Board 8 > Persona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus

(+) Yeah! (+)

red13n posted...

I mean, why not give plum the benefit of the doubt here? The roleblocker kind of got destroyed.

a roleblocker he didnt vote
---

Have Shad ever claimed scan? He claimed phantom thief, so once death wakes up we can figure out if that is true
---

Hbthebattle posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Also if Plum is scum then Sheep is just town, so let's leave Sheep alone. I dont think they got into a bus triangle. And I dont think the lynch moves from one scum to two scum.

We need Plum's flip. The game busts open at that point I think

Also just for fun

Plum, Corrik, Chris. That would be interesting

Why have you been defending Sheep so much
It's pretty suspicious in my opinion

Because he was sitting in the lead yesterday until the last few hours of the day. Most people were just "bleh" on him. That's the first thing that set me off that we should avoid lynching him. And nothing he's done since day 1 has given me any scum vibes. I can also see his day 1 decision happening due to a simple misread, where as DYL's explanation for his day 1 decision was very fake. He seems to agree with me a lot. That's another reason I like him. (or maybe I agree with him, but he IS the Sheep).

Everyone just assumes he is scum, but literally has anyone disliked any of his day 2 posts? Contested anything he did day 2? Argued with him at all over his day 2 content? It all just feels meh to me right now
---

Plum is pretty much scum lol
---

ScareChan posted...

red13n posted...

I mean, why not give plum the benefit of the doubt here? The roleblocker kind of got destroyed.

a roleblocker he didnt vote

That's like the surest sign of a scum/scum lynch right there. Didnt this screw one of us over in our scum game? If not that one, it was a recent game
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Plum is pretty much scum lol

I'm not sure how this clears Sheep.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Also if Plum is scum then Sheep is just town, so let's leave Sheep alone. I dont think they got into a bus triangle. And I dont think the lynch moves from one scum to two scum.

We need Plum's flip. The game busts open at that point I think

Also just for fun

Plum, Corrik, Chris. That would be interesting

Why have you been defending Sheep so much
It's pretty suspicious in my opinion

Because he was sitting in the lead yesterday until the last few hours of the day. Most people were just "bleh" on him. That's the first thing that set me off that we should avoid lynching him. And nothing he's done since day 1 has given me any scum vibes. I can also see his day 1 decision happening due to a simple misread, where as DYL's explanation for his day 1 decision was very fake. He seems to agree with me a lot. That's another reason I like him. (or maybe I agree with him, but he IS the Sheep).

Everyone just assumes he is scum, but literally has anyone disliked any of his day 2 posts? Contested anything he did day 2? Argued with him at all over his day 2 content? It all just feels meh to me right now

I disliked how sheep went about the lynch, left his hard scum read in dyl.

Also plum was the counterwagon to scum end of day, you have to think that an afk dyl is more valuable to a scum team than a active plum?

sheep doesnt matter right now really

plum does

##Vote: Plum

give your shitty claim today so we can lynch you
---

Scare what if I told you I'm real certain plum is town?
---

Scare, it's always nice being town buddies with you

##Vote: Plum
---

I would need you to come clean to me because as much as I have evidence you should be town I am also very paranoid of you this game for reasons I have mentioned

its very convient the one time you role play there is a role that can pick you up
---

Like the whole he didnt vote scum d2 is sort of a bad argument to me.

He voted scum d1 and if not for a wild ed push to save reg he would of gotten lynched.

So not sure why he would of hesitated on d2

red13n posted...

Scare what if I told you I'm real certain plum is town?

Right now I'm fully operating under the assumption he is scum, so it would be something to me
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Scare, it's always nice being town buddies with you

##Vote: Plum

if you are scum I will cry for real

like real actual tears of pain
---

ScareChan posted...

I would need you to come clean to me because as much as I have evidence you should be town I am also very paranoid of you this game for reasons I have mentioned

its very convient the one time you role play there is a role that can pick you up

I can't do that just yet. Just humor me for part of the day and then I'll explain.
---

Neablis posted...

Like the whole he didnt vote scum d2 is sort of a bad argument to me.

He voted scum d1 and if not for a wild ed push to save reg he would of gotten lynched.

So not sure why he would of hesitated on d2

I find that he does hesitate on busses, certainly. He had time to set up on Reg. No time for DYL. I think it's different
---

I can do that, but what is it you want me to do? I assume you want me to move my vote to someone in paticular
---

because believe me, nothing would be more satisfying than burning a scum plum to the ground with me/you/ben.
---

By the way Scare I totally get you being wary of that DYL lynch in the last ten minutes. People did seemingly appear from nowhere to vote DYL. It was alarming enough that I switched over too, just to be safe.

In that light, i also totally understand why a town Sheep would do it.
---

Im not sweating sheep, he can prove himself there is better routes to take today imo ben

I am flexible for the most part
---

red13n posted...

because believe me, nothing would be more satisfying than burning a scum plum to the ground with me/you/ben.

man this made me feel all good inside

and actually gave your case to hold off more water to be honest

##Unvote

What do you have in mind
---

ScareChan posted...

