Board 8 > Percussion Mafia Topic 6 - Sextuplet or Sixtuplet?

(+) Yeah! (+)

DYL, you also forgot I'm detective

---

oh wait, no you didn't , my bad

---

Other than Scare, who later changed his mind.. Who shaded Tange?

Corrik did for a bit but it was more based in him thinking he claimed a broken rold.

---

Wondering. If Panth is lying.
Panths claim could be a cover for Lea as well.
On the other hand, I cannot 100 % rule out that scum targeted Lea in some way to explain the detection going off. And of the people that were copscanned innocent, I liked Lea more than I liked Balla.
---

Votals
[2] Scare - Tange, Sultan
[1] Plum - Crescent
[1] Hb - Corrik, (MZero)
[0] Balla - (Lea), (DYL), (Scare)
[0] Tange - (Damion), (Scare)
[0] Lea - (Plum)

Day ends tomorrow at 9pm EDT. 8 votes to reach majority. Remember the Alamo.

---

Dark Young Link posted...

Panthera claims Town Drunk.

I feel like this should have been claimed way sooner. Puns almost got away day 1, you'd think claiming that day makes it much more likely. There was no guarantee that people would go off you at the end there.

Do people just not get that regardless of my alignment I cannot claim during times I am not at my computer for. I was making supper during tiebreaker. I don't remember what it was but I'm sure it was worth it.

This is another very fluffy DYL catch up post btw. Aside from being pro-Tange it's a lot of summary and "well this could be fake but maybe not but maybe" kind of language. I know it finishes with saying he'll look over it later but his day 2 catch up post was fluffy and never really went anywhere either so I'm not too keen on believing that unless I see it.

Actually yeah

Dark intentions lurk
Yet another fiendish lie
Lest scum's will reign free,

##Vote: DYL

---

Not seeing your usual town convincing logic this game, Panthera. Just don't see it, bud.

##vote: Panth

---

I don't know what usual town logic you actually think of with me to be honest. I'm never a big productive force for town. I'm usually more active than this but I rarely accomplish anything besides making big catch up posts no one reads and ending every day on a splinter lynch that usually doesn't even turn out to be scum anyway.

---

I will admit I dont have a big section of Panthera stories in my own memory.
.
Panth why did you switch to red (for a while) again day2?
---

Thought i mentioned i saw 5tar go to lea

---

Panthera posted...

I don't know what usual town logic you actually think of with me to be honest. I'm never a big productive force for town. I'm usually more active than this but I rarely accomplish anything besides making big catch up posts no one reads and ending every day on a splinter lynch that usually doesn't even turn out to be scum anyway.

Bs.

---

htaeD posted...

Panth why did you switch to red (for a while) again day2?

I didn't buy into the way he talked about his claim. He seemed like he was kind of changing how to say he had been viewing it to fit the situation, with the whole assuming his scan meant someone was town at first, then jumping to call himself a renamed vanilla but then making a big deal about how revealing his scan was bad only to do it anyway. IIRC I voted him when people (Corrik?) were trying to start a train on Lea which I didn't want. I preferred the Balla lynch to Red but I didn't expect it to get any traction, not until Chris tried to push it at least. My lynch priority list at the end of the day was like, Balla > Red > most of the game > Lea.

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Thought i mentioned i saw 5tar go to lea

Then why are you voting me?

Wasn't plum already claimed to do something else and you guys were waiting on lea to claim the missing movement?

Wtf

---

Am I missing something or am I going crazy

---

Corrik the only games I remember playing with you where I was town are the Phoenix Wright game I threw away at final four, the Chris game where I had a meltdown that made all of day 2 about how dumb I was, and the Blade game where you destroyed me. You've literally never seen me as town not being a colossal fuck up <_<

Anyway not really relevant to this game so I'll leave it at that

---

Plum claimed to have visited Lea. I'm pretty sure he did before Sultan claimed the track originally, though I don't remember that much for sure. I know Plum claimed to target Lea and Sultan already claimed the track on him before now

---

I read up after I posted that I saw lea about how they were missing the lea movement. But plum was already posting wasn't he?

---

That at least fits with what I see, Panth.
But I sure as hell barely noticed that Balla push yesterday. I even didnt like Balla myself.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Thought i mentioned i saw 5tar go to lea

Hm?
---

Fastbreak posted...

I read up after I posted that I saw lea about how they were missing the lea movement. But plum was already posting wasn't he?

Plum claimed to have targeted her in P137 of topic 5. Sultan claimed to have tracked Plum to Lea P256. Plum was posting when Lea was around but he didn't claim until after she had claimed her immortal thing. He voted her before he claimed his action and did say when claiming that she was scum if no one targeted her (which doesn't quite add up since scum could have targeted her, but I think that got addressed the next page).

---

Fastbreak posted...

Then why are you voting me?

Wasn't plum already claimed to do something else and you guys were waiting on lea to claim the missing movement?

Wtf

He did? When i alsked him he said he went to lea?

---

Not enough people are voting scare and it makes me sad

---

@ScareChan @Fastbreak

I want answers beaucse thats a lie

---

Did lea claim her actions.

