9 am, you all sure are posting a lot. My tired ass is barely functioning and I have to install some gutters here in a bit.

That being said, Town points to everyone who has tbd, I imagine scumis pretty demoralized at this point.
---

MZero11 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Trying to figure out if this is an intentional mistake Oops I forgot how many scum are left , or Crescent honestly missed the open setup.

She said something about completely forgetting about Zam and she did actually mention the open setup

Anyway looked like a genuine mistake

What's this forgetting Zam you're referring to? After what happened, I don't believe that's possible.
---

It's 10:30am for me and I don't have much of a choice if I want to get anything productive in today.

But back to the point of Red, how many people in that list of 6 has he openly showed suspicion for at some time? Because IGCD also commented about Red never bringing him up before tossing him on a scumlist.

ColZach posted...

Eaed is town. Id elaborate on this but out of embarrassment Id really rather not. Yall are just gonna have to trust me on this, eaed 100% confirmed as his claimed role.

!!

Although it was pretty obvious he was telling the truth when he claimed the block on Corrik. Scum doesn't block a bg, let alone over watcher
---

Why spoiler that?
---

htaeD posted...

Players who literally said fuck all
Mzero
Tange
Pjbasis

In my defense the twilight spanned from 3am to 11am for me and I was sleeping almost the whole time!
---

For effect idk
---

Crescent-Moon posted...

I must be more tired than I thought to have made a mistake like that

It's like I totally forgot Zam ever existed and died already.

---

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

MZero11 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Trying to figure out if this is an intentional mistake Oops I forgot how many scum are left , or Crescent honestly missed the open setup.

She said something about completely forgetting about Zam and she did actually mention the open setup

Anyway looked like a genuine mistake

What's this forgetting Zam you're referring to? After what happened, I don't believe that's possible.

I was posting later than I should've been and forgot two scum were already dead. For some reason, when it was commented that 4 were left, I took it as Panthera being called the second dead scum instead of remembering Zam already died as scum and called out Scare for saying it that way.

Then I got chided by a few people and realized I was probably more tired than I thought.

MZero11 posted...

Crescent-Moon posted...

I must be more tired than I thought to have made a mistake like that

It's like I totally forgot Zam ever existed and died already.

Zam's post acting out like a child on the other board distracted me from thinking of Zam in this game, if I had to guess. I really couldn't give you any concrete reason as to how I screwed that up.

I'm guessing the reason I got townreads for it is people think I would not fake a mistake like that... which is probably true, actually.

Regardless, this doesn't require more discussion. I want more people Red just scumlisted analyzed. Two of his list have already said he hasn't said a thing about us all game.

htaeD posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

It's possible, since he would be a spent poisoner in this situation and they would want to avoid a possible tracker hitting someone else, assuming that Panth wasn't long for the world.

It would also be explained by them deciding to just shoot Corrik... but that wouldn't happen if they knew he was poisoned.

What other role is possible in this situation? Framer?

On a role town will never scan? I think not. And we have already seen scums scanner.
Busdriver maybe, but Panth wouldnt claim to have just visisted Tony in that instance.

Yeah. The question is just... IF Panth is Scum, then what role would he be? I don't want to say he can't be Scum, but right now I'm just drawing beads on stuff like the Jinjo's from Blade Mafia.
---

I'm not going to be around tonight or most of the weekend I'm going camping so I need to figure out what to do today
---

I don't think there's any point in attempting to meta his role right now, and now that we at least know he isn't roleblocker, we're *probably* better off letting him live the day. He'll either confirm himself town, try to latch himself to a scumbuddy for confirmation, or he'll just die tomorrow.

If Panthera actually is town that can confirm himself, that's a gold mine.

i should be okay though might need to do a bit of catch up Sunday Saturday being night should work in my favor luckily
---

I don't think unblockable roleblocker is that strange with a town JK

turbopuns2 posted...

I don't think unblockable roleblocker is that strange with a town JK

This... Reminds me of something... I think my very first game. The only way Dowolf could really be scum is if he were untargetable roleblocker, and... Dowolf was untargetable roleblocker,

Don't untargetables auto-roleblock anyone who tries to target them, though?

Unblockable

Not untargetable

But Panthera couldn't be untargetable because why would he react to any kind of scan in the first place... So I guess it'd specifically have to be unblockable anyway.

Sheep007 has replaced PJbasis
---

Well that was sudden... Hello Wooly person

##Unvote: IGCD

Since I haven't done that yet, I don't think.