I can do that, but what is it you want me to do? I assume you want me to move my vote to someone in paticular

I think chris has been fishy as fuck but I have no specific wants beyond that.
---

Here's a thought. Chris played a certain card really early this game by saying that anyone on Reg is probably town. He made it clear to smart scum that they need to bus day 2 or get caught by Chris. If they do bus maybe they even get town cleared. Corrik is a smart player, aware of Chris' influence. Even a crafty player. He would have needed to bus. Maybe even kept Chris alive just to get town cleared by him.

So even IF Plum is town....I'm not liking that Chris asked for praise.
---

*Corrik asked for praise
---

I am in a odd spot with chris as we are currently a hydra together in another game so my views on him may be biased right now and I obviously cant talk about the other game
---

to be honest terra is one of the players I usually do not read many of their posts in depth, I skim them and expect someone else to read them more properly than me and I can evaluate a case

their end of day with reg felt real, but I did say reg flip clears no one

so I would need more than just a feeling on chris to persue him for real
---

10. IfGodCouldDie
13. MZero11
14. Neablis

I'd also be fairly confident scum is in this group. Not sure how many. Could be all 3 for all I know.
---

Neablis claimed shot on Reg
---

I'm just going to assume Chris is legitimately busy. Like leaving his vote on Sheep and not being there at EoD is...either the scummiest thing CHRIS could possibly do or he's just busy. And I want to think scum Chris aint that obvious,
---

ScareChan posted...

Neablis claimed shot on Reg

oh I forgot about that. Good call. I knew I was missing something.
---

I'm going to assume red is saying scum directed a shot on reg and had me claim it.

Then pushed dyl some and left my vote on him when he was getting 0 pressure really

But i digress

Mzero needs to either be voted or he needs to come in here with an epiphany, because I dont have anything to say on him.
---

That actually makes me feel a lot better about this game.

Sorry I've had a lot of wheels spinning this game(Scum broke a lot of them murdering death).
---

Neablis posted...

I'm going to assume red is saying scum directed a shot on reg and had me claim it.

Then pushed dyl some and left my vote on him when he was getting 0 pressure really

But i digress

corrik would absolutely do it.

But we'd have to get to final 3 with you alive to even consider this. I'm willing to say he didnt do it with his probable bus at the end of the day.
---

Chris is legit busy can confirm
---

Scare be careful with the in-game out-game talk.
---

I said it because its public knowledge. If you looked at other game you would see it there as well

But I will stop
---

I have been working uber hard right before my break. I rock tomorrow too, but half day.

But yeah obviously legit busy. Come on lol.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Here's a thought. Chris played a certain card really early this game by saying that anyone on Reg is probably town. He made it clear to smart scum that they need to bus day 2 or get caught by Chris. If they do bus maybe they even get town cleared. Corrik is a smart player, aware of Chris' influence. Even a crafty player. He would have needed to bus. Maybe even kept Chris alive just to get town cleared by him.

So even IF Plum is town....I'm not liking that Chris asked for praise.

Ben you are a clever boy.
---

Well, I basically need to know Plum's alignment as soon as possible and am a little frozen until then. And of course I know who i DONT want to lynch

The only person I want to pursue regardless of Plum's alignment is now Corrik. For reasons mentioned above
---

Ben as I get my red bull and food remind me who is alive and voted ed day 1 sheep aside.
---

I will say this about Chris slot before he came in.

Terra was defending me against reg pretty firmly for very little. The conversation between reg and terra felt real and the frustration reg felt at that point seemed real.

The train that reg was trying to start also was ok in context, but somewhat futile so that's neutral I think.

Chris has been ok but seemed busy, something that makes me a little off was when I was showing him about my dyl thought process he thought was really good, he disagreed slightly then directed me towards others.

He had suspicions on dyl but do not believe he really ever got back to him.

I think the slot is more neutral leaning town to me because of the interaction between terra and reg.

eaed [8] - (Han), Neablis, (IGCD), (ben), (Scare), (Hb), (Sheep), DYL, (Reg), Death, Reg, Sheep, Shad, IGCD, Anonymous

@DoomTheGyarados

Oh, well Neab already answered it. But yeah

Neab, Sheep, Shad, and IGCD are all that remain.
---

Mmk. I find it likely there is still scum to hunt there but I won't bite my re read.

And yeah I show mercy on bad players like dyl and wanted more good analysis from you. Sorry I passed out obv I murder dyl over plum. It was my entire day 2 strategy.
---

Only sheep and shad haven't been on a scum train at final vote tally however.

Myself and igcd helped lynch dyl obviously

Neablis posted...

Only sheep and shad haven't been on a scum train at final vote tally however.

Myself and igcd helped lynch dyl obviously

Bad news: I think you are scum.

See ben I am an evil bastard.
---

I think Shad is likely town since he admits to being a phantom thief.

So really just IGCD and Sheep are the only possibilities.
---

Shaduln posted...

Johnbobb posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Honestly I am a little suspicious of those who were super against the DYL lynch yesterday

I stand by the fact that lynching someone for being inactive when the host has already said they're looking for a replace is shitty

it was a terrible, unsportsmanlike play that happened to work out in our favor

We don't know the replace was for dyl

John might...
---