Board 8 > Persona 5 Mafia Topic 1 - Enter the Metaverse

(+) Yeah! (+)

This play from red and Scare feels a lot different than last games where they only became super active once accused. I think both seem pretty Town.
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

htaeD posted...

also I didnt even think Red was breadcrumbing hard with his 'go to sleep gag'
And I played the game too...

He mentioned some form of "aren't you tired? It's getting late. you should go to bed/sleep" approximately 15 times.

Its a meme from the game.
---

htaeD posted...

Reg posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Scare just badly fake claims then dies. That's all he ever does :P

...still?

I remember this happening more than a few times when I was actively playing!

Actually Scare badly fake claims, then gets away with it for one day by destroying any future faith people may have in him. And we let him do it too... Ugh

We used to let you get lynched at final 3/4 every game, but we eventually got over that. Maybe you guys will learn about Scare too...!

Hbthebattle posted...

This play from red and Scare feels a lot different than last games where they only became super active once accused. I think both seem pretty Town.

Definitely agree with this. Moreso on Scare than Red, but not hugely so.

Good, so we all agree. Scare and Red = town
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

You think 4 people are voting for you for "reasons"

It would be 3, and I would hope so. If not they outed themselves very early as either scum or terrible players.
---

Corrik posted...

Would anyone like to claim yet? Preferably Sheep.

I'll still same time with you.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

htaeD posted...

also I didnt even think Red was breadcrumbing hard with his 'go to sleep gag'
And I played the game too...

He mentioned some form of "aren't you tired? It's getting late. you should go to bed/sleep" approximately 15 times.

Its a meme from the game.

Indeed
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C_m6cq-U0AAkr9y.jpg

Eaed, are flavor acknowledged?
---

Corrik posted...

Would anyone like to claim yet? Preferably Sheep.

Why preferably me, Corrik? That's a hard no for now but ask again if we're both alive tomorrow.
---

HB providing solid reads so early probably means he's Town. What was he in the last game?
---

##unvote
##vote: Sheep
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

Scare is a player who when he puts his effort into it is an upper-half player in terms of skill.

I dunno if this is what Death was looking for but I don't really think so. What I'd like to know is how you think Scare acts normally, and why it's different to this.
---

Sheep007 posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Scare is a player who when he puts his effort into it is an upper-half player in terms of skill.

I dunno if this is what Death was looking for but I don't really think so. What I'd like to know is how you think Scare acts normally, and why it's different to this.

Thanks for pointing that out.
Now I feel bad for not catching that myself
---

Sheep007 posted...

HB providing solid reads so early probably means he's Town. What was he in the last game?

Scum.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

Sheep007 posted...

HB providing solid reads so early probably means he's Town. What was he in the last game?

Scum.

Cheers

And yeah, Death, Ed's got a pretty bad thing going this game. Voting pretty strong Townread Scare feels kinda silly and I'm trying to remember my scum game with him for what he was like D1 when he was similarly under pressure very early.
---

Reg posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

This play from red and Scare feels a lot different than last games where they only became super active once accused. I think both seem pretty Town.

Definitely agree with this. Moreso on Scare than Red, but not hugely so.

Did you follow the last mafia game?
---

I wouldnt call it exactly stellar activity, but I agree that its a clear difference so far.
---

Of course this could also be the lack of Chrisfear talking. Heh.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Reg posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

This play from red and Scare feels a lot different than last games where they only became super active once accused. I think both seem pretty Town.

Definitely agree with this. Moreso on Scare than Red, but not hugely so.

Did you follow the last mafia game?

Hell no.

Sheep007 posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Scare is a player who when he puts his effort into it is an upper-half player in terms of skill.

I dunno if this is what Death was looking for but I don't really think so. What I'd like to know is how you think Scare acts normally, and why it's different to this.

I guess could be remembering wrong but I thought Scare was a player who wasn't only active but provided substance. As opposed to last game where I feel like when he was active he was providing nonsense. Reading Han and Reg's reactions I would think that I could be potentially thinking of someone else? I always had him in a higher regard in terms of the player base.
---

In all seriousness I dont like Corrik. It feels like he is tryin
g to be town Corrik.
---

I'm judging Scare without considering any name value or reputation he has. I just like the game he's bringing to the table and think it's pro-town.

