Board 8 > Persona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus

(+) Yeah! (+)

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Neablis posted...

Only sheep and shad haven't been on a scum train at final vote tally however.

Myself and igcd helped lynch dyl obviously

Bad news: I think you are scum.

See ben I am an evil bastard.

You think Reg was the scum extra kill?

See I dont. I think I prevented that. I think I prevented scum from claiming vig. Why would scum Neab counterclaim me? It's suicide.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

ScareChan posted...

Deaths role makes me more weary of red tbh

Red never role plays like that

If scum had knowledge of being able to join his team and red had a role that could be recruited would explain it

I am not going to push red by any means right now, he looks good for end of day yesterday

But

He doesn't make final 3 either

Red was flavor hinting since the start of day 1, which is clearly what led to Death picking him as an night 1 recruit. He was recruited successfully, so Red is confirmed town

Did death confirm red town?
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

ScareChan posted...

Deaths role makes me more weary of red tbh

Red never role plays like that

If scum had knowledge of being able to join his team and red had a role that could be recruited would explain it

I am not going to push red by any means right now, he looks good for end of day yesterday

But

He doesn't make final 3 either

Red was flavor hinting since the start of day 1, which is clearly what led to Death picking him as an night 1 recruit. He was recruited successfully, so Red is confirmed town

Did death confirm red town?

Red was the one who asked for people to answer whether they were a Phantom thief or not. Now it's clear why, and clear that Red was recruited
---

benjamin3740 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Neablis posted...

Only sheep and shad haven't been on a scum train at final vote tally however.

Myself and igcd helped lynch dyl obviously

Bad news: I think you are scum.

See ben I am an evil bastard.

You think Reg was the scum extra kill?

See I dont. I think I prevented that. I think I prevented scum from claiming vig. Why would scum Neab counterclaim me? It's suicide.

I was just messing. Fly was the mafia vig lol
---

I mean it doesnt confirm him town, but it confirms he is Morgana, a good guy. And with Akechi being godfather, the flavor seems really cut and dry
---

Oh I see what you mean. No I was just teasing <.<
---

benjamin3740 posted...

ALso they probably got off DYL's extra shot already night 1. Because who wouldnt do that?

THe most hilarious outcome would be if they shot Terra expecting the Chris replace, and then Han protected Terra

Why the fuck would they be expecting Terra to be the replace?
---

I mean I am not going to argue I wouldn't shoot my scum partner to ride into final 3. Especially with so many big names alive. I think it wo yo ll be fun to do XD.

But on a serious note I think jb is a good lynch today.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

ALso they probably got off DYL's extra shot already night 1. Because who wouldnt do that?

THe most hilarious outcome would be if they shot Terra expecting the Chris replace, and then Han protected Terra

Why the fuck would they be expecting Terra to be the replace?

He said he might replace out during the day.
---

Anyway plum has been bad but confirmed town red says to let it go. So we shall for now.

Ordering food
---

DYL [4] - Sheep, Neablis, Ben, (Scare), IGCD
Plum [4] - Shad, Corrik, Scare, Johnbobb
Sheep [4] - Hb, Doom, DYL, (Scare), Plum

I would like to point this out also.

I know by the final tally of the game we have it looking like sheep wasnt really an option.

This is roughly 10 minutes or so before eod when plum votes sheep and makes it a three way tie.

Sheep is hard pushing plum at this point as well for staying that he (plum) thinks shad had a scan on him. In context sheeps vote makes sense.

Plums vote feels knee jerky and coupled with dyl vote on sheep earlier I think I might reverse my stance and think that sheep might be the preferred lynch by scum.

John is someone who's been acting weird for a while, he's been around but hasn't really contributed and has not been on the lynch of either confirmed scum.
---

Who were the two Corrik was saying were confirmed scum on day 1? Was it SHeep and Plum?
---

That's assuming plum is scum that is.

Also even though sheep is pushing plum he has not voted h I'll m yet with 10 minutes to go.

Red puts dyl up 5/4/4 and then we start seeing sheep move and others start showing up and putting votes

Neablis posted...

DYL [4] - Sheep, Neablis, Ben, (Scare), IGCD
Plum [4] - Shad, Corrik, Scare, Johnbobb
Sheep [4] - Hb, Doom, DYL, (Scare), Plum

I would like to point this out also.

I know by the final tally of the game we have it looking like sheep wasnt really an option.

This is roughly 10 minutes or so before eod when plum votes sheep and makes it a three way tie.

Sheep is hard pushing plum at this point as well for staying that he (plum) thinks shad had a scan on him. In context sheeps vote makes sense.

Plums vote feels knee jerky and coupled with dyl vote on sheep earlier I think I might reverse my stance and think that sheep might be the preferred lynch by scum.

That's exactly what i felt at the time. Plum's vote on Sheep did not seem right
---

benjamin3740 posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

ALso they probably got off DYL's extra shot already night 1. Because who wouldnt do that?

THe most hilarious outcome would be if they shot Terra expecting the Chris replace, and then Han protected Terra

Why the fuck would they be expecting Terra to be the replace?

He said he might replace out during the day.

And we had a player that made a single post the entire day.
---

Sheep007 posted...

Ugh oh man I like the people on the plum lynch way more than the DYL one but the DYL slot going is probably more helpful overall

##Unvote ##Vote: Plum

Also I hate this vote move by sheep.

It's not a good post at all

Lynches that pop up or massively grow in the last 10 minutes always worry me. The fact plum got pushed that quickly is pretty worrying to me.
See: ed

I need to look more at Shad. Didn't he claim Phantom Thief? Shouldn't red have mentioned that Shad was cleared because he turned up in the Thiefboard?
---

Remind me, who else claimed thief other than Shad?
---

Honestly if not for corrik we have s tie with sheeps vote very soon to deadline.

