Board 8 > Persona 5 Mafia Topic 1 - Enter the Metaverse

(+) Yeah! (+)

Hbthebattle posted...

I voted you to apply pressure, eaed. Im keeping my vote there for now because I dont really buy the claim, and youre the person I suspect most at the moment. You keep being dodgy with your questions, and instead of defending yourself you instead try to cast the finger on others.

I am absolutely defending myself.

Scare, I attempted to apply pressure because you were failing to provide content and I didnt belive you would act that way as town. your defense was "this is not how I would act as scum" of which my counter was "why should i anticipate you to play the same as scum every time?" The logic is linear to me.
---

only people on the playerlist I don't recognize at all are Garetha and HB

are they both noobies?
---

Johnbobb posted...

Reg posted...

Johnbobb posted...

howdy ho neigborinos

oh hey speaking of guys that have done jack shit this game...!

I mean, I said specifically last night that I had work first thing in the morning

and I just got home

Well, sure. I just find it funny somebody else that fits that description not long after I voted somebody else for it.

Now, if the evening's over and you're still in this category, I'll revisit this in force obv.

Reg posted...

Now, if the evening's over and you're still in this category, I'll revisit this in force obv.

hey did you know Corrik is scum? Bam, first one caught, job done for the day
---

Guys my wife is going out tonight so I gotta watch my kids. So i'm going to be gone for a couple of hours.
---

Johnbobb posted...

Reg posted...

Now, if the evening's over and you're still in this category, I'll revisit this in force obv.

hey did you know Corrik is scum? Bam, first one caught, job done for the day

You're like the fourth person to say this I think

and I look at it and I'm just like "uhhh maybe I guess?"

ok scrolling back through past pages

I like Han. As town I trust his reads more than most people here and he feels pretty town so far

so that puts suspicion on eadededeadad and Reg, both of which feel a little cruddy. Reg seems weirdly defensive early on but I'm pretty sure I've never played with Reg before so I don't know what to make of that.

eadeadeadde started off real bad. Saying you're gonna "try and be aggressive this time" feels like scum specifically trying to cover up differences in their town play. That and both going along with Red's game and also arguing Red's game seem wrong

Neab voting eaeadedead immediately after Han does feels bad as well. Like he was waiting until it was safe to vote
---

Reg posted...

Johnbobb posted...

Reg posted...

Now, if the evening's over and you're still in this category, I'll revisit this in force obv.

hey did you know Corrik is scum? Bam, first one caught, job done for the day

You're like the fourth person to say this I think

and I look at it and I'm just like "uhhh maybe I guess?"

rule of thumb in B8 mafia is when in doubt, blame corrik

has almost NEVER steered me wrong
---

I somehow missed the entire vanilla claim going on.
Ahem.
Flavor sounds messed up, relationship wise.
Though that could mean anything, honestly.
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

I gotta be honest Sheep and I said this when we were scum together I really dont think you're as good as you think you are. And I am not going to stand here and pretend I'm good but I'm just stating how I feel.

Omg Scum literally always go "you're not as good as you think you are"

Death, Neab, can you explain why eaed's flavor is wrong so we can stick a fork in him and move on?
---

I kinda want Eaed to try and see if he notices his mistake himself first.

That said, I dont know if Arti is the kind of host who provides scum with safelist flavor.
---

htaeD posted...

I somehow missed the entire vanilla claim going on.
Ahem.
Flavor sounds messed up, relationship wise.
Though that could mean anything, honestly.

Are you suggesting you know the flavor split?

HanOfTheNekos posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

I gotta be honest Sheep and I said this when we were scum together I really dont think you're as good as you think you are. And I am not going to stand here and pretend I'm good but I'm just stating how I feel.

Omg Scum literally always go "you're not as good as you think you are"

Death, Neab, can you explain why eaed's flavor is wrong so we can stick a fork in him and move on?

With your level of arrogance I almost want to die so that I can flip and you be wrong.
---

Why do people think this is a flavor issue. Seems normal to me
---

htaeD posted...

I kinda want Eaed to try and see if he notices his mistake himself first.

That said, I dont know if Arti is the kind of host who provides scum with safelist flavor.

So is the mistake that he is Ren's parents friend, who took him in to complete his probation in Tokyo?
---

htaeD posted...

I kinda want Eaed to try and see if he notices his mistake himself first.

That said, I dont know if Arti is the kind of host who provides scum with safelist flavor.

Oh. He gave actual flavor

Oh no
---

Welp. That was easy
---

Johnbobb posted...

also day 1 is dumb but you should know this by now

I madeit not dumb

do work
---

oh god that flavor
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

htaeD posted...

I kinda want Eaed to try and see if he notices his mistake himself first.

That said, I dont know if Arti is the kind of host who provides scum with safelist flavor.

So is the mistake that he is Ren's parents friend, who took him in to complete his probation in Tokyo?

Also, looking at the PM again I said the cafe is where they hang out but the it said it is where they hideout later in the game. If we want a better, more accurate paraphrase.
---

ScareChan posted...

Johnbobb posted...

also day 1 is dumb but you should know this by now

I madeit not dumb

do work

already found corrik pal
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

htaeD posted...

I kinda want Eaed to try and see if he notices his mistake himself first.

That said, I dont know if Arti is the kind of host who provides scum with safelist flavor.

So is the mistake that he is Ren's parents friend, who took him in to complete his probation in Tokyo?

That was at least it.
Sojiro was not the one being probated.
---

masterplum posted...

htaeD posted...

I kinda want Eaed to try and see if he notices his mistake himself first.

That said, I dont know if Arti is the kind of host who provides scum with safelist flavor.