If I take those factors into consideration with guys I know I'm super liable to get burned because I'm pretty sure I haven't followed *any* mafia game since I last played, not just the immediately previous game. Habits can change over that long of a span.

I don't particularly like Corrik since he's voted myself and the person I'm most sure on as Town but that's more of a Corrik thing than anything else.

Also, Ed, Scare is generally active and provides substance but is rarely entirely business. At least in my experience. I'd like you to be a bit clearer though: what about this game so far makes him worthy of a vote from you? Are you saying that Scare this game has only provided nonsense?
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Ok, so we already know Reg and Eaed are Scum, but I would also like to put forward a motion on Terra being Scum as well.

I'm ok with this
---

What did Terra do again? Don't remember a post from him.
---

Oh just a few things with barely any content very early. All pretty null to me.
---

I dont recall if this (claim with me on day1, random target) is a game Corrik has played before
---

It was God asking for the same time and Corrik just asking for a claim, wasn't it?
---

And yes I'm fairly sure he's done what you asked about regardless.
---

Reg posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Scare just badly fake claims then dies. That's all he ever does :P

...still?

I remember this happening more than a few times when I was actively playing!

Han is mad because I just went 1 for 1 with him as scum after fake claiming tracker on him. And previous to that he was yelling for two days that I was scum before I nighykilled him in game of thrones 5
---

masterplum posted...

In all seriousness I dont like Corrik. It feels like he is tryin
g to be town Corrik.

Do you mind elaborating a bit more?
---

masterplum posted...

In all seriousness I dont like Corrik. It feels like he is tryin
g to be town Corrik.

Like this post
---

So I'm mindmelding a lot with han which is usually a good sign

Spiritually my vote is on eaed, but dont think it needs to be physically there right now, he has a handful on him

And whoever is calling my posts fluff are not reading my posts at all. There is shitposting but I have posted and created a ton of content. Like maybe 75% of gamestae is due to me right now
---

Sheep007 posted...

masterplum posted...

In all seriousness I dont like Corrik. It feels like he is tryin
g to be town Corrik.

Do you mind elaborating a bit more?

Players who are better than average are cognizant of what they sound like when they are town and try to mimic it.

Corrik is known for absurdist claim asking as town. I dont like the feel of Corrik posts here. It feels closer to a Corrik trying to imitate himself than a natural Corrik.
---

ScareChan posted...

And whoever is calling my posts fluff are not reading my posts at all. There is shitposting but I have posted and created a ton of content. Like maybe 75% of gamestae is due to me right now

I knew I was right to give you credit for that earlier...!

Corrik, from what little I saw of him last game before he replaced out, did this exact same thing as scum, so Im not sure if acts like Town Corrik is fully reliable.
---

I forgot that Corrik was actually replaced one of the scums.

Though honestly it feels like Corrik has been less engaged as a whole.
---

Corrik consciously attempts to act the same as both alignments. I think what Plum was trying to say is that it feels like Corrik is consciously trying to look like Town Corrik (what he did last game is very similar to how he would behave as town in general, most likely).
---

Also eaed literally watched me as scum last game from host position. He should know this looks nothing like scum scare

Also if someone wanted to actually case me there is content there. You quote my first dozen posts, say what the hell is this shit, I'm possibly outing power roles to counter claim rught away, talking about non players and replaces, brought up Mason buddy again where I used it as scum last game and open claimed scum buddies with red

Like that's actually a respectable case and I would give you town credit for hunting

Calling my posts fluff and thank u, nexting is just showing you feel I am low hanging fruit where the playerbase is sour on me after last game and am easily punishable.

If your real goal was aggression fluff is not enough, give me that case I just gave on myself and I but it, but nah
---

I can half get how someone like Eaed might have seen your early content as fluff.
But more in the sense of it looking like you were joking around with your 'IGCD is townconfirmed etc' stuff. It was kinda hard to tell what posts were serious at first.

With stuff like the mason nonsense I am just going to assume you're never quitting that.
---

ScareChan posted...