---

I'm dumb

Plum is the motion detector that went to lea so they were still waiting on someone else that adds up

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Did lea claim her actions.

Lea claims not to have any actions

---

Hmm interesting cuz uwimm says she moved right scare scanned her town... so either she is lying or Uwnim right?

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Hmm interesting cuz uwimm says she moved right scare scanned her town... so either she is lying or Uwnim right?

Motion detector activates if the person moves OR if someone targets that person.

---

Crescent-Moon posted...

Motion detector activates if the person moves OR if someone targets that person.

Ohhh okay i must have had thst misunderstood thought it was only if that target moved

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Hmm interesting cuz uwimm says she moved right scare scanned her town... so either she is lying or Uwnim right?

No. Uwnim claimed to target DYL and saw no motion. Plum claimed to target Lea and saw motion.

---

Everything checks out, I'm just forgetting what is what

---

Fastbreak posted...

Everything checks out, I'm just forgetting what is what

you being town does not check out

---

Very hard to keep track of all the motion detection and stuff

---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Very hard to keep track of all the motion detection and stuff

How can a tracker not keep track? Sultan is lying scum kill him etc (this is a joke)

This is why I take notes. Even though I'm barely taking notes on this game, I'm still writing down all the claims and claimed actions just so I can at least remind myself of what the fuck is up

---

Panth what kind of reads you got

---

Would also like to point out HB has been MIA all day

---

Based on play alone, I think DYL and Balla are likeliest to be scum. Based on all the claims, Scare is up there. The way he built up to his claim seemed genuine but it's hard to see why would be untargetable if he's legit town cop, and both Tange and HB failed actions on him without apparent explanation. Tange I already buy, HB I'm a lot less sure on from play but he's the only claimed protection and even if he's scum, he doesn't have a lot of incentive to claim arbitrarily on Scare when Tange is already pushing the issue. And MZero/Lea shouldn't be able to co-exist as town, but I'm not voting for Lea because flavour.. So...DYL/Scare are my top scumspects, since Balla is scanned town via Tange and it's not worth godfather hunting yet. Tange is the most likely person to be town, followed by Uwnim probably due to his brief Ben interaction and generally never giving me any scum vibes.

---

Lea can just keep posting after death, right? That's not really the same as my role.

---

She's basically a confirmable town voice who I think can't vote (I think that was the thrust of her whole talk about it affecting parity at least) after death. You presumably still can vote but aren't confirmed anything except not dead, correct?

---

Right, I'm pretty much 1-shot bulletproof that also blocks lynches and presumably bombs

---

They're not the same, but they both serve a pretty similar purpose of letting town continue to have a voice after what should have been death. Both pretty much hard counter the hyper bomb (Lea loses her vote but she gets confirmed out of it), both partially negate a kill or mislynch (you negate them entirely, she loses her vote which affects mislynch numbers but doesn't get removed from the game). There's enough overlap in the role they play for it to be questionable.

---

I could see Lea and myself existing together in a FUN game

I think the game, as a whole, has gone to far down the role meta rabbit hole and almost no one is actually scum hunting

---

To leas credit her role sonds hard to make up..

---

That much is likely true, role meta is hard to get right in a game whose setup is only clear in the sense that it's weird. Which is why my vote is on DYL, because he's done almost nothing but post fluff walls occasionally.

---

Scare and uwimm i believe have the most questions about them why would 2 actions meant for other people go to uwimm and why would 2 actions not work on scare.. its verry odd but again "FUN GAME" this could be a game of all misdirection

---

Whats the case on Balla?

Once again I don't want to lynch panth because scum tried to get him lynched end of day 1 instead of trying to get a tie breaker

---

masterplum posted...

Whats the case on Balla?

If you've done any catch up reading/skimming, has he done anything that stands out to you at all? He hasn't been as inactive as the guys who replaced and he might actually have more posts than DYL, but he's probably the least impactful player in the game. His day 1 consisted basically of saying he had reasons to think Chris was town that he said he wouldn't share, voting for me because Chris said so and because he thought we needed a majority to avoid no lynch, but he never changed perspective when told we didn't (I do seem to recall he wasn't around after Chris switched off me to Puns so that much is not contradictory). He said he had made a lot of decisions about the game based on reading Chris as town but never said what they were even when asked. His day 2 onward has just...not really existed besides an out of nowhere vote on Red shortly before deadline.

He's been the definition of the peanut gallery, around enough to be seen commenting but never really advancing an agenda of his own. That said he's scanned innocent by Tange via the Chris gift and I buy Tange and it's not godfather hunting season.

---

Didn't someone scan Balla inno?

---

DoubleTangicide posted...

Would also like to point out HB has been MIA all day

I apologize for this, I've been really busy today.

My thoughts is that, as it stands, this game has way too many duplicate roles, and its suspicious. Panthera and Death are super similar, Lea and MZero are super similar, Unwim and Plum have literally identical roles with a tracker, who is also similar, on top of that... there's no way they're all telling the truth.
---

MZero11 posted...

Didn't someone scan Balla inno?

Panthera posted...

That said he's scanned innocent by Tange via the Chris gift and I buy Tange and it's not godfather hunting season.

---

Whoops!

---