Oh. He gave actual flavor

Oh no

....
how can you make a judgment call about it seeming 'normal' without having seen the claim?
---

htaeD posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

htaeD posted...

I kinda want Eaed to try and see if he notices his mistake himself first.

That said, I dont know if Arti is the kind of host who provides scum with safelist flavor.

So is the mistake that he is Ren's parents friend, who took him in to complete his probation in Tokyo?

That was at least it.
Sojiro was not the one being probated.

I wish I was able to show you this PM because the way I read it you can see where i made my mistake.
---

htaeD posted...

I kinda want Eaed to try and see if he notices his mistake himself first.

That said, I dont know if Arti is the kind of host who provides scum with safelist flavor.

Says soin the the opening posts

assuming he doesnt copy and paste that part without realizing it
---

Did anyone actually read the rules or am I going insane
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

I am Sojiro Sakura TOWN Vanilla. The flavor says something about Ren's parents taking me in to do my probation. Also mentions that I am the Manager of LeBlanc Cafe which is where the Phantom Thieves hang out. I

For those that don't know Persona 5, here's the inconsistency. Ren, aka Joker, was the one on probation and taken in by Sojiro, not the other way around.
---

Also if Ed is scum then Plum is basically confirmed town because I think he just noticed what I think I did
---

Of course, that could simply be a mistake on eaed's part in reading his information, but...
---

On the topic of the flavor discussion, the rules seem pretty clear to me that Arti will write it

Arti posted...

1. I may or may not write flavor for fakeclaiming with. Ask me if you want it. The sooner you ask, the more likely you are to get it before you urgently need it.

So unless you think scum Eaed literally didn't have flavor ready to claim with, I'm pretty sure he just doesn't know how to competently paraphrase (Though at least he's not incompetently paraphrasing in the modkill-worthy way <_<). Not sure this is an issue tbh.

Johnbobb posted...

ScareChan posted...

Johnbobb posted...

also day 1 is dumb but you should know this by now

I madeit not dumb

do work

already found corrik pal

Yes this was posted beforeI saw this page
I dont think you commented on me though
---

ScareChan posted...

Johnbobb posted...

ScareChan posted...

Johnbobb posted...

also day 1 is dumb but you should know this by now

I madeit not dumb

do work

already found corrik pal

Yes this was posted beforeI saw this page
I dont think you commented on me though

that's accurate
---

Personal thought

everyone who mucked up a claim last game was scum

and Ed watched that all happen

I would hope he would be more attentive there regardless
---

Eaed misreading flavor is about the most null tell thing I've probably ever seen.
---

Shaduln posted...

Eaed misreading flavor is about the most null tell thing I've probably ever seen.

Hey, look who finally decided to join the party!
---

Yep, busy 24 hours, whatcha gonna do
---

ScareChan posted...

Personal thought

everyone who mucked up a claim last game was scum

and Ed watched that all happen

I would hope he would be more attentive there regardless

Counterpoint: Sultan, I'd argue, screwed up a claim by not doing it early.
---

anyways

##unvote
##Vote: Battle

Hbthebattle posted...

Of course, that could simply be a mistake on eaed's part in reading his information, but...

Said that Eaed should claim. Didnt vote
Asked why he didnt vote,then voted
Now that he has the claim he is fence sitting

He got next to nothing pressure wise last game. time to crack the egg
---

Its not a scare level error, I will give you that.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

ScareChan posted...

Personal thought

everyone who mucked up a claim last game was scum

and Ed watched that all happen

I would hope he would be more attentive there regardless

Counterpoint: Sultan, I'd argue, screwed up a claim by not doing it early.

This just adds to my fence sitting statement
---

Fence sitting? How am I doing that? I lean on the side of eaed being scum.
---

htaeD posted...

Its not a scare level error, I will give you that.

to my credit, my actual role was not named after a move last game, I just had moves to use. I was WRESTLER which was not an attack so I bit on the hero of time thing
---

I am trying to consider all the options, Scare. Eaed's claim could be a fuckup in paraphrasing, or it could have been speedreading the wiki.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

I am trying to consider all the options, Scare. Eaed's claim could be a fuckup in paraphrasing, or it could have been speedreading the wiki.

You're making me do this bro

You're really making me do this.

##Unvote
##Vote: Hb

This doesn't fly. Not at all.

Hbthebattle posted...

Fence sitting? How am I doing that? I lean on the side of eaed being scum.

He gave his claim and you said this

Hbthebattle posted...

Of course, that could simply be a mistake on eaed's part in reading his information, but...

Which means you are uncertain

I then cited examples of saying a misclaim is more evidence to being scum due to recent history
you countered with so did town

how out ofthose two posts do I read that as leaning scum?
---

Hbthebattle posted...

I am trying to consider all the options, Scare. Eaed's claim could be a fuckup in paraphrasing, or it could have been speedreading the wiki.

"could be a screw up as town, could be a screw up as scum"

This is fence sitting
---

which for the record is not a bad thing to be on the fence. I see cases on both sides already

But you yourself are saying you lean scum
After I had to nudge you to actually vote when you saidyou wanted a claim
he is lean scum but you keep giving exits for town play

What is your reaction to his claim? Thats what you wanted from him. Give me allthoughts
---

Reg, why do you think eaed is Town?
---

Ok, so if you're not 100% on someone as scum, it's fence-sitting. Good to know.

Also, thank you, Reg, for confirming yourself scum right there.
---

Scare is convincing me.

Also, anyone using eaed's claim as a main reason for a lynch (I haven't really seen if anyone is doing that for the record) is probably scum.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

Ok, so if you're not 100% on someone as scum, it's fence-sitting. Good to know.

Also, thank you, Reg, for confirming yourself scum right there.

.You dont have to be 100% certain

But you arent backing up your read, you are going against your read
---