Also eaed literally watched me as scum last game from host position. He should know this looks nothing like scum scare

Also if someone wanted to actually case me there is content there. You quote my first dozen posts, say what the hell is this shit, I'm possibly outing power roles to counter claim rught away, talking about non players and replaces, brought up Mason buddy again where I used it as scum last game and open claimed scum buddies with red

Like that's actually a respectable case and I would give you town credit for hunting

Calling my posts fluff and thank u, nexting is just showing you feel I am low hanging fruit where the playerbase is sour on me after last game and am easily punishable.

If your real goal was aggression fluff is not enough, give me that case I just gave on myself and I but it, but nah

This is not good logic.

It assumes

A. You are identical every game
B. eaed is good at mafia
---

Also, Reg, why unvote me?
---

Ok, Reg has ignored all my suspicion on him, but was willing to reply to an unrelated question.

Reg has surpassed eaed on my suspicion confidence. Well no, eaed is Scum. So I guess they've just confirmed what we already know.
---

Reg posted...

ScareChan posted...

And whoever is calling my posts fluff are not reading my posts at all. There is shitposting but I have posted and created a ton of content. Like maybe 75% of gamestae is due to me right now

I knew I was right to give you credit for that earlier...!

Pretty much any key thread can be linked to me right now lol. Red vs igcd happened because i pasted chris wall. Ed is on the hook for shading me. The only thing not fully my doing is corrik and I had a hand in that too by having him vote me
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Also, Reg, why unvote me?

Because the original idea behind the vote was that, as far as I could tell, you were explicitly choosing to keep your head out of the game and not give us anything to work with. So I decided to hop on the train that Red was trying to build in hopes that a bit of pressure would change that.

It did. So why leave the vote?

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Ok, Reg has ignored all my suspicion on him, but was willing to reply to an unrelated question.

Reg has surpassed eaed on my suspicion confidence. Well no, eaed is Scum. So I guess they've just confirmed what we already know.

I'd be lying if I said I especially cared about the suspicion on me. Especially since it all seems to boil down to "reg wanted to play mafia on day 1 guys!!!"

masterplum posted...

ScareChan posted...

Also eaed literally watched me as scum last game from host position. He should know this looks nothing like scum scare

Also if someone wanted to actually case me there is content there. You quote my first dozen posts, say what the hell is this shit, I'm possibly outing power roles to counter claim rught away, talking about non players and replaces, brought up Mason buddy again where I used it as scum last game and open claimed scum buddies with red

Like that's actually a respectable case and I would give you town credit for hunting

Calling my posts fluff and thank u, nexting is just showing you feel I am low hanging fruit where the playerbase is sour on me after last game and am easily punishable.

If your real goal was aggression fluff is not enough, give me that case I just gave on myself and I but it, but nah

This is not good logic.

It assumes

A. You are identical every game
B. eaed is good at mafia

It should establish my point that eaed case is poor
---

Reg posted...

Because the original idea behind the vote was that, as far as I could tell, you were explicitly choosing to keep your head out of the game and not give us anything to work with. So I decided to hop on the train that Red was trying to build in hopes that a bit of pressure would change that.

It did. So why leave the vote?

That was hardly what changed it, but fair enough.
---

Reg is Scum because:

1. He has ignored suspicion and arguments on him, which is one of the biggest scumtells in the game.
2. He's clearly annoyed of the suspicion. Not a "it's dumb because I'm not Scum" but a "this reasoning is stupid and I shouldn't have been caught on it".

And it makes sense. Vets who come back after awhile tend to do bad at Scum. I know that happened to me in Hamiton mafia.

But yeah, since he's playing for the first time in awhile I'm satisfied killing eaed first.
---

Also, Scare - I'm not mad at you for those games. I'm mad at people like Death and FD who mega-derped in those situations.
---

htaeD posted...

red13n posted...

Neablis posted...

Hi kids,

So excite about this flavor

your flavor in particular or?

Why would you ask this though, red?

I was honestly curious how quickly he'd be able to answer that.
---

But yeah, since he's playing for the first time in awhile I'm satisfied killing eaed first.

Thats it?
You dont even want Reg to claim today?
---