2 spoilers)

Topic List	Page List: 1
Maze_ 05/01/21 6:28:14 PM #1:	They got married years after Dutch and John cut all contact. John has no real dealings with the gang (outside of Uncle) Sure they met one time in the mountains but it wasn't like "Hi Dutch, BTW me and Abby got married! :D" before pointing guns at each other. Yet in Blackwater Dutch knew they got married. He had no intercourse with Bill or Javier either so how did he know? When he was like "This guy here married a whore! We all had her but he married her!" it would have been awkward as hell if John was like "WTF, no I didn't. We had a really nasty break up, now I'm dating a French girl called Camille." --- When the going gets tough, the tough go have a little cry in the corner. "Your mustache is crooked" ~ R.I.P Randy Savage. <cite>Maze_ posted [p:953450100] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>They got married years after Dutch and John cut all contact. John has no real dealings with the gang (outside of Uncle) Sure they met one time in the mountains but it wasn't like "Hi Dutch, BTW me and Abby got married! :D" before pointing guns at each other. Yet in Blackwater Dutch knew they got married. He had no intercourse with Bill or Javier either so how did he know? When he was like "This guy here married a whore! We all had her but he married her!" it would have been awkward as hell if John was like "WTF, no I didn't. We had a really nasty break up, now I'm dating a French girl called Camille." </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
CouldBeAnAlt 05/01/21 6:29:25 PM #2:	Maze_ posted... He had no intercourse with Bill or Javier either That's the part I wanna see --- Fithos lusec wecos vinosec she/her <cite>CouldBeAnAlt posted [p:953450133] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>Maze_ posted... </cite> <quote>He had no intercourse with Bill or Javier either</quote>That's the part I wanna see </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ShyOx 05/01/21 6:29:59 PM #3:	I think John was unfortunately quite well known for hunting famous outlaws by then; he went by the same name, he had pretty crazy exploits in Mexico and Thieves Landing. Dutch would have done some light investigating I'm sure, and John wasn't super private about the story. --- http://img836.imageshack.us/img836/6938/vyqp.jpg DIPLOMACY <cite>ShyOx posted [p:953450146] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>I think John was unfortunately quite well known for hunting famous outlaws by then; he went by the same name, he had pretty crazy exploits in Mexico and Thieves Landing. Dutch would have done some light investigating I'm sure, and John wasn't super private about the story. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
YUNASBFGIR 05/01/21 6:30:21 PM #4:	Defo thought you meant RuPaul's Drag Race for a moment. --- http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lugf8hRaTl1qfsjnx.gif http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_l59lehewLa1qavchl.gif <cite>YUNASBFGIR posted [p:953450160] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>Defo thought you meant RuPaul's Drag Race for a moment. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Tired-Insomniac 05/01/21 6:30:54 PM #5:	Were marriages publicized in newspapers back then like they are now? --- "I like turtles" <cite>Tired-Insomniac posted [p:953450179] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>Were marriages publicized in newspapers back then like they are now? </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
GameGodOfAll 05/01/21 6:31:48 PM #6:	Think it woulda been easy enough for Dutch to find out some info on his old friend John. --- My Words Were True And Sheamus Made You Believe! https://imgur.com/Fc39f <cite>GameGodOfAll posted [p:953450211] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>Think it woulda been easy enough for Dutch to find out some info on his old friend John. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Irony 05/01/21 6:32:09 PM #7:	His plan and god damn faith --- I am Mogar, God of Irony and The Devourer of Topics. <cite>Irony posted [p:953450225] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>His plan and god damn faith </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Maze_ 05/01/21 6:32:56 PM #8:	Tired-Insomniac posted... Were marriages publicized in newspapers back then like they are now? Even if they were, which I doubt. John was a wanted man. He wouldn't promote it like that --- When the going gets tough, the tough go have a little cry in the corner. "Your mustache is crooked" ~ R.I.P Randy Savage. <cite>Maze_ posted [p:953450262] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>Tired-Insomniac posted... </cite> <quote>Were marriages publicized in newspapers back then like they are now?</quote>Even if they were, which I doubt. John was a wanted man. He wouldn't promote it like that </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Tired-Insomniac 05/01/21 6:39:51 PM #9:	Maze_ posted... Even if they were, which I doubt. John was a wanted man. He wouldn't promote it like that They might have used that fake name he uses in the epilogue, and maybe hed used it in the past and Dutch recognized it or its just a plot hole lol --- "I like turtles" <cite>Tired-Insomniac posted [p:953450485] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>Maze_ posted... </cite> <quote>Even if they were, which I doubt. John was a wanted man. He wouldn't promote it like that</quote> They might have used that fake name he uses in the epilogue, and maybe hed used it in the past and Dutch recognized it or its just a plot hole lol </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Noumas 05/01/21 6:51:21 PM #10:	It makes no sense when there was no social media to post pics of the wedding or even reception <cite>Noumas posted [p:953450817] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>It makes no sense when there was no social media to post pics of the wedding or even reception </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
MysteryMan923 05/01/21 6:54:44 PM #11:	It's fiction. It's a video game. It doesn't have to make sense. We don't see everything that happens. We don't see Dutch take a shit, yet he's definitely a pooper. --- You ain't gotta like me You just mad cuz I tell it how it is and you tell it how it might be <cite>MysteryMan923 posted [p:953450928] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>It's fiction. It's a video game. It doesn't have to make sense. We don't see everything that happens. We don't see Dutch take a shit, yet he's definitely a pooper. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