That does not seem like town sheep to tie up the vote like that when scum had an anonymous vote the day before.

Especially with him hating dyl slot.

Plum also is so adamant about not claiming and saving himself what's the poi t as scam there? He could use a safelist or anything to basically get cor off his back.

But he basically just tells him to go f himself and leaves.

Doesn't seem like scum trying to save himself there, his tiring it still looks bad but his other actions dont seem super safe as scam either.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

I am a Phantom Thief, not.

Was a this a thief claim or not, it's deliberately confusing
---

Hbthebattle posted...

Lynches that pop up or massively grow in the last 10 minutes always worry me. The fact plum got pushed that quickly is pretty worrying to me.
See: ed

I need to look more at Shad. Didn't he claim Phantom Thief? Shouldn't red have mentioned that Shad was cleared because he turned up in the Thiefboard?

None

Shad is the only person who claimed thief. There would be no logical reason for Death his use his power on anyone else. The scum roleblocker was already dead.
---

10. IfGodCouldDie
11. Johnbobb
13. MZero11
19. Sheep007

So either this is the exact scum team or one of my town cleaers (from very strong to hand waving for the sake of hand waving) is wrong. Hoho
---

I think JB and Mzero shouldn't be scum together.

I think mzero was pushing in a few of his posts how sure he was that jb was scum and was annoyed nobody was listening to him.

It seemed to me a towny reaction.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

10. IfGodCouldDie
11. Johnbobb
13. MZero11
19. Sheep007

So either this is the exact scum team or one of my town clears (from very strong to hand waving for the sake of hand waving) is wrong. Hoho

Juicy and delicious

Why is Corrik town for you?
---

I'm not tryng to say you're wrong at all btw, just want to know what your town tell is
---

Hbthebattle posted...

Shad is the only person who claimed thief. There would be no logical reason for Death his use his power on anyone else. The scum roleblocker was already dead.

Also this is an excellent post.

Also worth noting, obviously they had to check death. Shad claiming thief there was safe as it got him off the chopping block for the day.

They kill death and shad can still fly sort of low for a bit with more pressing needs.

I think shad should claim fully. As he should be in the board with death and red.

Read tiebreaker. Then read him not accepting my town clear from it is
---

I hate that read (present tense) and read (past tense) are spelled the same, because it's the only english word that actually confuses me sometimes as to what is being said. Plz patch english language
---

Chris how would you feel about some form of

Shad/JB//Sheep and maybe a +1 after

Oh and another thing

Death's pm told us Phantom Thief roles have to be upgradable in some way. It's easy to see how Schizo gets upgraded. How do you upgrade thief?
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Who were the two Corrik was saying were confirmed scum on day 1? Was it SHeep and Plum?

Yes plum must claim. Minus a plum claim, we lynch sheep
---

oh well yeah if Shad lied about his role then obviously he can die in a fire. I assume death would have brought him on board so we'll see.

without having done much work given sheep and jb was in my list of 4 I obviously am ok with that.
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

ALso they probably got off DYL's extra shot already night 1. Because who wouldnt do that?

THe most hilarious outcome would be if they shot Terra expecting the Chris replace, and then Han protected Terra

Why the fuck would they be expecting Terra to be the replace?

stuff like this is why I think IGCD is town

he is reading, he is alert, he just isnt that active. it may be a bit atypical of his town game, but I honestl feel like he is trying to just change his style and

I dont know, I just lean town on him
---

I am catching up but why is game dead for 2 hours now
---

oh there is just nothing

poop
---

We're all waiting for Red to tell us his big secret
Wild guess: He's waiting for Death to wake up and tell him who he used his ability on.
---

Votals, as of #338
Plum [3] - Sheep, Shad, (Scare), ben
Sheep [2] - Corrik, Hb

With 14 players alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch. Day ends at 8:00 PM EST on Monday, December 24th, approximately forty-two hours from now.
---

ScareChan posted...

I am catching up but why is game dead for 2 hours now

We still have a whole bunch of people that havent popped in.
---

anything you want to talk about red

any more on chris and are you still holding off on the plum thing
---

Still just waiting.
---

What do you think about bob
---

bob has been just out of the loop enough that it feels like hes probably town.
---

how have you progressed on igcd
---

he hasnt gone anywhere. His contributions have been nil.
---

So where do you think the game stands here Scare?
---

I think there is merit in continuing to persue the ed lynch

I still think plum is scum but withholding for now

ben is town

I feel like there is one power player on scum here. At this point I think that would have to be corrik, but I have explained my concerns with you and chris fear is a thing still of course

I thin battle is town. I think his day 1 was iffy but I feel pushing DYL, having some fire in opposing me looks good on him. However if plum flips scum, especially a good power then this read can be flipped

I think igcd is townie still. I have mostly liked bob

Miz has been nowhere to be seen and is always scum

neab is pretty much confirmed

who am I missing? Shad? if plum is scum I think it locks shad town
---

missing ashe and sheep

Ashe is in the same boat as battle

sheep I could flip a coin on right now really, but I feel like I dont want to lynch him today

I know you said plum is town but I think he also opens up the game with his flip. It gives a ton of weight to all the dyl voters
---

Neablis posted...

Sheep why did you really hop off confirmed scum in this situation?

I thought Ashe and Death were potential scum and the fact that they both voted DYL very quickly along with Scare (who I trust) being on Plum and very vocal about a likely scum save happening convinced me.

Also Neab throwing shade at me for not being on the DYL lynch at EoD... I was pushing him the entire day and only switched onto my other scumread at the last second. I'm still rather convinced that Plum is scum, too. Do you really think yesterday was a scum/scum/scum lynch? Even the most incompetent scum team can avoid that.
---