Board 8 > Illuminati Mafia Topic 4 - The Lies You Believe to Live a Comfortable Life

(+) Yeah! (+)

Also for anyone wondering about the modkill, essentially the way I look at it is, the players know when the end of the day is and are responsible for not posting past that and the host is responsible for making timely post duty posts so if you post past the deadline but before I post stop I let it slide, if you post after I post stop no leeway. Crescent made a post acknowledging exactly when the day was going to end then posted 28 seconds after the deadline and after I posted stop so there was no leeway to be had in that scenario.

---

Also maintain gravy -probably- should have just been modkilled. Pretty hard to see someone as scum after a blowup and replace like that.

---

Also originally I had a setup where
The parity cop was actually a role cop
Neighbours were masons
There was a survivor that acted as a mass role block until killed, with kills being unaffected
The mafia had a doctor, cop and something else instead of what they got.

I really wanted to make a low power game but I think after revisions I ended up handicapping scum too much.

---

red13n posted...

Also maintain gravy -probably- should have just been modkilled. Pretty hard to see someone as scum after a blowup and replace like that.

That's fair and you're probably right, but I went with my gut and got the replace instead.

---

it was a good claim red, I bought it

game was fine, igcd. It was just low activiity

---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Also for anyone wondering about the modkill, essentially the way I look at it is, the players know when the end of the day is and are responsible for not posting past that and the host is responsible for making timely post duty posts so if you post past the deadline but before I post stop I let it slide, if you post after I post stop no leeway. Crescent made a post acknowledging exactly when the day was going to end then posted 28 seconds after the deadline and after I posted stop so there was no leeway to be had in that scenario.

Tange posted after the deadline as did Red the final day. I am all for strict enforcing but gotta be consistent.

Just because you posted in between. Her hitting the button and tange did is hardly a fair division.

---

red13n posted...

Also maintain gravy -probably- should have just been modkilled. Pretty hard to see someone as scum after a blowup and replace like that.

At the very least banned.

Gg. Scum probably underpowered, but doesn't stop the fact that it was a perfect game.

I'll take my MVP trophy for getting Sultan to gamble on me

lol

---

I felt this game was a bit replace-happy. I mean, Gravy's whole thing was pretty crazy.

This was the first time I was replaced without being contacted by the host FIRST? Really did seem odd to get replaced when I did. I mean, had I been contacted first, I'd have probably said, yeah, go ahead, but... Eh.

---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

At the very least banned.

Gg. Scum probably underpowered, but doesn't stop the fact that it was a perfect game.

I'll take my MVP trophy for getting Sultan to gamble on me

lol

Gravy killed the fun of the game day 1 and ofc red called me out as being scum for acknowledging it lol

---

Neither Gravy nor Crescent should have been allowed in the game to begin with. And I have said as much to both and I would hope they understand why I said it.

But I thought the setup was fun, I stand by the shot from Sultan being a good one in that it confirmed Han and it gave us Tange and confirmed Corrik so it was a 3 for 1 for results at least

---

The modkill on Crescent was exceptionally stupid. She posted 15 seconds after the stop. No one else ever gets killed for shit like that.
---

Corrik7 posted...

Tange posted after the deadline as did Red the final day. I am all for strict enforcing but gotta be consistent.

Just because you posted in between. Her hitting the button and tange did is hardly a fair division.

Yea maybe, thing is I was trying to be more lenient, I guess I should just be more strict on it in the future. If you post anything after deadline whether a stop has been posted or not will result in modkill.

---

Crescent shouldn't have been modkilled unless being modkilled for posting even 1 second after deadline was posted in the rules at the beginning of the game, since that varies host-to-host.


---

Hbthebattle posted...

The modkill on Crescent was exceptionally stupid. She posted 15 seconds after the stop. No one else ever gets killed for shit like that.

So I asked you this in a PM and you did not respond, how long after DEADLINE should people be allowed to keep posting before it is modkillable?

@Hbthebattle

---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

So I asked you this in a PM and you did not respond, how long after DEADLINE should people be allowed to keep posting before it is modkillable?

a minute or so of leniency is what most people do
---

I prefer strict even a second is a modkill. But you gotta have that in the rules at the start and have now exceptions.

---

Hbthebattle posted...

a minute or so of leniency is what most people do

And I disagree, I think any post after deadline should be modkilled, but I feel like I have to be lenient because modkills really suck.

---

It's okay to be strict, just make it clear at the beginning of the game.

---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

It's okay to be strict, just make it clear at the beginning of the game.

This. I was tremoring at the time. My ability to keep track of time to the second was completely shot. I was on my phone, and mangled my Tange vote three times because I was shaking and kept hitting the wrong buttons. If I had any knowledge it was that strict, I would not have made another post after that vote. That post came out 20-30 seconds after I wanted to make it because I kept screwing it up.

I went back to topic 1 to look up the rules to see if I was missing anything, which I wasn't, and that's why I got the impression I was being targeted.

---

Funny footnote. I almost posted and got modkilled at night because I saw Crescents post and thought the day wasn't over. Luckily I read some.

---

I honestly felt bad for Crescent, and didn't think she should have been modkilled.

I also had a problem with the tiebreaker rules....it really screwed me that 1) it wasn't day over when the tie was broken and then 2) that false stop.

I'm not saying I deserved to live, but I think the game may have played out a little differently had the day ended when Scare was voted

Other than that, I didn't have an issue with the setup, and did have fun playing while I was alive.

---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Dead town
https://discord.gg/2yx46Cj

Kinda rude to not invite me
---

also Though I did feel bad for Crescent, I can see why a modkill would happen because people probably wouldnt shut up about whether or not a scumher deliberately posted after the Stop to appear town. It happened before.

Also I assumed posting after a STOP should need no explanation.
---

htaeD posted...

Kinda rude to not invite me

It wasn't meant to be rude, it was because there was a very real possibility I might have had to use you as another replace.

---

"Replacement Cop"

A tale in five acts

turbopuns3 posted...

I was asked spontaneously to fill in for a low energy game. I don't feel like reading day 1 and I don't think it will matter a whole lot whether I do or don't.

turbopuns3 posted...

I'm Heroic Police Officer - Parity Cop

turbopuns3 posted...

What has there even been for me to do?

Scum was lynched day 1 and 2 without me. Every single player today wants to lynched red.

turbopuns3 posted...

##vote: red

I mean this was expected before anything else happened, it still makes the most sense after you consider my scan, the claim is scummy, etc.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Red was lynched he was...

The last remaining scum.

My job here is done.

*tips hat*

*rides slowly into the sunset for a minute then disappears*