g0ldie 05/01/21 6:55:42 PM #12:	iirc, like Abigail said, they were "married" already, but John wanted to make it official both legally and spiritually at the end of RDR2. at 1:09 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lDS4ZNgyrg0 --- https://imgur.com/mApEnf3 <cite>g0ldie posted [p:953450960] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>iirc, like Abigail said, they were "married" already, but John wanted to make it official both legally and spiritually at the end of RDR2. at 1:09 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lDS4ZNgyrg0 </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
GameGodOfAll 05/01/21 7:01:06 PM #13:	MysteryMan923 posted... It's fiction. It's a video game. It doesn't have to make sense. We don't see everything that happens. We don't see Dutch take a shit, yet he's definitely a pooper. Ugh. Hate this sort of take. It adds nothing to a discussion when people want to just write stuff off like that. If TC thought about it and others replied it's worth thinking about and discussing. --- My Words Were True And Sheamus Made You Believe! https://imgur.com/Fc39f <cite>GameGodOfAll posted [p:953451105] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>MysteryMan923 posted... </cite> <quote>It's fiction. It's a video game. It doesn't have to make sense. We don't see everything that happens. We don't see Dutch take a shit, yet he's definitely a pooper.</quote>Ugh. Hate this sort of take. It adds nothing to a discussion when people want to just write stuff off like that. If TC thought about it and others replied it's worth thinking about and discussing. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Funkydog 05/01/21 7:02:20 PM #14:	MysteryMan923 posted... It's fiction. It's a video game. It doesn't have to make sense. We don't see everything that happens. We don't see Dutch take a shit, yet he's definitely a pooper. You could just not post if you don't want to discuss the narrative points of something. --- https://imgur.com/BGbZK <cite>Funkydog posted [p:953451138] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>MysteryMan923 posted... </cite> <quote>It's fiction. It's a video game. It doesn't have to make sense. We don't see everything that happens. We don't see Dutch take a shit, yet he's definitely a pooper.</quote>You could just not post if you don't want to discuss the narrative points of something. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
MysteryMan923 05/01/21 7:10:05 PM #15:	Funkydog posted... You could just not post if you don't want to discuss the narrative points of something. I did discuss it. You just don't like my explanation. You could just not post if you don't like my explanation. --- You ain't gotta like me You just mad cuz I tell it how it is and you tell it how it might be <cite>MysteryMan923 posted [p:953451340] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>Funkydog posted... </cite> <quote>You could just not post if you don't want to discuss the narrative points of something.</quote> I did discuss it. You just don't like my explanation. You could just not post if you don't like my explanation. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Irony 05/01/21 7:10:47 PM #16:	MysteryMan923 posted... It's fiction. It's a video game. It doesn't have to make sense. We don't see everything that happens. We don't see Dutch take a shit, yet he's definitely a pooper. Shut the fuck up --- I am Mogar, God of Irony and The Devourer of Topics. <cite>Irony posted [p:953451360] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>MysteryMan923 posted... </cite> <quote>It's fiction. It's a video game. It doesn't have to make sense. We don't see everything that happens. We don't see Dutch take a shit, yet he's definitely a pooper.</quote>Shut the fuck up </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Funkydog 05/01/21 7:11:16 PM #17:	MysteryMan923 posted... I did discuss it. You just don't like my explanation. You could just not post if you don't like my explanation. Have a pity response. --- https://imgur.com/BGbZK <cite>Funkydog posted [p:953451376] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>MysteryMan923 posted... </cite> <quote>I did discuss it. You just don't like my explanation. You could just not post if you don't like my explanation.</quote>Have a pity response. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
MysteryMan923 05/01/21 7:16:55 PM #18:	Irony posted... Shut the fuck up No u --- You ain't gotta like me You just mad cuz I tell it how it is and you tell it how it might be <cite>MysteryMan923 posted [p:953451523] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>Irony posted... </cite> <quote>Shut the fuck up</quote> No u </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Maze_ 05/02/21 7:50:16 PM #19:	g0ldie posted... iirc, like Abigail said, they were "married" already, but John wanted to make it official both legally and spiritually at the end of RDR2. at 1:09 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lDS4ZNgyrg0 That would stll be awkward if he and Abigail broke up years ago, and Dutch didn't know that at the bank while he rants about "marrying a whore" years ago --- When the going gets tough, the tough go have a little cry in the corner. "Your mustache is crooked" ~ R.I.P Randy Savage. <cite>Maze_ posted [p:953485984] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>g0ldie posted... </cite> <quote>iirc, like Abigail said, they were "married" already, but John wanted to make it official both legally and spiritually at the end of RDR2. at 1:09 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lDS4ZNgyrg0</quote> That would stll be awkward if he and Abigail broke up years ago, and Dutch didn't know that at the bank while he rants about "marrying a whore" years ago </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Slayer_22 05/02/21 7:52:54 PM #20:	Maze_ posted... That would stll be awkward if he and Abigail broke up years ago, and Dutch didn't know that at the bank while he rants about "marrying a whore" years ago I don't think Dutch really gave a shit about awkward or looking crazy at that point lol. --- "And no I'm not signing your twitter after this type of attitude so don't ask..." - IIINCORRUPTIBLE <cite>Slayer_22 posted [p:953486053] in How did Du... [t:79436002]...</cite> <quote>Maze_ posted...</cite> <quote> That would stll be awkward if he and Abigail broke up years ago, and Dutch didn't know that at the bank while he rants about "marrying a whore" years ago </quote> I don't think Dutch really gave a shit about awkward or looking crazy at that point lol.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1

Current Events > How did Dutch know that John and Abigail were married in RDR1? (RDR1/2 spoilers) (+) Yeah! (+)

Current Events > How did Dutch know that John and Abigail were married in RDR1? (RDR1/2 spoilers)