Hey Sheep. Claim please.
---

To be clear: telling your fellow players 'fuck you' gets you replaced regardless of anything else. I expect no questions of this. Respect your fellow players.
---

Sheep quick claim lols
---

But meowing at them is perfectly legal~

Meow.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Sheep007 has replaced PJbasis

...Scum pj deciding this game isnt worth it?
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

To be clear: telling your fellow players 'fuck you' gets you replaced regardless of anything else. I expect no questions of this. Respect your fellow players.

...Oh.
---

Sorry, I saw an opportunity that seemed to scream out "meow"... So, I did.

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

To be clear: telling your fellow players 'fuck you' gets you replaced regardless of anything else. I expect no questions of this. Respect your fellow players.

...Oh.

Mhm. Moving on I guess.

By the way Puns, what do you think of Red's list?

Unfortunately ed just instantly blew his load and revealed blocking panth before panth even showed up, so we lost any possible chance of tripping him up

Crescent-Moon posted...

By the way Puns, what do you think of Red's list?

Can you quote it for me

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

To be clear: telling your fellow players 'fuck you' gets you replaced regardless of anything else. I expect no questions of this. Respect your fellow players.

...Oh.

My thoughts exactly.
---

turbopuns2 posted...

Crescent-Moon posted...

By the way Puns, what do you think of Red's list?

Can you quote it for me

red13n posted...

Anyway, that is all meta assuming zam is just on all levels the easiest person to read ever.

3. IfGodCouldDie
6. Panthera
7. Mzero11
14. DoubleTangicide
17. Crescent-Moon
18. Edumey

16. HanOfTheNekos
21. htaeD (Death)
1. TheSultanOfSlam
20. Benjamin3740
8. pjbasis

4. ColZach
10. ChaosTonyV4
11. turbopuns2
13. Forceful_Dragon
19. ScareChan
22. Town MVP eaedwards6400

That is how that breaks this down.

---

red13n posted...

Anyway, that is all meta assuming zam is just on all levels the easiest person to read ever.

3. IfGodCouldDie
6. Panthera
7. Mzero11
14. DoubleTangicide
17. Crescent-Moon
18. Edumey

16. HanOfTheNekos
21. htaeD (Death)
1. TheSultanOfSlam
20. Benjamin3740
8. pjbasis

4. ColZach
10. ChaosTonyV4
11. turbopuns2
13. Forceful_Dragon
19. ScareChan
22. Town MVP eaedwards6400

That is how that breaks this down.

This list.

The "6 scum" are essentially the 6 softest targets in the game at the time, and both IGCD and I have mentioned that Red hasn't said a single thing about us the entire game.

He doesn't even attempt to give any sort of reasons for justifying any of it, either. Something about this list is very much a "do not like".

Red DID say he based the list on reading Zam's posts. Even still, it is a little odd that the top Scum are just, as Crescent says, a list of soft targets.
---

@Sheep007 eod is 11pm est today. I'm not sure if you have been following along at all but this topic has some pretty good recaps and I think the last topic does as well. Have fun.
---

Last game Reds reads were awful and lazy too. But he definitely posted more.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Red DID say he based the list on reading Zam's posts. Even still, it is a little odd that the top Scum are just, as Crescent says, a list of soft targets.

See that isn't much of a reason to make a list, much less somehow end up with every soft target on the game on a scumlist you don't bother to explain.

Also I feel like ColZach has been pretty absent this day. Really let me down when I had finished my great finale regarding MZero.
---

Well if red is scum the bottom 6 are all probably guaranteed town

Curious as to the reason for sultan, ben, pj being the only ones out of order

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Last game Reds reads were awful and lazy too. But he definitely posted more.

Red was a factor in TT. Red has been a total nonfactor in this game. Then he comes out with the laziest list possibly in the laziest manner possible? Was he that lazy in TT?

turbopuns2 posted...

Well if red is scum the bottom 6 are all probably guaranteed town

Curious as to the reason for sultan, ben, pj being the only ones out of order

You think if hes scum hes calling all the town town?
---

In tt red was alot more active he also was one of the town people I thought was a threat him and scare where probably the 2 best people on town
---

Ok I'm just going to do it.

##Vote: Red

I haven't liked him for a while now. I also noted him as someone I particularly disliked in my longer post last night. Then, he comes and makes this effortless list post that tells us nothing and adds nothing else to the game. Red has been playing this game as lazily as possible almost from the start, which is in stark contrast to his play last game. Perhaps I've simply been giving him too much benefit of the doubt this game for no reason I see justifiable anymore.